Language Limits and Existential Realization: The Constitutive Surplus of Pre-linguistic Experience and Its Non-propositional Paths

In the reception history of developmental and evolutionary linguistics, "pre-linguistic" is situated in the past, and adults' ineffable experiences are retroactively interpreted as early remnants, accompanied by a normative ideal of "adequate articulation." This paper argues that the popular presupposition of this ideal—that experience can be fully encoded—does not hold: propositionalization is a selective abstraction, and every abstraction simultaneously produces content it cannot accommodate. This paper terms this layer "constitutive surplus" and divides it into givenness (the condition of propositionalization, which cannot be realized but only acknowledged) and concrete surplus (the omission of each abstraction, which can be taken up and actualized). The surplus is not a blind spot awaiting illumination, but the very condition for the emergence of new meaning. After conceptualization reaches its limits, concrete surplus is realized through two paths that do not rely on propositional information as a medium: bodily co-presence opens up situations intersubjectively, and decisive action changes the position of the surplus through irreversible consequences. Realization does not eliminate the surplus; it only changes the subject's relationship to it, and is a local, reversible respite. The revealing efficacy of action must be separated from moral legitimacy. In this paper, "pre-linguistic" always refers to what is logically prior to propositionalization, i.e., pre-propositional experience, not what is temporally prior to language acquisition. Keywords: Pre-linguistic Experience; Constitutive Surplus; Non-propositional; Bodily Intersubjectivity; Decisive Action 摘要:在发展与演化语言学的接受史中,“前语言”被安放在过去,成人难以言说的体验被回溯为早期遗留,并配套一种“充分言说”的规范理想。本文主张该理想的通俗预设——体验可被完整编码——并不成立:命题化是选择性抽象,每一次抽象同步生产出它无法收纳的内容。本文把这一层次称为构成性剩余,并拆为给予性(命题化的条件,不可兑现,只能被承认)与具体剩余(每次抽象的遗漏,可被承接、可被现实化)。剩余不是待照亮的盲区,而是新意义得以生发的条件。概念化抵达界限后,具体剩余经两条不以命题信息为中介的路径兑现:肉身共在使处境在主体间相互敞开,决断行动以不可撤销的后果改变剩余的位置。兑现不消除剩余,只改变主体与剩余的关系,且是局部、可逆的暂歇。行动的揭示效力须与道德正当性分离。本文所谓“前语言”,一律指逻辑上先于命题化,即前命题经验,不指时间上先于语言习得。 关键词:前语言经验;构成性剩余;非命题性;肉身间性;决断行动

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24164491
Primary Topic
Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Language Limits and Existential Realization: The Constitutive Surplus of Pre-linguistic Experience and Its Non-propositional Paths

光 许
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy
preprint

Language Limits and Existential Realization: The Constitutive Surplus of Pre-linguistic Experience and Its Non-propositional Paths

光 许
preprint en

Abstract

In the reception history of developmental and evolutionary linguistics, "pre-linguistic" is situated in the past, and adults' ineffable experiences are retroactively interpreted as early remnants, accompanied by a normative ideal of "adequate articulation." This paper argues that the popular presupposition of this ideal—that experience can be fully encoded—does not hold: propositionalization is a selective abstraction, and every abstraction simultaneously produces content it cannot accommodate. This paper terms this layer "constitutive surplus" and divides it into givenness (the condition of propositionalization, which cannot be realized but only acknowledged) and concrete surplus (the omission of each abstraction, which can be taken up and actualized). The surplus is not a blind spot awaiting illumination, but the very condition for the emergence of new meaning. After conceptualization reaches its limits, concrete surplus is realized through two paths that do not rely on propositional information as a medium: bodily co-presence opens up situations intersubjectively, and decisive action changes the position of the surplus through irreversible consequences. Realization does not eliminate the surplus; it only changes the subject's relationship to it, and is a local, reversible respite. The revealing efficacy of action must be separated from moral legitimacy. In this paper, "pre-linguistic" always refers to what is logically prior to propositionalization, i.e., pre-propositional experience, not what is temporally prior to language acquisition. Keywords: Pre-linguistic Experience; Constitutive Surplus; Non-propositional; Bodily Intersubjectivity; Decisive Action 摘要:在发展与演化语言学的接受史中,“前语言”被安放在过去,成人难以言说的体验被回溯为早期遗留,并配套一种“充分言说”的规范理想。本文主张该理想的通俗预设——体验可被完整编码——并不成立:命题化是选择性抽象,每一次抽象同步生产出它无法收纳的内容。本文把这一层次称为构成性剩余,并拆为给予性(命题化的条件,不可兑现,只能被承认)与具体剩余(每次抽象的遗漏,可被承接、可被现实化)。剩余不是待照亮的盲区,而是新意义得以生发的条件。概念化抵达界限后,具体剩余经两条不以命题信息为中介的路径兑现:肉身共在使处境在主体间相互敞开,决断行动以不可撤销的后果改变剩余的位置。兑现不消除剩余,只改变主体与剩余的关系,且是局部、可逆的暂歇。行动的揭示效力须与道德正当性分离。本文所谓“前语言”,一律指逻辑上先于命题化,即前命题经验,不指时间上先于语言习得。 关键词:前语言经验;构成性剩余;非命题性;肉身间性;决断行动

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Phenomenology and Existential Philosophy
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon