Measure the Ward First: Intentional Sufficiency as a Design Rule for Sleep Sensing in Acute Inpatient Psychiatry

This Viewpoint argues that measurement design, not model capability, is the first constraint on clinical AI in acute inpatient psychiatry and proposes intentional sufficiency as a design rule for sleep sensing on acute wards. Acute psychiatric wards exclude much of the conventional sensing design space: ligature, ingestion, and projectile hazards; unreliable adherence; impaired consent; and nursing workload mean that a device that is excellent when a patient is cooperative may be absent when the patient is most unwell. We define intentional sufficiency in 3 parts: the intended clinical use sets the required signal properties and acceptable error; safety, validity, consent, and workflow constraints define the feasible design space; and within that space, the rule selects the least burdensome option that preserves the required properties, because excess capability can be paid for in persistence, not only in money. We contrast this rule with capability-maximizing design using 2 examples at opposite ends of the design space: a structured nightly nursing sleep duration record that, in Taiwan, already exists within routine care, and a disposable wrist-worn sensing architecture under development that reduces the wearable to what the derived sleep measure requires. The first shows when the rule can conclude that no hardware should be added, provided adequacy has been shown for the intended use; the second shows when it concludes that hardware must be redesigned, and is presented as a design prediction rather than a result. Importantly, agreement with a reference method does not by itself establish task-level sufficiency; greater sensing capability does not necessarily produce more clinically available information when deployment and persistence are constrained; and some signal properties are validity defining and cannot be traded against cost.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Medical Internet Research
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.2196/112674
Primary Topic
Healthcare Technology and Patient Monitoring
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Measure the Ward First: Intentional Sufficiency as a Design Rule for Sleep Sensing in Acute Inpatient Psychiatry

Terry B. J. Kuo, Hong-Ming Chen
1 links
Journal of Medical Internet Research
Healthcare Technology and Patient Monitoring
article

Measure the Ward First: Intentional Sufficiency as a Design Rule for Sleep Sensing in Acute Inpatient Psychiatry

Terry B. J. Kuo, Hong-Ming Chen
article en

Abstract

This Viewpoint argues that measurement design, not model capability, is the first constraint on clinical AI in acute inpatient psychiatry and proposes intentional sufficiency as a design rule for sleep sensing on acute wards. Acute psychiatric wards exclude much of the conventional sensing design space: ligature, ingestion, and projectile hazards; unreliable adherence; impaired consent; and nursing workload mean that a device that is excellent when a patient is cooperative may be absent when the patient is most unwell. We define intentional sufficiency in 3 parts: the intended clinical use sets the required signal properties and acceptable error; safety, validity, consent, and workflow constraints define the feasible design space; and within that space, the rule selects the least burdensome option that preserves the required properties, because excess capability can be paid for in persistence, not only in money. We contrast this rule with capability-maximizing design using 2 examples at opposite ends of the design space: a structured nightly nursing sleep duration record that, in Taiwan, already exists within routine care, and a disposable wrist-worn sensing architecture under development that reduces the wearable to what the derived sleep measure requires. The first shows when the rule can conclude that no hardware should be added, provided adequacy has been shown for the intended use; the second shows when it concludes that hardware must be redesigned, and is presented as a design prediction rather than a result. Importantly, agreement with a reference method does not by itself establish task-level sufficiency; greater sensing capability does not necessarily produce more clinically available information when deployment and persistence are constrained; and some signal properties are validity defining and cannot be traded against cost.

Journal of Medical Internet ResearchVol. 28
Good health and well-being
Healthcare Technology and Patient Monitoring
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon