A Systemic Network Approach to Identifying Core Failure Drivers and Propagation Characteristics in AI‐Driven Higher Education Transformation Processes: Integrating Improved K‐Shell and SEIR Models

ABSTRACT AI is rapidly reshaping higher education systems, introducing both transformative opportunities and complex systemic risks that challenge traditional governance approaches. This study investigates the mechanisms underlying documented AI‐related failure incidents in higher education transformation from a systemic and network‐oriented perspective. Higher education is conceptualized as a complex socio‐technical system, where failures emerge from cross‐layer interactions among model, human, organizational and institutional dimensions rather than isolated factors. To capture both structural interdependencies and dynamic propagation processes, a structure–dynamics coupling framework is developed by integrating an improved K‐shell decomposition method with a susceptible–exposed–infected–recovered (SEIR) model. Based on 63 publicly documented AI‐related failure incidents collected from established AI incident databases, a directed weighted network of failure drivers is constructed. The improved K‐shell method incorporates node heterogeneity and edge weights to identify structurally critical nodes, while the SEIR model simulates the temporal evolution of risk propagation through heterogeneous transmission and recovery mechanisms. The results reveal a pronounced core–periphery structure, where a small number of nodes dominate systemic risk diffusion. Model‐related and human‐related factors are identified as high‐impact ‘super‐spreaders’, whereas organizational and institutional factors primarily function as structural enablers shaping propagation pathways. The importance–propagability matrix further uncovers nonlinear threshold effects, indicating that small changes in key nodes can trigger large‐scale systemic risks. From a system‐of‐systems perspective, the findings demonstrate that AI‐driven failures are emergent outcomes of recursive cross‐layer feedback loops. Based on this, the study proposes model‐informed governance strategies, including targeted intervention on high‐risk nodes, enhancement of AI literacy, strengthening of organizational buffering mechanisms and threshold‐based early warning systems. This research advances a systemic analytical framework integrating complex network analysis and diffusion modelling, providing both theoretical insights and practical guidance for improving the resilience and governance of AI‐enabled higher education systems.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Systems Research and Behavioral Science
Published
2026-11-10
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1002/sres.70185
Primary Topic
Artificial Intelligence in Education
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A Systemic Network Approach to Identifying Core Failure Drivers and Propagation Characteristics in AI‐Driven Higher Education Transformation Processes: Integrating Improved K‐Shell and SEIR Models

赵晓英, Jun Shen, Xin Dong, Dingwen Zhang et al.
Systems Research and Behavioral Science
Artificial Intelligence in Education
article

A Systemic Network Approach to Identifying Core Failure Drivers and Propagation Characteristics in AI‐Driven Higher Education Transformation Processes: Integrating Improved K‐Shell and SEIR Models

赵晓英, Jun Shen, Xin Dong, Dingwen Zhang, Fengyang Xu, Zhuolun Wang
article en

Abstract

ABSTRACT AI is rapidly reshaping higher education systems, introducing both transformative opportunities and complex systemic risks that challenge traditional governance approaches. This study investigates the mechanisms underlying documented AI‐related failure incidents in higher education transformation from a systemic and network‐oriented perspective. Higher education is conceptualized as a complex socio‐technical system, where failures emerge from cross‐layer interactions among model, human, organizational and institutional dimensions rather than isolated factors. To capture both structural interdependencies and dynamic propagation processes, a structure–dynamics coupling framework is developed by integrating an improved K‐shell decomposition method with a susceptible–exposed–infected–recovered (SEIR) model. Based on 63 publicly documented AI‐related failure incidents collected from established AI incident databases, a directed weighted network of failure drivers is constructed. The improved K‐shell method incorporates node heterogeneity and edge weights to identify structurally critical nodes, while the SEIR model simulates the temporal evolution of risk propagation through heterogeneous transmission and recovery mechanisms. The results reveal a pronounced core–periphery structure, where a small number of nodes dominate systemic risk diffusion. Model‐related and human‐related factors are identified as high‐impact ‘super‐spreaders’, whereas organizational and institutional factors primarily function as structural enablers shaping propagation pathways. The importance–propagability matrix further uncovers nonlinear threshold effects, indicating that small changes in key nodes can trigger large‐scale systemic risks. From a system‐of‐systems perspective, the findings demonstrate that AI‐driven failures are emergent outcomes of recursive cross‐layer feedback loops. Based on this, the study proposes model‐informed governance strategies, including targeted intervention on high‐risk nodes, enhancement of AI literacy, strengthening of organizational buffering mechanisms and threshold‐based early warning systems. This research advances a systemic analytical framework integrating complex network analysis and diffusion modelling, providing both theoretical insights and practical guidance for improving the resilience and governance of AI‐enabled higher education systems.

Systems Research and Behavioral Science
Dalian Maritime University (CN), China People's Police University (CN)
Artificial Intelligence in Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon