GAILC Working Paper 002: The Intervention Test — When Human Oversight Meets AI-Mediated Decision-Making, Can a Human Actually Change the Outcome?

{"As":[0],"artificial":[1],"intelligence":[2],"systems":[3,24],"become":[4],"increasingly":[5,21],"capable":[6],"of":[7,41,173,184,204,294],"generating":[8],"recommendations,":[9],"making":[10],"classifications,":[11],"initiating":[12],"actions,":[13],"allocating":[14],"resources,":[15],"and":[16,84,139,241,288],"influencing":[17],"consequential":[18],"decisions,":[19],"organizations":[20],"describe":[22],"these":[23],"as":[25],"operating":[26],"with":[27,140],"a":[28,42,150,170,193,198,202,208,323],"human":[29,43,53,57,158,166,186,200,209,250,257,295],"\\"in":[30],"the":[31,39,72,77,99,103,147,182],"loop,\\"":[32],"\\"human":[33,36],"oversight,\\"":[34],"or":[35,329],"review.\\"":[37],"Yet":[38],"existence":[40],"in":[44,188,297],"an":[45,110,120,214,278],"AI-mediated":[46,215,298],"workflow":[47],"does":[48,268],"not":[49,196,249,255,262,269,322],"establish":[50,128],"that":[51],"meaningful":[52],"control":[54],"exists.":[55],"A":[56],"may":[58,67,80,97,114,122,291],"be":[59],"present":[60],"but":[61,70,87,101,206],"lack":[62,71],"authority":[63,69,83],"to":[64,75,91,108,127,271,305,309],"intervene.":[65],"They":[66,79,96,113],"possess":[68,81],"technical":[73,85],"capacity":[74,86],"alter":[76,219],"system.":[78],"both":[82],"receive":[88,102],"insufficient":[89],"information":[90],"understand":[92,98],"what":[93,130,141],"requires":[94],"intervention.":[95,258],"system":[100],"relevant":[104],"signal":[105],"too":[106],"late":[107],"prevent":[109],"irreversible":[111],"consequence.":[112],"intervene":[115],"without":[116,124],"sufficient":[117,125],"competence.":[118],"And":[119],"intervention":[121,162,260,301],"occur":[123],"provenance":[126],"afterward":[129],"was":[131,135],"changed,":[132,136],"why":[133],"it":[134,276],"by":[137],"whom,":[138],"effect.":[142],"This":[143],"Working":[144,177],"Paper":[145,178],"introduces":[146],"Intervention":[148,229,231,233,235,237,239,242],"Test:":[149],"GAILC":[151,176],"research":[152,320],"framework":[153,223,267],"for":[154,212],"examining":[155],"whether":[156,197,207],"claimed":[157],"oversight":[159,253,296],"constitutes":[160],"genuine":[161],"rather":[163],"than":[164],"merely":[165],"presence.":[167],"It":[168],"develops":[169],"distinct":[171],"line":[172],"inquiry":[174],"from":[175],"001,":[179],"which":[180,282],"examined":[181],"economics":[183],"authenticated":[185],"participation":[187],"synthetic-media":[189],"contexts.":[190],"WP002":[191],"asks":[192],"different":[194],"question:":[195],"real":[199],"originated":[201],"piece":[203],"content,":[205],"formally":[210],"responsible":[211],"supervising":[213],"decision":[216],"can":[217],"actually":[218],"its":[220],"outcome.":[221],"The":[222,266,300],"investigates":[224],"eight":[225],"dimensions:":[226],"Human":[227,246,252,259],"Intervention,":[228],"Authority,":[230],"Capacity,":[232],"Timing,":[234],"Information,":[236],"Competence,":[238],"Provenance,":[240],"Confidence.":[243],"Central":[244],"distinction:":[245],"presence":[247],"is":[248,254,261,303],"oversight.":[251],"necessarily":[256,263],"effective":[264],"control.":[265],"attempt":[270],"determine":[272],"legal":[273,324],"liability.":[274],"Instead,":[275],"provides":[277],"evidentiary":[279],"architecture":[280],"through":[281,311],"organizations,":[283],"researchers,":[284],"regulators,":[285],"auditors,":[286],"courts,":[287],"other":[289],"investigators":[290],"interrogate":[292],"claims":[293],"systems.":[299],"question":[302],"proposed":[304],"remain":[306],"empirically":[307],"open":[308],"refinement":[310],"application":[312],"across":[313],"GAILC's":[314],"Counter-Brief":[315],"series.":[316],"Framework":[317],"status:":[318],"Evolving":[319],"methodology;":[321],"standard,":[325],"certification,":[326],"regulatory":[327],"determination,":[328],"liability":[330],"test.":[331],"Version":[332],"0.2":[333],"(Revised),":[334],"August":[335],"2026.":[336]}