Where Does Profit Come From: An Analysis of Profit Generation and Governance Based on the General Transfer Mechanism

Mainstream economics separately employs externality theory, rent theory, and transaction cost theory to explain excess profits and market failure. However, these theories remain isolated from one another, lacking a unified micro-generation mechanism that integrates labor exploitation, ecological depletion, industrial chain risk transfer, platform rent, and financial valuation bubbles. Grounded in the ontology of critical realism and introducing the perspective of manifestation-readings analysis, this paper proposes the precondition of boundary exploitation and the core mechanism of general transfer, constructing a two-dimensional four-quadrant analytical model of time-space, cost, and price. The study finds that the vast majority of structural excess profits originate from general transfer: the complete total manifested cost of economic activity is partitioned by the readings boundary into in-field accounting costs and out-of-field liabilities, with out-of-field liabilities borne by contemporary external entities or future generations, thereby generating book surplus in-field. Out-of-field liabilities can be divided into irreversible physical-real costs and reversible relational-institutional costs, with important ontological differences between the two. Even without individual subjective malice, the system will tend toward saturated transfer driven by four dynamics: minimum impedance sliding, readings-endogenous bias, competitive screening, and collective ex-ante expectation lock-in. At the ontological level, there is no optimal solution to completely eradicate transfer; reality can only pursue constrained second-best improvement, compressing the scale of out-of-field liabilities by changing readings and changing grammar, but improvement relies on continuous regulatory exertion, and liabilities can only be compressed, never completely zeroed out. This paper also clarifies the valid boundaries of the theory as a "reading," avoiding infinite generalization of the analytical framework. Keywords: General Transfer; Boundary Exploitation; Externality; Second-Best Governance; Critical Realism; Rent Dynamics 摘要:主流经济学分别借助外部性理论、地租理论、交易成本理论解释超额利润与市场失灵,但各理论相互分立,缺少贯通劳动剥削、生态损耗、产业链风险转移、平台租金、金融估值泡沫的统一微观生成机制。本文立足于批判实在论本体论,引入显现‑读数分析视角,提出边界剥削前置条件与一般转嫁核心机制,构建时空‑代价‑成本二维四象限分析模型。研究发现:绝大多数结构性超额利润来源于一般转嫁——经济活动完整总代价被读数边界切分为场内核算代价与场外亏欠,场外亏欠交由同代场外主体或后代承担,场内由此形成账面剩余;场外亏欠可划分为不可逆的物理‑实在代价与可逆的关系‑制度成本,二者存在重要本体差异。即便不存在个体主观恶意,系统也会在最低阻抗滑行、读数内生偏向、竞争筛选、集体前期望锁死四重动力驱动下趋向饱和式转嫁。本体层面不存在彻底根除转嫁的最优方案,现实只能追求约束型次优改良,通过改读数、改语法压缩场外亏欠规模,但改良依赖持续监管做功,亏欠仅能被压缩而无法完全清零。本文同时明确理论作为“读法”的有效边界,避免分析框架的无限泛化。 关键词:一般转嫁;边界剥削;外部性;次优治理;批判实在论;地租动力学

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24165354
Primary Topic
Economic Theory and Institutions
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Where Does Profit Come From: An Analysis of Profit Generation and Governance Based on the General Transfer Mechanism

光 许
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Economic Theory and Institutions
preprint

Where Does Profit Come From: An Analysis of Profit Generation and Governance Based on the General Transfer Mechanism

光 许
preprint en

Abstract

Mainstream economics separately employs externality theory, rent theory, and transaction cost theory to explain excess profits and market failure. However, these theories remain isolated from one another, lacking a unified micro-generation mechanism that integrates labor exploitation, ecological depletion, industrial chain risk transfer, platform rent, and financial valuation bubbles. Grounded in the ontology of critical realism and introducing the perspective of manifestation-readings analysis, this paper proposes the precondition of boundary exploitation and the core mechanism of general transfer, constructing a two-dimensional four-quadrant analytical model of time-space, cost, and price. The study finds that the vast majority of structural excess profits originate from general transfer: the complete total manifested cost of economic activity is partitioned by the readings boundary into in-field accounting costs and out-of-field liabilities, with out-of-field liabilities borne by contemporary external entities or future generations, thereby generating book surplus in-field. Out-of-field liabilities can be divided into irreversible physical-real costs and reversible relational-institutional costs, with important ontological differences between the two. Even without individual subjective malice, the system will tend toward saturated transfer driven by four dynamics: minimum impedance sliding, readings-endogenous bias, competitive screening, and collective ex-ante expectation lock-in. At the ontological level, there is no optimal solution to completely eradicate transfer; reality can only pursue constrained second-best improvement, compressing the scale of out-of-field liabilities by changing readings and changing grammar, but improvement relies on continuous regulatory exertion, and liabilities can only be compressed, never completely zeroed out. This paper also clarifies the valid boundaries of the theory as a "reading," avoiding infinite generalization of the analytical framework. Keywords: General Transfer; Boundary Exploitation; Externality; Second-Best Governance; Critical Realism; Rent Dynamics 摘要:主流经济学分别借助外部性理论、地租理论、交易成本理论解释超额利润与市场失灵,但各理论相互分立,缺少贯通劳动剥削、生态损耗、产业链风险转移、平台租金、金融估值泡沫的统一微观生成机制。本文立足于批判实在论本体论,引入显现‑读数分析视角,提出边界剥削前置条件与一般转嫁核心机制,构建时空‑代价‑成本二维四象限分析模型。研究发现:绝大多数结构性超额利润来源于一般转嫁——经济活动完整总代价被读数边界切分为场内核算代价与场外亏欠,场外亏欠交由同代场外主体或后代承担,场内由此形成账面剩余;场外亏欠可划分为不可逆的物理‑实在代价与可逆的关系‑制度成本,二者存在重要本体差异。即便不存在个体主观恶意,系统也会在最低阻抗滑行、读数内生偏向、竞争筛选、集体前期望锁死四重动力驱动下趋向饱和式转嫁。本体层面不存在彻底根除转嫁的最优方案,现实只能追求约束型次优改良,通过改读数、改语法压缩场外亏欠规模,但改良依赖持续监管做功,亏欠仅能被压缩而无法完全清零。本文同时明确理论作为“读法”的有效边界,避免分析框架的无限泛化。 关键词:一般转嫁;边界剥削;外部性;次优治理;批判实在论;地租动力学

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Economic Theory and Institutions
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon