Temporal eligibility rules alter country composition and ecoregion representation in global river water-quality monitoring networks

Temporal eligibility can reorganize a monitoring network in directions that station loss alone does not predict.This instability was characterized in Caravan-Qual Lite version 1.1 over 2000-2020 using six constituents, country labels, 426 freshwater ecoregions, seven realms, and Hill numbers q=0, 1, and 2. The primary rule retained 14,387 electrical-conductivity stations (Cohort A) and a 4.373-station intersection of the independently eligible conductivity, phosphorus, and dissolved-oxygen networks (Cohort B); overlap in eligible years or sampling dates was not required.With minimum requirements of three, five, or ten nonconsecutive eligible calendar years, dissolved organic carbon was lost in 90.7% of stations, while ecoregion q = 2 increased from 3.909 to 6.594.Electrical conductivity and total phosphorus also gained q = 2 ecoregion representation at selected thresholds, whereas dissolved oxygen declined across countries, ecoregions, and realms.Nitrate and suspended solids realm q = 2 rose slightly from three to five years before falling to ten.Thus, comparable attrition did not imply a common geographic response.Equal-size references were treated as descriptive baselines rather than exchangeability tests.In Cohort B, ecoregion q = 0 was 10.8% below its equal-size median while q = 2 was 46.1% above it; the +0.5% within-country q = 2 residual showed that the evenness excess was largely reproduced after country counts were fixed, whereas the q = 0 deficit persisted.Requiring coverage in all four calendar quarters removed 40.1% of Cohort B stations and nine ecoregions and shifted country leverage.Tempoal rules, therefore, changed country composition and FEOW representation in constituent-and order-specific ways that station retention alone could not summarize.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Ecological Engineering
Published
2026-10-28
DOI
https://doi.org/10.12911/22998993/235928
Primary Topic
Water Quality and Pollution Assessment
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Temporal eligibility rules alter country composition and ecoregion representation in global river water-quality monitoring networks

Luis Buchelli Carpio, Sara Sofia Valencia Castillo, Roger Marcelo Freire-Avilés, Andrea Mariel Malavé Gómez et al.
Journal of Ecological Engineering
Water Quality and Pollution Assessment
article

Temporal eligibility rules alter country composition and ecoregion representation in global river water-quality monitoring networks

Luis Buchelli Carpio, Sara Sofia Valencia Castillo, Roger Marcelo Freire-Avilés, Andrea Mariel Malavé Gómez, Fabiola Rosa Lopezdomínguez Rivas, Norma Alexandra Valencia Castillo
article en

Abstract

Temporal eligibility can reorganize a monitoring network in directions that station loss alone does not predict.This instability was characterized in Caravan-Qual Lite version 1.1 over 2000-2020 using six constituents, country labels, 426 freshwater ecoregions, seven realms, and Hill numbers q=0, 1, and 2. The primary rule retained 14,387 electrical-conductivity stations (Cohort A) and a 4.373-station intersection of the independently eligible conductivity, phosphorus, and dissolved-oxygen networks (Cohort B); overlap in eligible years or sampling dates was not required.With minimum requirements of three, five, or ten nonconsecutive eligible calendar years, dissolved organic carbon was lost in 90.7% of stations, while ecoregion q = 2 increased from 3.909 to 6.594.Electrical conductivity and total phosphorus also gained q = 2 ecoregion representation at selected thresholds, whereas dissolved oxygen declined across countries, ecoregions, and realms.Nitrate and suspended solids realm q = 2 rose slightly from three to five years before falling to ten.Thus, comparable attrition did not imply a common geographic response.Equal-size references were treated as descriptive baselines rather than exchangeability tests.In Cohort B, ecoregion q = 0 was 10.8% below its equal-size median while q = 2 was 46.1% above it; the +0.5% within-country q = 2 residual showed that the evenness excess was largely reproduced after country counts were fixed, whereas the q = 0 deficit persisted.Requiring coverage in all four calendar quarters removed 40.1% of Cohort B stations and nine ecoregions and shifted country leverage.Tempoal rules, therefore, changed country composition and FEOW representation in constituent-and order-specific ways that station retention alone could not summarize.

Journal of Ecological EngineeringVol. 27(12)
Universidad Estatal de Milagro (EC), Universidad Agraria del Ecuador (EC)
Clean water and sanitation
Openalex Percentile: Top 25%
Water Quality and Pollution Assessment
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon