Neo Mencianism:A Complete Philosophical Analysis

Abstract This study presents Neo-Mencianism (新孟儒学) as a comprehensive political philosophical framework that reinterprets modern political economy, distributive justice, and world history through the institutional principle of Tonggong Yishi (通功易事). The framework distinguishes two fundamentally different forms of inequality: natural differentiation (自然分化), arising from differences in talent, effort, and market scarcity, and secondary differentiation (二次分化), arising from the institutional asymmetry of the employment contract. It argues that modern market economies should preserve the former while eliminating the latter by replacing the exchange of labour-power (Yili, 易力) with the exchange of labour accomplishments (Yishi, 易事), thereby transforming employer–employee relations into cooperative partnerships without abolishing markets or private capital. The study further situates Neo-Mencianism in dialogue with major traditions of Western philosophy. It argues that the framework preserves Hayek’s insight into dispersed knowledge and market coordination while rejecting the employment contract as the natural boundary condition of market order; accepts Marx’s diagnosis of wage exploitation while rejecting the Labour Theory of Value; extends Kant’s Formula of Humanity into the institutional sphere of production; and reconciles Strauss’s doctrine of natural right with modern productive justice. At the metaphysical level, it advances the thesis that Marx’s distinction between abstract and concrete labour reproduces Plato’s priority of universals over particulars, identifying this inheritance as the philosophical root of twentieth century failures of centrally planned socialism. Finally, the paper proposes a Confucian philosophy of history centred on the transition from the exchange of persons (易人), through the exchange of labour power (易力), to the exchange of labour accomplishments (易事). Within this historical framework, Mao’s later political philosophy is interpreted as a return to the Confucian tripartite tradition, Deng Xiaoping’s reforms as a practical correction of Marx’s metaphysical error through the restoration of concrete market activity, and Neo-Mencianism as the completion of that trajectory through the institutional specification of cooperative productive justice. The study argues that Neo-Mencianism offers a systematic synthesis of Confucian ethics, modern economics, and Western political philosophy, proposing a market-based institutional alternative that seeks to preserve efficiency while eliminating structural exploitation.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-10450718/v1
Primary Topic
Political Philosophy and Ethics
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Neo Mencianism:A Complete Philosophical Analysis

灵山
Research Square
Political Philosophy and Ethics
preprint

Neo Mencianism:A Complete Philosophical Analysis

灵山
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract This study presents Neo-Mencianism (新孟儒学) as a comprehensive political philosophical framework that reinterprets modern political economy, distributive justice, and world history through the institutional principle of Tonggong Yishi (通功易事). The framework distinguishes two fundamentally different forms of inequality: natural differentiation (自然分化), arising from differences in talent, effort, and market scarcity, and secondary differentiation (二次分化), arising from the institutional asymmetry of the employment contract. It argues that modern market economies should preserve the former while eliminating the latter by replacing the exchange of labour-power (Yili, 易力) with the exchange of labour accomplishments (Yishi, 易事), thereby transforming employer–employee relations into cooperative partnerships without abolishing markets or private capital. The study further situates Neo-Mencianism in dialogue with major traditions of Western philosophy. It argues that the framework preserves Hayek’s insight into dispersed knowledge and market coordination while rejecting the employment contract as the natural boundary condition of market order; accepts Marx’s diagnosis of wage exploitation while rejecting the Labour Theory of Value; extends Kant’s Formula of Humanity into the institutional sphere of production; and reconciles Strauss’s doctrine of natural right with modern productive justice. At the metaphysical level, it advances the thesis that Marx’s distinction between abstract and concrete labour reproduces Plato’s priority of universals over particulars, identifying this inheritance as the philosophical root of twentieth century failures of centrally planned socialism. Finally, the paper proposes a Confucian philosophy of history centred on the transition from the exchange of persons (易人), through the exchange of labour power (易力), to the exchange of labour accomplishments (易事). Within this historical framework, Mao’s later political philosophy is interpreted as a return to the Confucian tripartite tradition, Deng Xiaoping’s reforms as a practical correction of Marx’s metaphysical error through the restoration of concrete market activity, and Neo-Mencianism as the completion of that trajectory through the institutional specification of cooperative productive justice. The study argues that Neo-Mencianism offers a systematic synthesis of Confucian ethics, modern economics, and Western political philosophy, proposing a market-based institutional alternative that seeks to preserve efficiency while eliminating structural exploitation.

Research Square
Political Philosophy and Ethics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon