One Degree of Freedom Moves the Frontier, the Other Four Do Not: A Preregistered Factorization of an Active-Dendrite Repair, Its Architecture-Bound Supply, and Five Failed Escapes

This record (version 1) deposits the manuscript and the complete reproduction package for a preregistered factorization of an active-dendrite continual-learning repair into its protection-budget degrees of freedom. Across 1,213 newly collected training runs plus 60 reused controls, five preregistered escapes were tested and four failed: the strength of the protection, its temporal decay schedule, a forward-pass-only intervention, and the context pathway leave the frontier unchanged (R1: 24 Holm-corrected cells, minimum p = 0.585). The one degree of freedom that works -- reallocating a fixed total anchor budget toward recent tasks under exact weight conservation -- moves the Pareto frontier on its home MLP architecture (T=20: +8.08 accuracy over the un-repaired baseline while improving retention over the repair itself, Holm p = 6.4e-5, four preregistered criteria met in full), with direction specificity confirmed by a preregistered reverse-weighting arm (worse on retention in all 20/20 paired seeds, |d_z| = 4.0). The supply of this freedom is architecture-bound: on a calibrated ResNet-18+GN backbone the same reallocation reaches neither of the preregistered verdict levels, after a first-round apparent transfer (+1.94, Holm p = 0.041 at n = 10) was overturned by the preregistered sample-extension clause (n = 20: +0.72, p = 0.34) -- a flip reported in full in the main text. On a convolutional backbone, a preregistered lambda sweep (six points, 240 runs) shows that the companion audit's non-transfer was partly a single-point artifact on the deepest trough of a non-monotonic dose curve, while the recalibrated effect remains an order of magnitude below its MLP value. Every experiment ran under a written preregistration with implementation-correctness gates whose failure voids the data; six gates fired across the program and none was resolved by relaxing a criterion; all six are tabulated in the paper. Two independent machine-checkable verifiers are included and run from the package root with the standard library alone: r_repro/verify_package.py (25 checks) recomputes every headline statistic from the raw per-run records, and paper/check_paper_numbers.py (17 checks) additionally re-derives the seed-direction counts, per-dataset splits, figure-caption numbers, every protocol-table constant, and the 1,213-run ledger, asserting agreement with the manuscript text. The package contains the LaTeX source and compiled PDF, the figure-generation script and all figures, the twelve local modules used by the R1-R3 runners, the raw per-run JSON records of all five experiments (results_r1, results_r2, results_r2t, results_r3, and the reused audit controls results_e9), and the preregistrations with dated amendments and collection reports. Code and records are also archived in the project repository linked under related identifiers.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24148620
Primary Topic
Domain Adaptation and Few-Shot Learning
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

One Degree of Freedom Moves the Frontier, the Other Four Do Not: A Preregistered Factorization of an Active-Dendrite Repair, Its Architecture-Bound Supply, and Five Failed Escapes

Ranxi Zhou
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Domain Adaptation and Few-Shot Learning
preprint

One Degree of Freedom Moves the Frontier, the Other Four Do Not: A Preregistered Factorization of an Active-Dendrite Repair, Its Architecture-Bound Supply, and Five Failed Escapes

Ranxi Zhou
preprint en

Abstract

This record (version 1) deposits the manuscript and the complete reproduction package for a preregistered factorization of an active-dendrite continual-learning repair into its protection-budget degrees of freedom. Across 1,213 newly collected training runs plus 60 reused controls, five preregistered escapes were tested and four failed: the strength of the protection, its temporal decay schedule, a forward-pass-only intervention, and the context pathway leave the frontier unchanged (R1: 24 Holm-corrected cells, minimum p = 0.585). The one degree of freedom that works -- reallocating a fixed total anchor budget toward recent tasks under exact weight conservation -- moves the Pareto frontier on its home MLP architecture (T=20: +8.08 accuracy over the un-repaired baseline while improving retention over the repair itself, Holm p = 6.4e-5, four preregistered criteria met in full), with direction specificity confirmed by a preregistered reverse-weighting arm (worse on retention in all 20/20 paired seeds, |d_z| = 4.0). The supply of this freedom is architecture-bound: on a calibrated ResNet-18+GN backbone the same reallocation reaches neither of the preregistered verdict levels, after a first-round apparent transfer (+1.94, Holm p = 0.041 at n = 10) was overturned by the preregistered sample-extension clause (n = 20: +0.72, p = 0.34) -- a flip reported in full in the main text. On a convolutional backbone, a preregistered lambda sweep (six points, 240 runs) shows that the companion audit's non-transfer was partly a single-point artifact on the deepest trough of a non-monotonic dose curve, while the recalibrated effect remains an order of magnitude below its MLP value. Every experiment ran under a written preregistration with implementation-correctness gates whose failure voids the data; six gates fired across the program and none was resolved by relaxing a criterion; all six are tabulated in the paper. Two independent machine-checkable verifiers are included and run from the package root with the standard library alone: r_repro/verify_package.py (25 checks) recomputes every headline statistic from the raw per-run records, and paper/check_paper_numbers.py (17 checks) additionally re-derives the seed-direction counts, per-dataset splits, figure-caption numbers, every protocol-table constant, and the 1,213-run ledger, asserting agreement with the manuscript text. The package contains the LaTeX source and compiled PDF, the figure-generation script and all figures, the twelve local modules used by the R1-R3 runners, the raw per-run JSON records of all five experiments (results_r1, results_r2, results_r2t, results_r3, and the reused audit controls results_e9), and the preregistrations with dated amendments and collection reports. Code and records are also archived in the project repository linked under related identifiers.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Domain Adaptation and Few-Shot Learning
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon