Seasonal-reference and regularization sensitivity with weak annual chlorophyll prediction
Do bloom-phase heatwave exposures improve annual surface-chlorophyll anomaly prediction beyond a nutrient-aware baseline? We compare two historical seasonal-reference constructions on fixed lateryear evaluation cases, outcomes and inputs. The best pooled error on the original model and penalty grid is less than 4% below zero-anomaly prediction, which predicts the calibrated seasonal-reference integral; primary conditional bands for benchmark gains include zero, with coverage unvalidated. Under fixed historical geometry, an apparent selected-procedure advantage depends on nearly tied coarse-grid tuning, while full and baseline model errors are nearly identical at penalty 1000. A retrospective one-standard-error rule selects 1000 for every pooled model under both constructions and removes the large reversal; it is not a validated remedy. Competing troughs exchange rank and move annual boundaries. Joint response and predictor substitution for ten extreme historical windows is conditionally sufficient to reproduce the penalty switch; substituting their whole complement is not. Cross-scoring shows prediction changes and target changes each reverse the tested penalty pair. With original targets fixed, both errors increase; the weaker penalty deteriorates more. Target substitution alone yields a near-zero reversal. Both constructions share a dense-grid minimum and broad near-optimal region. Report calibrated benchmarks and paired selection losses, and justify the scientific target before freezing preprocessing and selection for independent evaluation.
Authors
- Luigi Caputi (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-5724-1943)
Institutions
- San Raffaele University of Rome (IT)
Publication Details
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.31223/x5mn8k
- Primary Topic
- Marine Plankton and Biogeochemistry
- Type
- preprint