Chunking of physics formulas: An exploratory study using handwriting recording

Formulas are one of the key representations in physics. They serve to model complex physics phenomena using a symbolic mathematical language. Even though it is part of the daily life of physicists to apply formulas in problem-solving processes or to discuss phenomena by nexplaining formulas, little is known about the underlying cognitive processes taking place when we perceive, read, or write formulas. In this paper, this topic is approached through the lens of chunk-based information processing. In a laboratory setting, participants of varying levels of expertise performed a recall task. They were presented with formulas of varying complexity, both in conventional and unconventional representation formats, which they sequentially read, wrote, and evaluated in terms of their familiarity. The writing process was tracked digitally, and both recall results and writing dynamics were analyzed. In this recall task, observed patterns are consistent with expertise-dependent chunking in the context of physics formulas. This finding emerges from examining the writing data from different perspectives. Namely, we find that experts are able to reproduce more elements of a formula than the capacity of short-term memory would suggest, with high correlation ( ρ = 0.8 ) between task-specific familiarity and recall results. The relationship between recall rate and expertise was moderated by formula length, as differences in performance across expertise groups were most pronounced for longer formulas, with experts outperforming both lay people and first-year students particularly in this regard. Furthermore, analyses of writing dynamics indicated an increasing relative number of short pauses ( t pause < 0.54 ) with task-specific familiarity, as evidenced by a moderate correlation ( ρ = 0.54 ) between these metrics. Since within-chunk pauses are assumed to be shorter than between-chunk pauses, this suggests the emergence of larger chunks as expertise develops. Finally, analyses of reordered formulas permit preliminary cautious statements to be made about the nature of these chunks and suggest the potential importance of templates in the perception of formulas.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Physical Review Physics Education Research
Published
2026-11-19
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1103/m6bl-7rnq
Primary Topic
Visual and Cognitive Learning Processes
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Chunking of physics formulas: An exploratory study using handwriting recording

Pascal Klein, Josefine Neuhaus, Andréas Müller
Physical Review Physics Education Research
Visual and Cognitive Learning Processes
article

Chunking of physics formulas: An exploratory study using handwriting recording

Pascal Klein, Josefine Neuhaus, Andréas Müller
article en

Abstract

Formulas are one of the key representations in physics. They serve to model complex physics phenomena using a symbolic mathematical language. Even though it is part of the daily life of physicists to apply formulas in problem-solving processes or to discuss phenomena by nexplaining formulas, little is known about the underlying cognitive processes taking place when we perceive, read, or write formulas. In this paper, this topic is approached through the lens of chunk-based information processing. In a laboratory setting, participants of varying levels of expertise performed a recall task. They were presented with formulas of varying complexity, both in conventional and unconventional representation formats, which they sequentially read, wrote, and evaluated in terms of their familiarity. The writing process was tracked digitally, and both recall results and writing dynamics were analyzed. In this recall task, observed patterns are consistent with expertise-dependent chunking in the context of physics formulas. This finding emerges from examining the writing data from different perspectives. Namely, we find that experts are able to reproduce more elements of a formula than the capacity of short-term memory would suggest, with high correlation ( ρ = 0.8 ) between task-specific familiarity and recall results. The relationship between recall rate and expertise was moderated by formula length, as differences in performance across expertise groups were most pronounced for longer formulas, with experts outperforming both lay people and first-year students particularly in this regard. Furthermore, analyses of writing dynamics indicated an increasing relative number of short pauses ( t pause < 0.54 ) with task-specific familiarity, as evidenced by a moderate correlation ( ρ = 0.54 ) between these metrics. Since within-chunk pauses are assumed to be shorter than between-chunk pauses, this suggests the emergence of larger chunks as expertise develops. Finally, analyses of reordered formulas permit preliminary cautious statements to be made about the nature of these chunks and suggest the potential importance of templates in the perception of formulas.

Physical Review Physics Education ResearchVol. 22(2)
University of Geneva (CH), University of Göttingen (DE)
Visual and Cognitive Learning Processes
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon