A Theory-Informed, Large Language Model-Assisted Competitive Intelligence Process for Assessing Competing Quantum Error-Correction Technologies

Emerging deep technologies create a competitive technical intelligence challenge because technical architectures, performance claims, ecosystem arrangements, and prospective markets evolve before stable adoption evidence is available. This article develops and illustrates a theory-informed, large language model (LLM)-assisted competitive intelligence (CI) process for assessing the disruptive potential of the development and commercialization of emerging quantum error-correction technologies. The process translates concepts from disruptive innovation, architectural innovation, value proposition analysis, and disruptive threat assessment into intelligence constructs, evidence questions, sequential prompt functions, source-validation criteria, and monitoring outputs. Perplexity.ai supported document discovery, organization, comparison, and preliminary synthesis; the authors evaluated sources, classified claims, and made all final interpretations. The process is illustrated through a comparative documentary analysis of Nord Quantique’s multimode bosonic quantum error-correction approach and IBM’s transmon, surface-code, and quantum low-density parity-check-oriented approach. The analysis identifies NQ as a documented architectural alternative that seeks to embed error protection within superconducting resonator modes. Its proposed reduction of error-correction overhead provides a plausible mechanism for changing system-resource requirements and deployment conditions. However, the retained evidence does not establish comparative system level advantage, lower total cost, a validated customer segment, a disruptive foothold, adoption, or incumbent displacement. The article contributes a source-disciplined and monitorable LLM-assisted CI process for emerging deep technologies. It enables analysts to distinguish documented observations, plausible mechanisms, and unverified outcomes; trace claim provenance; and identify the technical, market, ecosystem, and company signals that would justify revising an assessment. The process does not predict market winners or treat LLM output as empirical evidence.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Intelligence Studies in Business
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.37380/jisib.v16i2.3510
Primary Topic
Competitive and Knowledge Intelligence
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A Theory-Informed, Large Language Model-Assisted Competitive Intelligence Process for Assessing Competing Quantum Error-Correction Technologies

Stoyan Tanev, Nuša Fain, Jonathan Calof
Journal of Intelligence Studies in Business
Competitive and Knowledge Intelligence
article

A Theory-Informed, Large Language Model-Assisted Competitive Intelligence Process for Assessing Competing Quantum Error-Correction Technologies

Stoyan Tanev, Nuša Fain, Jonathan Calof
article en

Abstract

Emerging deep technologies create a competitive technical intelligence challenge because technical architectures, performance claims, ecosystem arrangements, and prospective markets evolve before stable adoption evidence is available. This article develops and illustrates a theory-informed, large language model (LLM)-assisted competitive intelligence (CI) process for assessing the disruptive potential of the development and commercialization of emerging quantum error-correction technologies. The process translates concepts from disruptive innovation, architectural innovation, value proposition analysis, and disruptive threat assessment into intelligence constructs, evidence questions, sequential prompt functions, source-validation criteria, and monitoring outputs. Perplexity.ai supported document discovery, organization, comparison, and preliminary synthesis; the authors evaluated sources, classified claims, and made all final interpretations. The process is illustrated through a comparative documentary analysis of Nord Quantique’s multimode bosonic quantum error-correction approach and IBM’s transmon, surface-code, and quantum low-density parity-check-oriented approach. The analysis identifies NQ as a documented architectural alternative that seeks to embed error protection within superconducting resonator modes. Its proposed reduction of error-correction overhead provides a plausible mechanism for changing system-resource requirements and deployment conditions. However, the retained evidence does not establish comparative system level advantage, lower total cost, a validated customer segment, a disruptive foothold, adoption, or incumbent displacement. The article contributes a source-disciplined and monitorable LLM-assisted CI process for emerging deep technologies. It enables analysts to distinguish documented observations, plausible mechanisms, and unverified outcomes; trace claim provenance; and identify the technical, market, ecosystem, and company signals that would justify revising an assessment. The process does not predict market winners or treat LLM output as empirical evidence.

Journal of Intelligence Studies in BusinessVol. 16(2)
University of Ottawa (CA), North-West University (ZA), Telfer School of Management (CA), Carleton University (CA)
Competitive and Knowledge Intelligence
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon