Conceptual Clarification of Plagiarism: Three Overlapping Relations
Abstract Institutional definitions of plagiarism start from a shared idea: using someone else’s work without acknowledgment is wrong. They then apply the same word to acts that do not share that structure, and the disagreements that follow are usually treated as disagreements about a single concept. They are better read as decisions about which relation has been breached. The relations overlap. Plagiarism proper is a misrepresented relation to another identifiable source. Source-use failure is a breakdown in transparent source use, and it need not be deceptive. Assessment recycling is a breach of an originality condition on the credit being awarded, and it includes a student resubmitting their own earlier work. A single submission can breach more than one of these. Copyright infringement and contract cheating sit next to the three relations without being instances of them. The argument sets four instructional accounts — a Bowdoin College conduct page, Plagiarism.org, a 2019 ThoughtCo essay, and the University of Oxford’s student guidance — against partitions already in the literature. A conduct code can keep one heading. It cannot keep one finding. The penalty has to attach to the relation that was breached.
Authors
- Lance Gentry
Institutions
- University of Mary Washington (US)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11543487/v1
- Primary Topic
- Academic integrity and plagiarism
- Type
- preprint