Quality Aware Candidate Selection for Silver Truth in Cell Segmentation

Abstract Background.: Quantitative microscopy requires accurate cell masks, but cell segmentation accuracy varies across individual cells and across segmentation models. Combining candidate masks available for a cell can yield more accurate segmentations, especially when poor-quality candidates are identified and eliminated. We test whether instance-level quality ranking and selection of candidate masks improves label fusion accuracy. Methods.: We evaluate segmentation on five Cell Tracking Challenge datasets. Using reference tracking markers to collect candidate masks from competitor submissions for each cell, we extract aligned crops of the candidate masks and the underlying microscopy image. A deep quality estimator predicts the intersection over union (IoU) for each candidate, and a pairwise ranker prunes degraded masks to retain the most promising candidates. Our ENSEMBLE pipeline combines the retained candidates using learned Deep Sets weighting and a boundary-aware vote. For a controlled comparison, we also apply the established SIMPLE fusion method to the same selected candidates as well as unfiltered pools. Using a two-fold cross-validation scheme across paired video sequences, we evaluate IoU on aligned cell crops and on fully reconstructed segmentation images. Results.: The Deep Sets ENSEMBLE achieves 0.8676 mean IoU. SIMPLE with the same quality-based candidate selection achieves 0.8654, compared with 0.8431 for the descriptive best fusion baseline without candidate selection. Reconstructing Deep Sets predictions as full images yields 0.8664 cell-weighted mean IoU with zero cell loss. The small difference between ENSEMBLE and SIMPLE indicates that instance-level candidate selection produces most of the improvement. The descriptive reference formed by selecting the best individual competitor in each fold averages 0.8712. Conclusions.: Ranking and pruning candidate masks for each individual cell substantially improves label fusion when candidate quality varies. ENSEMBLE achieves the leading fusion result, while the comparable performance of Selected SIMPLE demonstrates that the primary practical gain stems from quality-aware candidate selection prior to fusion.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11515932/v1
Primary Topic
Cell Image Analysis Techniques
Type
preprint

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Quality Aware Candidate Selection for Silver Truth in Cell Segmentation

Monika Weissová, Vladimír Ulman, David Číž, João Manuel Da Silva Carias
Research Square
Cell Image Analysis Techniques
preprint

Quality Aware Candidate Selection for Silver Truth in Cell Segmentation

Monika Weissová, Vladimír Ulman, David Číž, João Manuel Da Silva Carias
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Background.: Quantitative microscopy requires accurate cell masks, but cell segmentation accuracy varies across individual cells and across segmentation models. Combining candidate masks available for a cell can yield more accurate segmentations, especially when poor-quality candidates are identified and eliminated. We test whether instance-level quality ranking and selection of candidate masks improves label fusion accuracy. Methods.: We evaluate segmentation on five Cell Tracking Challenge datasets. Using reference tracking markers to collect candidate masks from competitor submissions for each cell, we extract aligned crops of the candidate masks and the underlying microscopy image. A deep quality estimator predicts the intersection over union (IoU) for each candidate, and a pairwise ranker prunes degraded masks to retain the most promising candidates. Our ENSEMBLE pipeline combines the retained candidates using learned Deep Sets weighting and a boundary-aware vote. For a controlled comparison, we also apply the established SIMPLE fusion method to the same selected candidates as well as unfiltered pools. Using a two-fold cross-validation scheme across paired video sequences, we evaluate IoU on aligned cell crops and on fully reconstructed segmentation images. Results.: The Deep Sets ENSEMBLE achieves 0.8676 mean IoU. SIMPLE with the same quality-based candidate selection achieves 0.8654, compared with 0.8431 for the descriptive best fusion baseline without candidate selection. Reconstructing Deep Sets predictions as full images yields 0.8664 cell-weighted mean IoU with zero cell loss. The small difference between ENSEMBLE and SIMPLE indicates that instance-level candidate selection produces most of the improvement. The descriptive reference formed by selecting the best individual competitor in each fold averages 0.8712. Conclusions.: Ranking and pruning candidate masks for each individual cell substantially improves label fusion when candidate quality varies. ENSEMBLE achieves the leading fusion result, while the comparable performance of Selected SIMPLE demonstrates that the primary practical gain stems from quality-aware candidate selection prior to fusion.

Research Square
VSB - Technical University of Ostrava (CZ)
NextGenerationEU
Cell Image Analysis Techniques
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon