Evaluating a peer-based visitation model as a developmental quality assurance strategy in Dutch physiotherapy practices: a mixed methods study

Abstract Background: Peer visitation is a quality improvement strategy that combines formative and summative quality indicators and is increasingly positioned as a developmental intervention that aims to reconcile accountability with learning and improvement. It is conducted by colleagues who are educated in their visitor’s role. In recent years, peer visitation is implemented in Dutch primary care physiotherapy practices. However, empirical evidence on how peer visitation is enacted in everyday practice, and under what conditions it fosters learning and improvement remains limited. Aim: To evaluate the peer visitation model of a Dutch quality registry for primary care physiotherapy practices, and to explore the improvements needed to meet its ambitions for learning and improvement. Methods: Mixed-methods study integrating four data sources: 1) visitation documents; 2) non-participant observations of six site visits; 3) semi-structured interviews with 20 stakeholders (practice owners, quality officers, observing practices and visitors); and 4) a nationwide cross-sectional survey among all stakeholders involved in peer visitation, differentiating four stakeholder roles: physiotherapist, practice owner, quality officer, and visitor. Observation notes, interview transcripts, and survey comments were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Survey data were analysed descriptively and compared across stakeholder groups. Results: Observations showed that visitation was largely delivered according to formal guidelines, but that time was predominantly devoted to process- and outcome indicators, leaving limited time for formative dialogue and sensemaking. Four visitor roles were identified—coach, analyst, connector and controller—which weredecisive for the learning potential of visitation. Interviews revealed four interrelated themes: data use between accountability and learning; quality culture and psychological safety; practice diversity and the need for differentiation; and explicit and implicit learning mechanisms. Visitation was primarily valued as a reflective learning opportunity rather than as a summative assessment. However, the combination of formative dialogue and summative judgement created tensions between ‘using data for compliance’ and using ‘data for learning and improvement’. Moreover, the results revealed the need for tailoring visitation to learning needs and practice maturity. The survey results showed substantial variation among stakeholder groups regarding the learning value of peer visitation. Across all groups, meaningful use of data for collective learning and improvement was limited. Conclusions: Peer visitation can enable learning if governance choices protect psychological safety, rebalance summative and formative elements, and provide feedback loops that demonstrate how data are used. These implementation lessons allow for the transfer to other primary care contexts seeking to shift from audit to learning.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-10922226/v1
Primary Topic
Healthcare Quality and Management
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Evaluating a peer-based visitation model as a developmental quality assurance strategy in Dutch physiotherapy practices: a mixed methods study

Marjo J. M. Maas, Henri Kiers, Michelle van 't Hag, Arie Cornelis Verburg et al.
Research Square
Healthcare Quality and Management
preprint

Evaluating a peer-based visitation model as a developmental quality assurance strategy in Dutch physiotherapy practices: a mixed methods study

Marjo J. M. Maas, Henri Kiers, Michelle van 't Hag, Arie Cornelis Verburg, Philip van der Wees
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Background: Peer visitation is a quality improvement strategy that combines formative and summative quality indicators and is increasingly positioned as a developmental intervention that aims to reconcile accountability with learning and improvement. It is conducted by colleagues who are educated in their visitor’s role. In recent years, peer visitation is implemented in Dutch primary care physiotherapy practices. However, empirical evidence on how peer visitation is enacted in everyday practice, and under what conditions it fosters learning and improvement remains limited. Aim: To evaluate the peer visitation model of a Dutch quality registry for primary care physiotherapy practices, and to explore the improvements needed to meet its ambitions for learning and improvement. Methods: Mixed-methods study integrating four data sources: 1) visitation documents; 2) non-participant observations of six site visits; 3) semi-structured interviews with 20 stakeholders (practice owners, quality officers, observing practices and visitors); and 4) a nationwide cross-sectional survey among all stakeholders involved in peer visitation, differentiating four stakeholder roles: physiotherapist, practice owner, quality officer, and visitor. Observation notes, interview transcripts, and survey comments were analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Survey data were analysed descriptively and compared across stakeholder groups. Results: Observations showed that visitation was largely delivered according to formal guidelines, but that time was predominantly devoted to process- and outcome indicators, leaving limited time for formative dialogue and sensemaking. Four visitor roles were identified—coach, analyst, connector and controller—which weredecisive for the learning potential of visitation. Interviews revealed four interrelated themes: data use between accountability and learning; quality culture and psychological safety; practice diversity and the need for differentiation; and explicit and implicit learning mechanisms. Visitation was primarily valued as a reflective learning opportunity rather than as a summative assessment. However, the combination of formative dialogue and summative judgement created tensions between ‘using data for compliance’ and using ‘data for learning and improvement’. Moreover, the results revealed the need for tailoring visitation to learning needs and practice maturity. The survey results showed substantial variation among stakeholder groups regarding the learning value of peer visitation. Across all groups, meaningful use of data for collective learning and improvement was limited. Conclusions: Peer visitation can enable learning if governance choices protect psychological safety, rebalance summative and formative elements, and provide feedback loops that demonstrate how data are used. These implementation lessons allow for the transfer to other primary care contexts seeking to shift from audit to learning.

Research Square
Radboud University Medical Center (NL)
Good health and well-being, Quality education
Healthcare Quality and Management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon