Cost-Bounded Evolving Guardrails for Chemistry Protocol Screening via Event-Pair Evidence Retrieval
Translating a published synthesis paragraph into a machine-actionable protocol is now routine, but judging whether the resulting steps are chemically safe on a given bench is not: frontier models recognise equipment at near-perfect accuracy yet fall to 0.28 accuracy on laboratory safety questions, and whole-text screening of a multi-step paragraph cannot point to which condition–effect pair justifies its verdict. We argue that risk lives at the level of event pairs, not paragraphs, and propose UHG, a cost-bounded evolving guardrail for screening heterogeneous chemistry protocols via event-pair evidence retrieval. UHG compiles text, tabular procedures, and figure captions into one event-pair space, retrieves condition–effect pairs as auditable evidence, distils a teacher’s evidence selection into a lightweight reranker, and evolves per-lab decision boundaries under a hard annotation and inference budget. On 50 catalyst-synthesis protocols with step-level risk labels, UHG reaches unsafe F1 of 0.72 at 0.13 of the cost of whole-text GPT-4o screening, outperforming Claude-3.5-Sonnet whole-text screening
Authors
- Nuoan Cheng
- Ziyang Pei (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0004-3257-7143)
- Jiarui Luo
- Xinyue Fang
- Yuchen Bai Kunming
Publication Details
- Journal
- ChemRxiv
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.26434/chemrxiv.15012079/v1
- Primary Topic
- Chemical Safety and Risk Management
- Type
- preprint