Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such: A Tholonic Structure for the Jungian Model of the Psyche

Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such: A Tholonic Structure for the Jungian Model of the Psyche Jung's model of the psyche is rich in observation and thin in structure. His archetypal figures (persona, shadow, anima and animus, Self) form a catalogue, and the catalogue does not say why these figures exist, how they relate, or why it holds the members it does. This paper tests whether the tholonic N-D-C model supplies that missing structure. The model has 3 roles: Negotiation (N, the emergent state), Definition (D, the bounding and excluding role), and Contribution (C, the flowing and integrating role). Its working hypothesis is that these roles describe the level Jung called the archetype-as-such, the form he held to be irrepresentable in itself, while the familiar figures are the images that fill the roles. Following the calibration method of earlier papers in the series, 7 criteria were fixed before any mapping was scored, and 4 candidate role assignments were scored against them. The intuitive assignment (Self as N) is rejected in writing: an OWL-DL reasoner (HermiT and Pellet, in agreement) finds it inconsistent with Jung's statement that the Self is "an a priori existent out of which the ego evolves", and an ablation shows that this statement alone causes the failure. The adopted assignment reads the psyche at 2 scales. At the scale of process, the directed conscious attitude is D, the compensating unconscious is C, and the ego, renewed by the transcendent function, is the child state N′. At the scale of image, the persona is the image of D, the anima or animus is the image of the C channel, the shadow is what D excludes, and the Self occupies the parent position as origin; the closing that Jung's own Axiom of Maria describes, read here as the whole psyche actually present in one instance, is what Jung called the Self as goal. This assignment is consistent with Jung's commitments and classifies all 7 pathological states Jung names as D-dominant or C-dominant. A deliberately swapped control is inconsistent, because Jung's own remedies for the states then contradict the model's remedy rule. Inflation, which Jung treats as one condition, splits into 2 structurally opposite classes, and Jung prescribes opposite remedies for them. The paper's main prediction concerns enantiodromia, the reversal of a one-sided attitude into its opposite. Modeled as a cusp bifurcation in the D/C imbalance, reversal with hysteresis occurs only on the D-dominant side; an equally unbalanced C-dominant psyche drifts gradually and reversibly, even though the balance score is the same. Jump size grows with rigidity as √(3r), which matches Jung's statement that the counter-position strengthens with one-sidedness. Rising autocorrelation precedes the flip, but it also precedes the gradual C-side transition, so it is not by itself a specific warning sign. No threshold value is derived; the 61.8 convention is not supported as a psychic threshold. The quaternity problem is resolved as 2 role classes (the rational and irrational functions) times 2 poles, with Jung's 3 + 1 read as the model's out-of-plane fourth point. The paper gives structure to Jung's model. It does not validate that model. Version 1.2. Preprint; not peer reviewed. First paper of a 3-paper series on Jung and the psyche (followed by The Tholonic Psyche in Jung's Language and A Tholonic Psychology of the Individual).

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-12
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24151111
Primary Topic
Jungian Analytical Psychology
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such: A Tholonic Structure for the Jungian Model of the Psyche

Jeffrey Milton
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Jungian Analytical Psychology
preprint

Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such: A Tholonic Structure for the Jungian Model of the Psyche

Jeffrey Milton
preprint en

Abstract

Giving Form to the Archetype-as-Such: A Tholonic Structure for the Jungian Model of the Psyche Jung's model of the psyche is rich in observation and thin in structure. His archetypal figures (persona, shadow, anima and animus, Self) form a catalogue, and the catalogue does not say why these figures exist, how they relate, or why it holds the members it does. This paper tests whether the tholonic N-D-C model supplies that missing structure. The model has 3 roles: Negotiation (N, the emergent state), Definition (D, the bounding and excluding role), and Contribution (C, the flowing and integrating role). Its working hypothesis is that these roles describe the level Jung called the archetype-as-such, the form he held to be irrepresentable in itself, while the familiar figures are the images that fill the roles. Following the calibration method of earlier papers in the series, 7 criteria were fixed before any mapping was scored, and 4 candidate role assignments were scored against them. The intuitive assignment (Self as N) is rejected in writing: an OWL-DL reasoner (HermiT and Pellet, in agreement) finds it inconsistent with Jung's statement that the Self is "an a priori existent out of which the ego evolves", and an ablation shows that this statement alone causes the failure. The adopted assignment reads the psyche at 2 scales. At the scale of process, the directed conscious attitude is D, the compensating unconscious is C, and the ego, renewed by the transcendent function, is the child state N′. At the scale of image, the persona is the image of D, the anima or animus is the image of the C channel, the shadow is what D excludes, and the Self occupies the parent position as origin; the closing that Jung's own Axiom of Maria describes, read here as the whole psyche actually present in one instance, is what Jung called the Self as goal. This assignment is consistent with Jung's commitments and classifies all 7 pathological states Jung names as D-dominant or C-dominant. A deliberately swapped control is inconsistent, because Jung's own remedies for the states then contradict the model's remedy rule. Inflation, which Jung treats as one condition, splits into 2 structurally opposite classes, and Jung prescribes opposite remedies for them. The paper's main prediction concerns enantiodromia, the reversal of a one-sided attitude into its opposite. Modeled as a cusp bifurcation in the D/C imbalance, reversal with hysteresis occurs only on the D-dominant side; an equally unbalanced C-dominant psyche drifts gradually and reversibly, even though the balance score is the same. Jump size grows with rigidity as √(3r), which matches Jung's statement that the counter-position strengthens with one-sidedness. Rising autocorrelation precedes the flip, but it also precedes the gradual C-side transition, so it is not by itself a specific warning sign. No threshold value is derived; the 61.8 convention is not supported as a psychic threshold. The quaternity problem is resolved as 2 role classes (the rational and irrational functions) times 2 poles, with Jung's 3 + 1 read as the model's out-of-plane fourth point. The paper gives structure to Jung's model. It does not validate that model. Version 1.2. Preprint; not peer reviewed. First paper of a 3-paper series on Jung and the psyche (followed by The Tholonic Psyche in Jung's Language and A Tholonic Psychology of the Individual).

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Jungian Analytical Psychology
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon