Phase Transitions After Alignment: A Two-Coordinate Account of AGI Labour Substitution and an Audit of Its Metaphors

{"Abstract":[0],"Most":[1],"work":[2],"on":[3,105,140,158],"AI":[4],"risk":[5],"concerns":[6],"the":[7,16,49,62,106,141,152,159,169,173,181,211,214,218,223,230,233,237,250,281,292,323,326,329,332,335,338,344,361,370,381,391,395],"case":[8],"in":[9,45,164,179],"which":[10,60,75,180],"alignment":[11],"fails.":[12],"This":[13],"paper":[14],"examines":[15],"complementary":[17],"case:":[18],"even":[19],"if":[20],"an":[21,72,97,177],"artificial":[22],"general":[23],"intelligence":[24],"(AGI)":[25],"is":[26,96,163,176,184,197,300,375,385],"perfectly":[27],"aligned":[28],"and":[29,71,100,136,148,162,172,272,286,307,331,337,360,388,406],"fully":[30],"obedient,":[31],"sustained":[32],"substitution":[33,234],"of":[34,64,213,232,239,253,263,276,294,355,363,394],"human":[35],"economic":[36],"function":[37],"may":[38],"still":[39,190],"drive":[40],"a":[41,57,65,83,110,145,240,244,254,261,269,304,373,389,407],"structural":[42,91],"phase":[43],"transition":[44],"society.":[46],"We":[47,202,302,400],"describe":[48,229],"process":[50],"with":[51,144,210,402],"two":[52,274,396],"mutually":[53],"independent":[54],"state":[55,183],"coordinates:":[56],"scale":[58,107],"coordinate,":[59,74],"reads":[61,76],"shape":[63],"distribution":[66],"(how":[67],"concentrated":[68],"it":[69,309,346],"is),":[70],"activity":[73,86,95],"how":[77],"many":[78],"units":[79],"remain":[80],"active.":[81],"On":[82,225],"minimal":[84],"mean-field":[85],"equation":[87],"we":[88,228],"establish":[89],"three":[90],"facts.":[92],"First,":[93],"zero":[94],"invariant":[98],"manifold,":[99],"no":[101,149],"additive":[102],"floor":[103],"acting":[104],"coordinate":[108,241,345],"—":[109,116],"universal":[111],"basic":[112],"income,":[113],"for":[114,342],"example":[115],"can":[117,221],"reach":[118],"it.":[119],"Second,":[120],"synergistic":[121],"functions":[122],"(those":[123],"that":[124,193,204,369,410],"operate":[125],"only":[126],"when":[127],"enough":[128],"peers":[129],"are":[130,398],"already":[131,185],"active,":[132],"such":[133],"as":[134,236,260,372],"coordination":[135],"mutual":[137],"aid)":[138],"lie":[139],"saddle-node":[142],"side,":[143],"barrier,":[146],"hysteresis":[147],"return":[150],"along":[151],"original":[153],"path;":[154],"mere":[155],"connectivity":[156],"lies":[157],"transcritical":[160],"side":[161],"principle":[165],"reversible.":[166],"Third,":[167],"between":[168],"Maxwell":[170],"point":[171],"spinodal":[174],"there":[175],"interval":[178,206],"active":[182],"metastable":[186],"while":[187],"its":[188,348,350,353,357,364],"basin":[189],"exists,":[191],"so":[192],"every":[194],"snapshot":[195],"indicator":[196],"nearly":[198],"indistinguishable":[199],"from":[200,413],"health.":[201],"show":[203],"this":[205,226,318],"must":[207],"be":[208],"located":[209],"quasi-potential":[212],"underlying":[215],"jump":[216],"process;":[217],"deterministic":[219],"potential":[220],"reverse":[222],"verdict.":[224],"basis":[227],"endpoint":[231],"chain":[235],"obsolescence":[238],"rather":[242,267],"than":[243,268],"\\"collapse":[245],"back":[246],"to":[247,280,310],"uniformity\\",":[248],"classify":[249],"upward":[251],"move":[252],"few":[255],"individuals":[256],"onto":[257],"new":[258],"axes":[259],"shift":[262],"extreme":[264],"order":[265],"statistics":[266],"system-level":[270],"transition,":[271],"distinguish":[273],"depths":[275],"degeneration:":[277],"A1":[278],"(drift":[279],"passive":[282],"baseline,":[283],"fluctuations":[284,289],"intact)":[285],"A2":[287],"(background":[288],"suppressed":[290],"towards":[291,377],"level":[293],"spontaneous":[295],"activation).":[296],"Our":[297],"second":[298],"contribution":[299],"methodological.":[301],"propose":[303],"metaphor-audit":[305],"protocol":[306],"apply":[308],"six":[311],"metaphors":[312],"used":[313],"for,":[314,317],"or":[315],"proposed":[316],"problem":[319],"(the":[320],"black":[321],"hole,":[322],"two-wing":[324],"diagram,":[325],"dammed":[327],"lake,":[328,334],"river":[330],"dead":[333],"fishbowl,":[336],"cancer":[339],"cell),":[340],"reporting":[341],"each":[343],"reads,":[347],"class,":[349],"evidential":[351],"source,":[352],"range":[354],"validity,":[356],"failure":[358],"condition":[359],"direction":[362],"bias.":[365],"The":[366],"audit":[367],"shows":[368],"set":[371],"whole":[374],"biased":[376],"\\"one-way":[378],"sliding\\",":[379],"whereas":[380],"model's":[382],"core":[383],"structure":[384],"\\"two":[386],"wells":[387],"barrier\\";":[390],"policy":[392,408],"implications":[393],"pictures":[397],"opposite.":[399],"close":[401],"five":[403],"testable":[404],"predictions":[405],"discussion":[409],"separates":[411],"analysis":[412],"value":[414],"choice.":[415]}