Learning vector field concepts with multiple representations in introductory physics: Robustness of effects across instructional contexts

Students in introductory electromagnetism often struggle with the conceptual interpretation of vector differential operators such as divergence and curl, particularly when reasoning from graphical representations of vector fields. To address these difficulties, we developed research-based multirepresentational learning tasks that combine sketching activities with an interactive simulation to support conceptual understanding of vector calculus concepts. Building on a previous field study demonstrating the effectiveness of these tasks in a homework implementation setting, the present study investigates whether these learning effects generalize across instructional contexts. To this end, we evaluated an independent in-class implementation at RWTH Aachen University and compared the results with a reanalysis of data from the previously investigated homework implementation at the University of Göttingen using the same performance measure. Students participated in an in-class intervention group (IG1), a homework intervention group (IG2), or a control group (CG) working on traditional calculation-based tasks ( N = 131 ). Students in both intervention groups showed significant improvements in response accuracy (IG1: p < 0.001 , η G 2 = 0.20 ; IG2: p < 0.001 , η G 2 = 0.11 ) and response confidence (IG1: p < 0.001 , η G 2 = 0.17 ; IG2: p = 0.003 , η G 2 = 0.03 ), whereas no significant improvement was observed in the control group. The comparable learning gains observed in the independently implemented in-class intervention and the reanalyzed homework intervention (normalized Hake gain g H , IG 1 = 0.44 , g H , IG 2 = 0.38 ) indicate that the effectiveness of the multirepresentational learning tasks is robust across instructional and institutional contexts. Exploratory analyses further revealed no evidence for a dose-effect relationship between the number of completed learning tasks and the learning gains, highlighting the need for future research on the role of intervention intensity in multirepresentational learning about differential operators.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Physical Review Physics Education Research
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1103/hsd4-qy8s
Primary Topic
Science Education and Pedagogy
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Learning vector field concepts with multiple representations in introductory physics: Robustness of effects across instructional contexts

Pascal Klein, Larissa Hahn, Alexander Voigt
Physical Review Physics Education Research
Science Education and Pedagogy
article

Learning vector field concepts with multiple representations in introductory physics: Robustness of effects across instructional contexts

Pascal Klein, Larissa Hahn, Alexander Voigt
article en

Abstract

Students in introductory electromagnetism often struggle with the conceptual interpretation of vector differential operators such as divergence and curl, particularly when reasoning from graphical representations of vector fields. To address these difficulties, we developed research-based multirepresentational learning tasks that combine sketching activities with an interactive simulation to support conceptual understanding of vector calculus concepts. Building on a previous field study demonstrating the effectiveness of these tasks in a homework implementation setting, the present study investigates whether these learning effects generalize across instructional contexts. To this end, we evaluated an independent in-class implementation at RWTH Aachen University and compared the results with a reanalysis of data from the previously investigated homework implementation at the University of Göttingen using the same performance measure. Students participated in an in-class intervention group (IG1), a homework intervention group (IG2), or a control group (CG) working on traditional calculation-based tasks ( N = 131 ). Students in both intervention groups showed significant improvements in response accuracy (IG1: p < 0.001 , η G 2 = 0.20 ; IG2: p < 0.001 , η G 2 = 0.11 ) and response confidence (IG1: p < 0.001 , η G 2 = 0.17 ; IG2: p = 0.003 , η G 2 = 0.03 ), whereas no significant improvement was observed in the control group. The comparable learning gains observed in the independently implemented in-class intervention and the reanalyzed homework intervention (normalized Hake gain g H , IG 1 = 0.44 , g H , IG 2 = 0.38 ) indicate that the effectiveness of the multirepresentational learning tasks is robust across instructional and institutional contexts. Exploratory analyses further revealed no evidence for a dose-effect relationship between the number of completed learning tasks and the learning gains, highlighting the need for future research on the role of intervention intensity in multirepresentational learning about differential operators.

Physical Review Physics Education ResearchVol. 22(2)
University of Göttingen (DE), RWTH Aachen University (DE)
Quality education
Science Education and Pedagogy
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon