What Separates the Google Top 20 from Positions 21–50? On-Page, Topical, Intent and Technical Features of 7370 Result URLs, with a Comparison to Yandex

{"Search":[0],"engine":[1],"optimisation":[2],"checklists":[3],"ask":[4],"for":[5,97,420],"the":[6,10,23,65,118,128,144,149,157,222,257,276,291,294,299,302,310,357,371,382,424],"exact":[7],"query":[8,130,220,300],"in":[9,45,117,156,176,221,289,297,301],"title":[11,223,303],"and":[12,26,84,91,108,136,181,192,212,234,260,304,313,326,333,363,374,387,393,399],"H1,":[13],"a":[14,27,73,81,115,122,133,137,268,272,314],"word":[15],"count":[16],"matched":[17],"to":[18,105],"competitors,":[19],"full":[20,219],"coverage":[21,71,99,200],"of":[22,39,72,76,127,178,236,250,256,275,344],"user's":[24],"intent":[25,98,340],"light,":[28],"fast":[29],"page.":[30],"This":[31],"preprint":[32,311],"tests":[33],"those":[34],"items":[35],"against":[36,121],"one":[37,408,410],"snapshot":[38,274,318],"Google":[40,89,290],"results:":[41],"160":[42],"Russian-language":[43,418],"queries":[44,278],"16":[46,179],"niches,":[47],"positions":[48,125],"1–50,":[49],"Moscow,":[50],"desktop,":[51],"14":[52],"September":[53],"2026":[54],"(7401":[55],"result":[56],"rows,":[57],"7370":[58],"URLs,":[59],"4432":[60],"domains).":[61],"For":[62],"every":[63],"URL":[64],"study":[66],"measured":[67],"on-page":[68],"text":[69,172,292],"features,":[70,328,353],"query-specific":[74],"list":[75],"topical":[77],"terms":[78],"(\\"LSI":[79],"coverage\\"),":[80],"technical":[82,327],"audit":[83],"host-level":[85,329],"network":[86,330],"properties;":[87],"1228":[88],"documents":[90,94],"634":[92],"Yandex":[93,273,298,351],"were":[95],"scored":[96],"by":[100],"an":[101],"LLM":[102],"assessor":[103,346],"blind":[104],"rank,":[106],"domain":[107],"search":[109],"engine.":[110],"The":[111,218,307],"main":[112],"contrast":[113],"is":[114,154,174,187,201],"page":[116,123,388],"top":[119,158,295],"20":[120,159],"from":[124,370],"21–50":[126],"same":[129,258,277,425],"(AUC":[131,160,205],"with":[132,189,196,271,360,376],"query-level":[134],"bootstrap":[135],"within-query":[138],"permutation":[139,166],"test).":[140],"No":[141],"feature":[142],"separates":[143,293],"groups":[145],"strongly.":[146],"LSI":[147,325,336],"coverage,":[148],"hypothesis":[150],"treated":[151],"as":[152],"confirmatory,":[153],"higher":[155,204],"55.3,":[161],"95%":[162],"CI":[163],"[53.6;":[164],"56.9],":[165],"p":[167,209],"=":[168,210],"0.0002),":[169],"holds":[170],"when":[171,379],"length":[173],"controlled,":[175],"15":[177],"niches":[180],"without":[182],"aggregators;":[183],"its":[184],"within-domain":[185],"gap":[186,252],"+0.026":[188],"upper":[190],"medians":[191],"+0.015":[193],"[0.000;":[194],"0.032]":[195],"conventional":[197],"medians.":[198],"Intent":[199],"not":[202,265,395],"reliably":[203],"52.7":[206],"[49.5;":[207],"55.6],":[208],"0.063)":[211],"adds":[213],"nothing":[214],"at":[215,227],"equal":[216],"length.":[217],"or":[224],"H1":[225],"performs":[226],"chance":[228],"level":[229],"(within-query":[230],"pair":[231],"share":[232],"50.6":[233],"50.0":[235],"100).":[237],"Top-20":[238],"pages":[239,255],"are":[240,390,394],"larger":[241,287],"(HTML":[242],"246.3":[243],"vs":[244,281],"207.1":[245],"KB),":[246],"but":[247],"only":[248],"15%":[249],"that":[251],"remains":[253],"between":[254],"site,":[259],"server":[261],"response":[262],"time":[263],"does":[264],"differ.":[266],"At":[267],"common":[269],"boundary":[270],"(positions":[279],"1–10":[280],"odd":[282],"31–49),":[283],"both":[284],"engines":[285],"favour":[286],"pages;":[288],"more,":[296],"description":[305],"does.":[306],"record":[308],"contains":[309],"(PDF)":[312],"replication":[315],"package:":[316],"SERP":[317],"(query,":[319],"position,":[320],"URL,":[321],"domain),":[322],"per-page":[323],"on-page,":[324],"data,":[331],"stub":[332],"exclusion":[334],"flags,":[335],"term":[337],"lists,":[338],"frozen":[339],"maps,":[341],"0/1/2":[342],"scores":[343],"two":[345],"runs":[347],"(weighted":[348],"kappa":[349],"0.863),":[350],"comparison":[352],"original":[354,383],"analysis":[355],"logs,":[356],"pre-analysis":[358],"plan":[359],"amendments":[361],"(Russian)":[362],"code.":[364],"code/verify_headline_numbers.py":[365],"recomputes":[366],"88":[367],"headline":[368],"numbers":[369],"CSV":[372],"files":[373],"exits":[375],"code":[377],"0":[378],"they":[380],"match":[381],"logs.":[384],"Raw":[385],"HTML":[386],"texts":[389],"third-party":[391],"content":[392],"included.":[396],"Text,":[397],"figures":[398],"data:":[400,426],"CC":[401],"BY":[402],"4.0;":[403],"code:":[404],"MIT.":[405],"Observational":[406],"design,":[407],"date,":[409],"region,":[411],"desktop":[412],"only;":[413],"no":[414],"causal":[415],"claims.":[416],"A":[417],"article":[419],"practitioners":[421],"based":[422],"on":[423],"sk-seo.ru/blog/chto-otlichaet-top-20-google.html.":[427]}

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-09-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22796115
Primary Topic
Web visibility and informetrics
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
preprint

What Separates the Google Top 20 from Positions 21–50? On-Page, Topical, Intent and Technical Features of 7370 Result URLs, with a Comparison to Yandex

Stanislav Kirichenko
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Web visibility and informetrics
preprint

What Separates the Google Top 20 from Positions 21–50? On-Page, Topical, Intent and Technical Features of 7370 Result URLs, with a Comparison to Yandex

Stanislav Kirichenko
preprint en

Abstract

Search engine optimisation checklists ask for the exact query in the title and H1, a word count matched to competitors, full coverage of the user's intent and a light, fast page. This preprint tests those items against one snapshot of Google results: 160 Russian-language queries in 16 niches, positions 1–50, Moscow, desktop, 14 September 2026 (7401 result rows, 7370 URLs, 4432 domains). For every URL the study measured on-page text features, coverage of a query-specific list of topical terms ("LSI coverage"), a technical audit and host-level network properties; 1228 Google documents and 634 Yandex documents were scored for intent coverage by an LLM assessor blind to rank, domain and search engine. The main contrast is a page in the top 20 against a page from positions 21–50 of the same query (AUC with a query-level bootstrap and a within-query permutation test). No feature separates the groups strongly. LSI coverage, the hypothesis treated as confirmatory, is higher in the top 20 (AUC 55.3, 95% CI [53.6; 56.9], permutation p = 0.0002), holds when text length is controlled, in 15 of 16 niches and without aggregators; its within-domain gap is +0.026 with upper medians and +0.015 [0.000; 0.032] with conventional medians. Intent coverage is not reliably higher (AUC 52.7 [49.5; 55.6], p = 0.063) and adds nothing at equal length. The full query in the title or H1 performs at chance level (within-query pair share 50.6 and 50.0 of 100). Top-20 pages are larger (HTML 246.3 vs 207.1 KB), but only 15% of that gap remains between pages of the same site, and server response time does not differ. At a common boundary with a Yandex snapshot of the same queries (positions 1–10 vs odd 31–49), both engines favour larger pages; in Google the text separates the top more, in Yandex the query in the title and description does. The record contains the preprint (PDF) and a replication package: SERP snapshot (query, position, URL, domain), per-page on-page, LSI and technical features, host-level network data, stub and exclusion flags, LSI term lists, frozen intent maps, 0/1/2 scores of two assessor runs (weighted kappa 0.863), Yandex comparison features, original analysis logs, the pre-analysis plan with amendments (Russian) and code. code/verify_headline_numbers.py recomputes 88 headline numbers from the CSV files and exits with code 0 when they match the original logs. Raw HTML and page texts are third-party content and are not included. Text, figures and data: CC BY 4.0; code: MIT. Observational design, one date, one region, desktop only; no causal claims. A Russian-language article for practitioners based on the same data: sk-seo.ru/blog/chto-otlichaet-top-20-google.html.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Web visibility and informetrics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.