Which Counterexamples to the Petersen Coloring Conjecture Are Colorable Only by Themselves?
For cubic graphs G and H, an H-coloring of G is a map from the edges of G to the edges of H that sends every vertex star of G bijectively onto a vertex star of H; a Petersen coloring is the case where H is the Petersen graph. Ma, Mattiolo, Steffen and Wolf showed that there is a unique minimal set H_3 of connected bridgeless cubic graphs that color every bridgeless cubic graph, and that a graph belongs to it exactly when no bridgeless cubic graph of smaller order colors it. Since the Petersen coloring conjecture was refuted in 2026, H_3 is infinite and contains every smallest counterexample. Goedgebeur, Jooken, Máčajová, Mattiolo, Mazzuoccolo and Ulyanov asked whether their two counterexamples on 52 vertices, the smallest known, are colorable only by themselves. We prove two lemmas on the vertex map of an H-coloring: all its fibers have the same parity, and target vertices that are not used can be reduced to at most one by the splitting lemma. They leave three kinds of colorings, in none of which the target graph has a part unconstrained by G, and they turn the question into one propositional formula per target order, with the target graph as part of the unknown. For both 52-vertex counterexamples, every even target order from 40 to 50 is refuted with a DRAT proof checked by drat-trim; several smaller orders are refuted as well. Together with the result of Goedgebeur et al. that every bridgeless cubic graph on at most 38 vertices has a Petersen coloring, this shows that both graphs belong to H_3: they are colorable only by themselves. Without the two lemmas the same search decided no target order of the first graph within comparable time. Source code, data, computational records and verification instructions: https://github.com/fsantibanezleal/CAOS_RESEARCH (problems/combinatorics/petersen-coloring, computation EXP-007).
Authors
- Felipe A. Santibáñez-Leal (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0150-3246)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-10-06
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22859074
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Graph Theory Research
- Type
- preprint