Pricing the Receipt, Not the Invention: Why Royalties Misread the Value of Public Technology

Abstract Royalty income is the standard measure of technology-transfer performance, on the presumption that licence prices reflect technological value. We find that, in public R&D, they largely reflect the rules. Innovation research holds that the value of R&D collaboration depends on the technology field, but this evidence comes from knowledge creation, not from the pricing of public technology. We distinguish two tiers of the transfer stage, contract design (how a licence is paid) and price formation (how much is paid), and propose institutional price anchoring: prices attach to the inputs that fee rules make salient rather than to the technology. Korean administrative records spanning a governance reform allow a comparative test: 2,252 licensing contracts executed under the Joint Regulations and 18,534 university and institute participations in 2024 consortia formed under the 2021 National R&D Innovation Act. We report three findings. First, field differences do not reach price; they relocate into contract design, with biotechnology licences 20 percentage points more likely to be sales-linked. Second, the government contribution named in fee rules is priced where formulas require it, never where price follows sales, and in negotiated deals only when government research institutes sell, a pattern a value-proxy account cannot explain. Third, after the reform, programme design explains 52% of the variance in commercialization-role assignment and organizational type 0.2%. Public technology is priced on its receipt, not its invention. Royalty income therefore mixes rule-driven and value-driven revenue, and reforms of fee rules change what transfer metrics measure before they change what transfer achieves. JEL classification: O32; O34; O38; L24; D86

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11403739/v1
Primary Topic
Intellectual Property and Patents
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Pricing the Receipt, Not the Invention: Why Royalties Misread the Value of Public Technology

Junghee Han
Research Square
Intellectual Property and Patents
preprint

Pricing the Receipt, Not the Invention: Why Royalties Misread the Value of Public Technology

Junghee Han
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Royalty income is the standard measure of technology-transfer performance, on the presumption that licence prices reflect technological value. We find that, in public R&D, they largely reflect the rules. Innovation research holds that the value of R&D collaboration depends on the technology field, but this evidence comes from knowledge creation, not from the pricing of public technology. We distinguish two tiers of the transfer stage, contract design (how a licence is paid) and price formation (how much is paid), and propose institutional price anchoring: prices attach to the inputs that fee rules make salient rather than to the technology. Korean administrative records spanning a governance reform allow a comparative test: 2,252 licensing contracts executed under the Joint Regulations and 18,534 university and institute participations in 2024 consortia formed under the 2021 National R&D Innovation Act. We report three findings. First, field differences do not reach price; they relocate into contract design, with biotechnology licences 20 percentage points more likely to be sales-linked. Second, the government contribution named in fee rules is priced where formulas require it, never where price follows sales, and in negotiated deals only when government research institutes sell, a pattern a value-proxy account cannot explain. Third, after the reform, programme design explains 52% of the variance in commercialization-role assignment and organizational type 0.2%. Public technology is priced on its receipt, not its invention. Royalty income therefore mixes rule-driven and value-driven revenue, and reforms of fee rules change what transfer metrics measure before they change what transfer achieves. JEL classification: O32; O34; O38; L24; D86

Research Square
Hongik University (KR)
Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Intellectual Property and Patents
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon