Examination of Energy Conservation in Relativistic Heavy Ion Collisions
This paper draws on publicly available experimental data collected over the twenty five year operation of the Relativistic Heavy Ion Collider at Brookhaven National Laboratory and formal research conclusions published by its four major collaborations. Using energy conservation as a fundamental rigid physical principle, this work systematically examines the physical consistency and observational validity of the quark gluon plasma hypothesis. The core RHIC experiments adopt a collision mode of gold nucleus on gold nucleus at 200 GeV per nucleon in the center of mass frame. Experimental measurements show that the energy of stable matter particles which can be precisely reconstructed in the mid rapidity region after collision accounts for only about four percent of the total collision energy. The remaining ninety six percent of the energy lacks a clear material destination and no complete closed itemized energy balance sheet has been published to date. Published documents from key collaborations including STAR and PHOBOS have clearly acknowledged that all current diagnostic signals for quark gluon plasma such as elliptic flow jet quenching particle yield scaling and thermal photon spectra are indirect signals obtained through model fitting. Twenty five years of experiments have never yielded direct observational evidence for free quarks or free gluons nor exclusive experimental proof for deconfinement. This paper conducts logical deduction while retaining the theoretical premises of quantum chromodynamics and the color confinement rule. The deduction reveals a fundamental physical inconsistency within the quark gluon plasma hypothesis. If quarks and gluons were real independent elementary matter particles even when confined such that they cannot escape individually, the massive populations generated at high temperature should transform into matter particles of matching magnitude or leave detectable medium traces during fireball cooling and hadronization. However experiments show neither matching yields of matter products nor residual medium signatures. The hypothetical matter components leave no detectable trace at all which seriously violates the fundamental law of energy conservation. Based on the theoretical framework of the Light Origin Theory this paper establishes a self consistent alternative physical evolution picture. The only elementary matter particles capable of long term stable existence in nature are protons and electrons. They form through gamma ray photon energy exchange energy level matching and a strong locking mechanism. Neutrons are not generated directly from photons. They form secondarily when protons capture electrons and become electrically neutral. The extreme high temperature of four trillion degrees produced in heavy ion collisions only breaks the binding system of original nucleons and releases large numbers of gamma photons with mixed energy levels. The observed jets clusters and fluid collective dynamic effects are essentially transient energy phenomena produced by high density photon interactions within a tiny space rather than a new state of matter. During fireball cooling photons continuously collide and undergo energy increase or decrease. When photon energy levels have not reached the locking threshold all collisions only produce short lived transient reaction products and cannot form stable matter structures. Only after repeated energy exchange and precise energy level matching can subsequent photon collisions trigger strong locking. This process solidifies energy into stable protons and electrons which constitute the four percent of steady state matter particles detected by experiments. The vast majority of photons never satisfy the energy requirement for locking. They finally escape as free photons or low energy radiation or deposit their energy inside detector media. This fully accounts for the large energy deficit observed experimentally. This paper concludes that the current identification of quark gluon plasma in heavy ion collision research represents a subjective interpretation guided by models instead of an objective physical fact. This work also establishes rigid observational criteria for future heavy ion collision experiments. Any conclusion claiming a new state of matter must be supported by a closed energy balance sheet and direct physical evidence. Unfounded theoretical assumptions should be rejected. If future controlled experiments can fully verify the two way transformation mechanism in which matter can dissociate into light and light can solidify into matter it will bring a revolutionary advance in human understanding of the origin of cosmic matter and reshape the foundational theoretical system of fundamental physics.
Authors
- Jiaqing Yan
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24157145
- Primary Topic
- High-Energy Particle Collisions Research
- Type
- preprint