Conflicting logics in conflicted contexts: how fragility, militarization and armed violence shape US and Chinese FDI

Purpose This paper aims to examine whether MNEs originating from different political-economic systems respond differently to fragility, militarization and armed violence in conflict-affected countries. It seeks to explore how MNEs from two powerful but contrasting home countries direct their foreign direct investment (FDI) differently, given these characteristics of fragile host countries. Design/methodology/approach This study undertakes a comparative analysis of US and Chinese FDI into 20 fragile, conflict-affected countries between 2010 and 2021. Country-level econometric analysis is combined with project-level greenfield FDI data to compare investment patterns and sectoral characteristics. Findings Institutional fragility deters US FDI but is positively associated with Chinese FDI. Militarization has no significant relationship with US FDI but is positively associated with Chinese FDI, while armed violence deters investment from both countries. Project-level evidence shows that Chinese investment into these countries is concentrated in infrastructure and manufacturing projects, whereas US investment is predominantly service-oriented and smaller in scale. Together, findings suggest that firms originating from different national development models respond differently to conflict-affected environments. Research limitations/implications The research identifies macro-level patterns that can be used to enhance IB theory. It does not distinguish conflict stages, subnational exposure or project-level decision processes. Future research should compare pre-conflict, active-conflict and post-conflict phases, combine subnational violence and project-location data and use qualitative case studies to examine how MNEs from different home countries negotiate security, legitimacy, state−business relations and development responsibilities in the same conflict-affected environments. Practical implications The findings suggest that policymakers should recognize that investors from different political-economic systems respond differently to conflict-related risks. Host governments seeking FDI should align investment promotion strategies with the industrial capabilities, investment models and comparative advantages of different investor groups, rather than assuming all foreign investors respond similarly to fragile and conflict-affected environments. Social implications State-backed investment may provide infrastructure, industrial capacity, employment and resources for reconstruction and development in conflict-affected countries, but its broader impacts may vary depending on host-country institutional conditions. The findings highlight the need to evaluate international investment not only by its volume but also by its developmental, distributional, peacebuilding and human consequences. Originality/value This study provides a novel contribution in three respects. First, it provides evidence that suggests MNE responses to conflict are shaped not only by host-country conditions but also by the political-economic systems from which investing firms originate. Second, it conceptualizes conflict-affected environments as comprising distinct dimensions (institutional fragility, militarization and armed violence) that exert different influences on FDI. Third, it argues that national development models generate internationally transferable industrial capabilities that are deployed through state-coordinated investment systems, creating comparative advantages that shape FDI volumes and locations.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Critical Perspectives on International Business
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/cpoib-03-2026-0068
Primary Topic
International Business and FDI
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Conflicting logics in conflicted contexts: how fragility, militarization and armed violence shape US and Chinese FDI

Dylan Sutherland, Christopher Williams, Lotfi Hamzi, Ludan Wu et al.
2 links
Critical Perspectives on International Business
International Business and FDI
article

Conflicting logics in conflicted contexts: how fragility, militarization and armed violence shape US and Chinese FDI

Dylan Sutherland, Christopher Williams, Lotfi Hamzi, Ludan Wu, Nahid Anaraki
article en

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to examine whether MNEs originating from different political-economic systems respond differently to fragility, militarization and armed violence in conflict-affected countries. It seeks to explore how MNEs from two powerful but contrasting home countries direct their foreign direct investment (FDI) differently, given these characteristics of fragile host countries. Design/methodology/approach This study undertakes a comparative analysis of US and Chinese FDI into 20 fragile, conflict-affected countries between 2010 and 2021. Country-level econometric analysis is combined with project-level greenfield FDI data to compare investment patterns and sectoral characteristics. Findings Institutional fragility deters US FDI but is positively associated with Chinese FDI. Militarization has no significant relationship with US FDI but is positively associated with Chinese FDI, while armed violence deters investment from both countries. Project-level evidence shows that Chinese investment into these countries is concentrated in infrastructure and manufacturing projects, whereas US investment is predominantly service-oriented and smaller in scale. Together, findings suggest that firms originating from different national development models respond differently to conflict-affected environments. Research limitations/implications The research identifies macro-level patterns that can be used to enhance IB theory. It does not distinguish conflict stages, subnational exposure or project-level decision processes. Future research should compare pre-conflict, active-conflict and post-conflict phases, combine subnational violence and project-location data and use qualitative case studies to examine how MNEs from different home countries negotiate security, legitimacy, state−business relations and development responsibilities in the same conflict-affected environments. Practical implications The findings suggest that policymakers should recognize that investors from different political-economic systems respond differently to conflict-related risks. Host governments seeking FDI should align investment promotion strategies with the industrial capabilities, investment models and comparative advantages of different investor groups, rather than assuming all foreign investors respond similarly to fragile and conflict-affected environments. Social implications State-backed investment may provide infrastructure, industrial capacity, employment and resources for reconstruction and development in conflict-affected countries, but its broader impacts may vary depending on host-country institutional conditions. The findings highlight the need to evaluate international investment not only by its volume but also by its developmental, distributional, peacebuilding and human consequences. Originality/value This study provides a novel contribution in three respects. First, it provides evidence that suggests MNE responses to conflict are shaped not only by host-country conditions but also by the political-economic systems from which investing firms originate. Second, it conceptualizes conflict-affected environments as comprising distinct dimensions (institutional fragility, militarization and armed violence) that exert different influences on FDI. Third, it argues that national development models generate internationally transferable industrial capabilities that are deployed through state-coordinated investment systems, creating comparative advantages that shape FDI volumes and locations.

Critical Perspectives on International Business
NEOMA Business School (FR), Durham University (GB), Fort Hays State University (US), ESSCA School of Management (FR), Tsinghua University (CN)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions
International Business and FDI
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon