Virtual sensors from networks of small formulas: eight registered tests of NAI-fnet
Machines often need a quantity they cannot measure where it matters, such as the torque in a robot joint or the temperature of a rotor, and estimate it on their own microcontroller from the signals they already have. NAI-fnet builds such virtual sensors as networks of small formulas exported as dependency-free C. Its method is not disclosed; this preprint reports eight registered tests of it as a black box, each with five hypotheses written down before the single run on the test data. On four devices with real data, NAI-fnet as released in NAI v26 was compared with tuned LightGBM and an MLP 32×32. Elbow torque of a Franka Emika Panda arm: 0.062 % nMSE against 0.060 % for tuned LightGBM and 0.090 % for the dataset authors' Gaussian process, with C code 17 times smaller and 45 times faster than LightGBM's; rotor magnet temperature of a traction motor: 1.76 K² against 6.62 for tuned LightGBM and 3.12 for the MLP; power of five wind turbines: 2.26 % NRMSE against 2.14 % for tuned LightGBM and 2.95 % for the IEC power curve; drag of an airliner beyond the measured Mach numbers: 27.8 drag counts against 42.8 for tuned LightGBM and 205.8 for a look-up table. The 95 % bootstrap intervals of these error ratios all exclude 1. On four suites of 40 open engineering tables, NAI-fnet extrapolated beyond the training data about as well as tuned boosting (geometric mean error ratio 0.92, interval 0.79 to 1.06) and was less accurate inside the data. In all, 32 of the 40 hypotheses held; the eight that failed are reported with the rest. The registrations of the four device tests, their manifests, harness scripts and the outputs of the registered runs: https://github.com/mindscanlabs/NAI-track-record/tree/main/formula-network. Interactive simulators of the device examples: https://naiscience.com/fnet.html
Authors
- Smirnov Mikhail
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24163945
- Primary Topic
- Sensor Technology and Measurement Systems
- Type
- preprint