After Net Zero: Why Holding Atmospheric CO₂ Requires Two Actuators, Bidirectional Emission Rights, and Element-Level Accounting
Net zero is defined in the Paris Agreement as a balance of flows, not a target for the atmospheric state. Earth-system simulations show that once anthropogenic CO₂ emissions cease, atmospheric CO₂ declines because sinks continue to absorb carbon. Holding any concentration therefore requires the capacity to move it in both directions, yet policy is designed to eliminate one actuator and build the other. This paper, a conceptual synthesis of Earth-system modelling, project-management science, crop physiology and the NDC record within a control-theoretic framework, treats post-net-zero atmospheric management as a bidirectional control problem. It makes five proposals: incorporate the systematic undershoot of iterative planning into climate target-setting; grow emission and removal flows in balance and control the state through their difference — removal being plannable infrastructure where reduction is fragmented negotiation — so that national gross emissions may rise when matched by verified removal; recognise that the achievable range of flows is bounded by political interests at both edges, fossil and decarbonisation industries above and CO₂-dependent agriculture below; operate emission rights in both directions, extending Article 6 with a removal exchange ratio above 1:1; and resolve inventories to the element level: carbon by pathway, oxygen as a check, methane and by-products.
Authors
- Franny Philos Sophia (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0004-7089-5265)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24148966
- Primary Topic
- Climate Change Policy and Economics
- Type
- preprint