Calibration, domain, and a classification discontinuity in the Vierendeel provisions of BS EN 1993-1-13:2024
BS EN 1993-1-13:2024 gives two methods for Vierendeel bending at a circular web opening — a four-hinge equivalent-opening mechanism (cl. 8.4) and a section check on inclined planes through the Tee (cl. 8.9) — with no rule for choosing between them. Both were implemented independently and validated against Warren’s tests: on five plastic Vierendeel failures, the mean predicted-to-measured ratio is 0.951 for cl. 8.4 and 0.832 for cl. 8.9; every prediction is conservative. Against GMNIA collapse loads on a ladder on which the mechanism governs, cl. 8.4 worked in full holds a margin of about 7% over the upper half of the manufactured range, while cl. 8.9’s falls at least about three times as fast, to 12%. Under uniform load at h0/tw = 54, no specimen reached a Vierendeel mechanism at any depth examined: the end regions became unstable first, and their margin against that instability narrowed from 1.74 to 1.15 times the collapse load as the Tee deepened. Utilisations cannot be compared between the routes: cl. 8.4 is convex in load and Formula (8.49) linear, so routes of equal capacity report utilisations up to 2.7 times apart. Cl. 8.9(7) cites only the Class 2 sub-clauses 7.5(5) and (6), withholding the reclassification of 7.5(7) and 7.5(10) from the radial route. Its capacity then falls 7.5% for one millimetre of additional depth. Adding the cross-references leaves a 2.1% step; extending EN 1993-1-1 Annex B to Tee outstands removes it.
Authors
- Cemil Ozmert (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-2321-7876)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-12
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24060003
- Primary Topic
- Structural Load-Bearing Analysis
- Type
- preprint