Atoms and critical droplets of zero-temperature Edwards–Anderson metastates

We study how ground states of the Edwards–Anderson spin glass on ℤ^d respond to a change of a single coupling. The couplings are i.i.d. with an atomless law; no moment or symmetry condition is imposed. In the first part the law also has support ℝ. Let κ_J be a periodic zero-temperature metastate: the conditional law, given the couplings J, of the ground state in a subsequential limit of the joint law of the couplings and the ground state on tori. Reading flexibilities and critical droplets through a one-bond excitation lift built from exact finite-volume identities, we prove that ground-state pairs of positive κ_J-weight carry no σ-critical edges of either of the two kinds introduced by Newman and Stein, in this metastate sense. For every edge b_0, almost surely, if the ground-state pair has positive weight, then for every value of the coupling of b_0 on the same side of its critical value, the set of edges whose critical contour contains b_0 has zero upper density along centred cubes; so has the critical contour of b_0. Consequently, if κ_J is purely atomic, almost surely no edge is σ-critical, and the hypothesis of Newman and Stein's theorem relating σ-criticality to the number of ground-state pairs, read in the same sense, forces κ_J to have no atoms. The proof attaches to each atom the asymptotic cube average of a bounded function of its flexibilities. The law of these values over the atoms is almost surely deterministic, while σ-criticality would make the value of a single atom move strictly with the coupling of b_0. In the second part we work in the excitation-metastate framework of Arguin, Damron, Newman and Stein, with an added locality property that holds for finite-volume measures, their weak limits, mixtures and translation averages. In every such metastate, finite critical droplets are connected unique minimizers, and infinite-volume forms of the comparison lemmas for flexibilities hold; these are known in substance. For weak limits of finite-volume measures in d ≥ 2, the law of the size of the critical contour is the limit of its finite-volume laws. Under full support, energy escapes to infinity with positive probability if and only if two ground states coexist across the critical contour; a one-dimensional example with a gapped law shows that it can escape although the ground-state pair is unique. In d ≥ 2, under a five-point condition on the support of |J|, a positive density of edges have single-site critical droplets.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24177686
Primary Topic
Theoretical and Computational Physics
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Atoms and critical droplets of zero-temperature Edwards–Anderson metastates

Yan Ru Pei
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Theoretical and Computational Physics
preprint

Atoms and critical droplets of zero-temperature Edwards–Anderson metastates

Yan Ru Pei
preprint en

Abstract

We study how ground states of the Edwards–Anderson spin glass on ℤ^d respond to a change of a single coupling. The couplings are i.i.d. with an atomless law; no moment or symmetry condition is imposed. In the first part the law also has support ℝ. Let κ_J be a periodic zero-temperature metastate: the conditional law, given the couplings J, of the ground state in a subsequential limit of the joint law of the couplings and the ground state on tori. Reading flexibilities and critical droplets through a one-bond excitation lift built from exact finite-volume identities, we prove that ground-state pairs of positive κ_J-weight carry no σ-critical edges of either of the two kinds introduced by Newman and Stein, in this metastate sense. For every edge b_0, almost surely, if the ground-state pair has positive weight, then for every value of the coupling of b_0 on the same side of its critical value, the set of edges whose critical contour contains b_0 has zero upper density along centred cubes; so has the critical contour of b_0. Consequently, if κ_J is purely atomic, almost surely no edge is σ-critical, and the hypothesis of Newman and Stein's theorem relating σ-criticality to the number of ground-state pairs, read in the same sense, forces κ_J to have no atoms. The proof attaches to each atom the asymptotic cube average of a bounded function of its flexibilities. The law of these values over the atoms is almost surely deterministic, while σ-criticality would make the value of a single atom move strictly with the coupling of b_0. In the second part we work in the excitation-metastate framework of Arguin, Damron, Newman and Stein, with an added locality property that holds for finite-volume measures, their weak limits, mixtures and translation averages. In every such metastate, finite critical droplets are connected unique minimizers, and infinite-volume forms of the comparison lemmas for flexibilities hold; these are known in substance. For weak limits of finite-volume measures in d ≥ 2, the law of the size of the critical contour is the limit of its finite-volume laws. Under full support, energy escapes to infinity with positive probability if and only if two ground states coexist across the critical contour; a one-dimensional example with a gapped law shows that it can escape although the ground-state pair is unique. In d ≥ 2, under a five-point condition on the support of |J|, a positive density of edges have single-site critical droplets.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Theoretical and Computational Physics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon