The Cost of Marginal Measurement: Energy-Service Packages and Hidden Welfare Deprivation
Energy deprivation indicators evaluate services separately: some classify households by a single service, such as cooking fuel; others sum scores across several. Both discard the joint configuration of services, where energy deprivation combines with budget and infrastructure to shape welfare. This paper shows that grouping households by energy-service packages (for instance, the joint arrangement of cooking, heating, and hot water) preserves discarded information and yields groupings more faithful to welfare than any marginal indicator can be. We formalize this diagnostic alternative, treating welfare as achieved energy-related functionings rather than commodity inputs, and prove that no marginal scoring rule can correctly rank household configurations when services interact. Using the Chilean National Household Survey (n=72,056) and after classifying households into six energy-service package configurations, we show that although targeting cooking fuel is rational, given biomass's health risks, it is incomplete by construction. In 13% of households, clean cooking coexists with missing heating or hot water; the cooking-fuel indicator treats them as adequate, yet they are more food-insecure than the biomass cookers it prioritizes. The blind spot is not a single indicator artifact; it persists even when using the official multidimensional poverty measure, which classifies two-thirds of this group as non-poor. The pattern is built into the method, not the place: wherever services interact, every marginal rule has its blind spot, and because each is blind to a different configuration, different measures identify different poor. The information to see past it already lies in the surveys, discarded the moment services are scored apart. Working paper, version of 9 August 2026. A revised version is in preparation.
Authors
- Carlos Villalobos Barría (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3981-2909)
Institutions
- Universidad de Talca (CL)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177661
- Primary Topic
- Energy and Environment Impacts
- Type
- preprint