प्रत्युत्सारः — Refutation by Reasoning

Pratyutsāra, "driving back", is the refutation of another's view by reasoning. It is one of the four tantrayuktis that Caraka adds to the shared list, and Cakrapāṇi defines it as "the warding off of another's view by argument (upapatti)". His example is taken from Caraka's twenty-fifth chapter, a symposium of sages on the origin of the person and of disease, where Vāryovida's claim that beings arise from rasa is rebutted by Hiraṇyākṣa: "the self is not said to arise from rasa." The symposium is a chain of such rebuttals: nine sages in turn propose the self, the mind, rasa, the six elements, the parents, karma, nature, the creator and time as the origin, and each is refused by the next with a reason. Ātreya then halts the debate: "truth is hard to reach by clinging to a side"; those who argue thesis against counter-thesis "never reach the end, like men at an oil-press going round." This article examines the chain, distinguishes pratyutsāra from the Nyāya vitaṇḍā (refutation without a thesis of one's own) and from pūrvapakṣa and uttarapakṣa, and answers three objections: that refutation is purely negative and adds no knowledge, that it is the same as uttarapakṣa, and that it leads to endless dispute. It concludes that pratyutsāra is the critical step of a śāstra — necessary, but incomplete without re-establishment (uddhāra, TY-37) — and that its modern forms are critique, falsification and the rebuttal of rival hypotheses. Series: तन्त्रयुक्तिविमर्शः · Tantrayukti Studies, TY-2026/36. Loci: Ca. Si. 12.45 (Āyurvedadīpikā). Online version: https://sanskritmanthan.in/a/ty-36-pratyutsara

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23947983
Primary Topic
Indian and Buddhist Studies
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

प्रत्युत्सारः — Refutation by Reasoning

Srinivasu Mantha
5 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Indian and Buddhist Studies
preprint

प्रत्युत्सारः — Refutation by Reasoning

Srinivasu Mantha
preprint en

Abstract

Pratyutsāra, "driving back", is the refutation of another's view by reasoning. It is one of the four tantrayuktis that Caraka adds to the shared list, and Cakrapāṇi defines it as "the warding off of another's view by argument (upapatti)". His example is taken from Caraka's twenty-fifth chapter, a symposium of sages on the origin of the person and of disease, where Vāryovida's claim that beings arise from rasa is rebutted by Hiraṇyākṣa: "the self is not said to arise from rasa." The symposium is a chain of such rebuttals: nine sages in turn propose the self, the mind, rasa, the six elements, the parents, karma, nature, the creator and time as the origin, and each is refused by the next with a reason. Ātreya then halts the debate: "truth is hard to reach by clinging to a side"; those who argue thesis against counter-thesis "never reach the end, like men at an oil-press going round." This article examines the chain, distinguishes pratyutsāra from the Nyāya vitaṇḍā (refutation without a thesis of one's own) and from pūrvapakṣa and uttarapakṣa, and answers three objections: that refutation is purely negative and adds no knowledge, that it is the same as uttarapakṣa, and that it leads to endless dispute. It concludes that pratyutsāra is the critical step of a śāstra — necessary, but incomplete without re-establishment (uddhāra, TY-37) — and that its modern forms are critique, falsification and the rebuttal of rival hypotheses. Series: तन्त्रयुक्तिविमर्शः · Tantrayukti Studies, TY-2026/36. Loci: Ca. Si. 12.45 (Āyurvedadīpikā). Online version: https://sanskritmanthan.in/a/ty-36-pratyutsara

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Indian and Buddhist Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon