Unpacking Country-led and Locally Led Evaluation: Power, Ownership and Accountability in Development Evaluation and Their Implications for Evaluation Capacity Development
Evaluation capacity development (ECD) aims at strengthening the skills, systems and institutional cultures necessary to generate and use evidence for public policy. Beyond its technical dimensions, ECD carries the ambition of redistributing ownership and responsibility for evaluations and of fostering more equitable partnerships in knowledge production, particularly between Global North and Global South actors. Two concepts – country-led evaluation (CLE) and locally led evaluation (LLE) – have gained considerable traction as mechanisms for shifting evaluative ownership towards governments, institutions and the communities most directly affected by development interventions. Yet despite growing rhetorical embrace and investment, the transformative potential of CLE and LLE remains largely unrealised. An impediment is the conceptual ambiguity of both concepts. Unclear or contradictory definitions of what constitutes “local”, “national” or “country-level” create conditions for strategic appropriation, enabling actors to invoke the language of localisation while leaving underlying power hierarchies intact. This ambiguity also impedes learning, which this paper conceptualises not as knowledge transfer but as iterative, reflexive co-production – the very process through which evaluation capacity is cultivated. This discussion paper aims to address this conceptual ambiguity in evaluation theory and practice through two methodological steps: a literature review tracing the discursive evolution of CLE and LLE between 2000 and 2025, and a comparative conceptual analysis examining how power relations are differently configured across both concepts. The analysis argues that sharper conceptual distinctions between CLE and LLE are not merely academic – they are operationally consequential. Greater clarity can inform differentiated ECD strategies that advance learning-centred, contextually grounded and transformative evaluation practice, with particular relevance for strengthening evaluation systems in the Global South.
Authors
- Sven Harten
- Sabine M. Palmreuther
- Dirk Hoffmann
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24157192
- Primary Topic
- Evaluation and Performance Assessment
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00