One Flaw, Two Residues: The Exhaustion of the Single-Imperfection Conjecture in Einstein–Cartan Cosmology

Einstein–Cartan cosmology with a Henneaux–Teitelboim unimodular sector — Route E, as developed in Two Bounds — contains two numbers it does not explain. At the non-singular bounce known as the Aldred pin sits the baryon asymmetry, η = 6.1×10⁻¹⁰. At the infrared end sits the vacuum ratio, ρ_Λ/ρ_Pl = 1.13×10⁻¹²³, carried as the integration constant Λ_int. This paper states at full strength the framework's most attractive conjecture — Conjecture C: a single dimensionless imperfection ε, seated at the pin, generates both residues by derivation — and reports its complete exhaustion. The power-law bridge class was already dead: in a 50,000-draw solve the pin drew 1 hit in 200,000 at underived exponents, the signature of numerology. Iteration 1 enumerated every named mechanism with a forced functional form. Gravitational baryogenesis misses by −39.98 dex at the Planck scale and by −2.66 dex at the only nominated non-Planck scale. The Nieh–Yan / axial class is dead in both forms: its coherent form by the pin's incoherent branch, ⟨𝒮^μ⟩ ≡ 0; its anomaly form by ≥18.8 dex, coefficient non-universality, and sphaleron erasure. The flux classes miss the floor by +44.27 dex, are vacuous as a boundary condition, absent as a stepping sector, or miss by +83.91 dex while restating ε_pin in disguise. Exponential suppression undershoots by ~10³⁸ dex. The Hehl–Datta asymmetry overshoots by +8.2 to +9.2 dex behind a conversion sector the framework does not contain, and gives η = 0 in-framework. Coleman / Baum–Hawking quantum selection is killed: its forced output is Λ → 0, not a finite Λℓ_P² = 2.85×10⁻¹²²; it supplies no η; and it imports an ensemble foreign to EC+HT. Iteration 2 ran the two computations left open, under thresholds registered before either ran. Attack 1 derives the baryogenesis cutoff: integrating out algebraic EC torsion yields only κ²-built contact terms, no derivable (∂_μ𝒯)J^μ_{B−L} operator at any non-Planckian scale. The nominated scale ħc𝒯_A = 2.657 GeV is a κ²-dressed background value, 𝒯_A = κ²cs_A, not a coupling. The derived scale, 2.44×10¹⁸–1.22×10¹⁹ GeV, exceeds the pre-registered 0.4 GeV threshold by +18.78 dex; η misses by −37.5 to −38.9 dex even with the true bounce profile, whose peak |Ṙ| = 43.85 GeV³ is 11.7× the estimate it replaces. The η side is empty. Attack 2 tests all eight matching conditions (M1–M8) for the conjugate pair (Λ_int, V₄) across H = 0. All eight are Λ-blind, centred on the exact cancellation of ρ_C in ρ_eff + p_eff and on Λ_int being the momentum conjugate to a cyclic coordinate. Matched bounces exist for the whole open interval ρ_C ∈ (−ρ_A/4, +∞), unselected throughout. The floor side is empty. Conjecture C is dead by exhaustion, at its own kill line, in a stronger form than the line contemplated: no derivation in the framework produces either residue from the pin. The two residues return to being two separate open problems that happen to share a framework. Nothing here touches Tier-1 Route E decoupling, the pin, or any claim in Two Bounds, where the link closed here was labelled open. The fourteen-entry kill log is the deliverable: a conjecture killed by exhaustion is a map of where the answer is not.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-10-27
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23698352
Primary Topic
Cosmology and Gravitation Theories
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
preprint

One Flaw, Two Residues: The Exhaustion of the Single-Imperfection Conjecture in Einstein–Cartan Cosmology

William Alexander Aldred
3 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Cosmology and Gravitation Theories
preprint

One Flaw, Two Residues: The Exhaustion of the Single-Imperfection Conjecture in Einstein–Cartan Cosmology

William Alexander Aldred
preprint en

Abstract

Einstein–Cartan cosmology with a Henneaux–Teitelboim unimodular sector — Route E, as developed in Two Bounds — contains two numbers it does not explain. At the non-singular bounce known as the Aldred pin sits the baryon asymmetry, η = 6.1×10⁻¹⁰. At the infrared end sits the vacuum ratio, ρ_Λ/ρ_Pl = 1.13×10⁻¹²³, carried as the integration constant Λ_int. This paper states at full strength the framework's most attractive conjecture — Conjecture C: a single dimensionless imperfection ε, seated at the pin, generates both residues by derivation — and reports its complete exhaustion. The power-law bridge class was already dead: in a 50,000-draw solve the pin drew 1 hit in 200,000 at underived exponents, the signature of numerology. Iteration 1 enumerated every named mechanism with a forced functional form. Gravitational baryogenesis misses by −39.98 dex at the Planck scale and by −2.66 dex at the only nominated non-Planck scale. The Nieh–Yan / axial class is dead in both forms: its coherent form by the pin's incoherent branch, ⟨𝒮^μ⟩ ≡ 0; its anomaly form by ≥18.8 dex, coefficient non-universality, and sphaleron erasure. The flux classes miss the floor by +44.27 dex, are vacuous as a boundary condition, absent as a stepping sector, or miss by +83.91 dex while restating ε_pin in disguise. Exponential suppression undershoots by ~10³⁸ dex. The Hehl–Datta asymmetry overshoots by +8.2 to +9.2 dex behind a conversion sector the framework does not contain, and gives η = 0 in-framework. Coleman / Baum–Hawking quantum selection is killed: its forced output is Λ → 0, not a finite Λℓ_P² = 2.85×10⁻¹²²; it supplies no η; and it imports an ensemble foreign to EC+HT. Iteration 2 ran the two computations left open, under thresholds registered before either ran. Attack 1 derives the baryogenesis cutoff: integrating out algebraic EC torsion yields only κ²-built contact terms, no derivable (∂_μ𝒯)J^μ_{B−L} operator at any non-Planckian scale. The nominated scale ħc𝒯_A = 2.657 GeV is a κ²-dressed background value, 𝒯_A = κ²cs_A, not a coupling. The derived scale, 2.44×10¹⁸–1.22×10¹⁹ GeV, exceeds the pre-registered 0.4 GeV threshold by +18.78 dex; η misses by −37.5 to −38.9 dex even with the true bounce profile, whose peak |Ṙ| = 43.85 GeV³ is 11.7× the estimate it replaces. The η side is empty. Attack 2 tests all eight matching conditions (M1–M8) for the conjugate pair (Λ_int, V₄) across H = 0. All eight are Λ-blind, centred on the exact cancellation of ρ_C in ρ_eff + p_eff and on Λ_int being the momentum conjugate to a cyclic coordinate. Matched bounces exist for the whole open interval ρ_C ∈ (−ρ_A/4, +∞), unselected throughout. The floor side is empty. Conjecture C is dead by exhaustion, at its own kill line, in a stronger form than the line contemplated: no derivation in the framework produces either residue from the pin. The two residues return to being two separate open problems that happen to share a framework. Nothing here touches Tier-1 Route E decoupling, the pin, or any claim in Two Bounds, where the link closed here was labelled open. The fourteen-entry kill log is the deliverable: a conjecture killed by exhaustion is a map of where the answer is not.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Cosmology and Gravitation Theories
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon