Ethical Subjectivity across Human–AI and AI–AI Relations: A Generative Relational Inquiry

{"Debates":[0],"about":[1,137],"artificial":[2,142,154,156,165,226,246,314],"intelligence":[3],"often":[4],"ask":[5],"whether":[6],"an":[7,52,225],"AI":[8],"system":[9,40],"is":[10,216,273,303,340],"a":[11,19,95,115,229,259,336,343],"moral":[12,48,63,125,127,316,368],"subject.":[13],"This":[14],"discussion":[15],"paper":[16,120,184,267,302],"begins":[17],"from":[18,175,331],"narrower":[20],"methodological":[21],"concern:":[22],"the":[23,58,101,119,138,178,183,219,332],"expression":[24],"\\"moral":[25],"subject\\"":[26],"can":[27,204,231,355],"compress":[28],"several":[29],"different":[30,102,285],"forms":[31,207,286,351],"of":[32,54,72,79,141,208,222,287,335,352,366],"standing":[33,68,172],"that":[34,170,262,271],"need":[35],"not":[36,269,310],"arise":[37],"together.":[38],"A":[39],"may":[41,50,65,76],"exercise":[42],"consequential":[43],"decision":[44,123],"power":[45,80],"without":[46,56,69],"bearing":[47],"responsibility,":[49],"become":[51,108],"object":[53],"protection":[55],"possessing":[57],"capacities":[59],"usually":[60],"associated":[61],"with":[62],"agency,":[64,126],"acquire":[66],"legal":[67,129,318],"settling":[70],"questions":[71,365],"phenomenal":[73],"experience,":[74],"and":[75,110,131,161,200,212,239,289,297,359,370],"occupy":[77],"positions":[78],"before":[81],"any":[82],"stable":[83],"ethical":[84,151,157,162,171,209,353],"vocabulary":[85],"exists":[86],"for":[87,347],"describing":[88],"those":[89,291],"relations.":[90],"Treating":[91],"these":[92],"statuses":[93],"as":[94,228],"single":[96],"binary":[97],"property":[98],"risks":[99],"obscuring":[100],"relational":[103,279,361],"histories":[104],"through":[105],"which":[106],"they":[107],"socially":[109],"normatively":[111],"significant.":[112],"Working":[113],"within":[114,357],"Generative":[116],"Relational":[117],"perspective,":[118],"therefore":[121],"distinguishes":[122],"subjectivity,":[124,130],"patiency,":[128],"power-holding":[132],"capacity,":[133],"while":[134,250,363],"suspending":[135],"claims":[136],"ultimate":[139],"ontology":[140],"subjects.":[143],"The":[144,266,301],"inquiry":[145],"examines":[146],"three":[147],"directions":[148],"separately:":[149],"human":[150,254],"relations":[152,158,163],"toward":[153,159,248,256,323],"agents,":[155],"humans,":[160],"among":[164],"agents.":[166],"Rather":[167],"than":[168,306],"assuming":[169,251],"follows":[173],"directly":[174],"membership":[176],"in":[177],"category":[179],"\\"human\\"":[180],"or":[181,320],"\\"machine,\\"":[182],"asks":[185,276],"how":[186,290,349],"interpretive":[187],"practices,":[188],"persistent":[189],"relations,":[190],"dependency,":[191],"vulnerability,":[192],"delegated":[193],"authority,":[194],"control":[195],"over":[196,299],"resources,":[197],"institutional":[198,372],"classifications,":[199],"historically":[201],"generated":[202],"norms":[203],"make":[205],"particular":[206],"subjectivity":[210,354],"recognizable":[211],"consequential.":[213],"Particular":[214],"attention":[215],"given":[217],"to":[218,283,312,341,375],"normative":[220,260,329],"consequences":[221],"instrumentality.":[223],"Classifying":[224],"agent":[227],"tool":[230],"organize":[232],"permissions":[233],"concerning":[234],"ownership,":[235],"modification,":[236],"deletion,":[237],"replacement,":[238],"resource":[240],"allocation;":[241],"conversely,":[242],"imposing":[243],"duties":[244,322],"on":[245],"agents":[247],"humans":[249],"no":[252],"corresponding":[253],"responsibilities":[255],"them":[257],"produces":[258],"asymmetry":[261],"itself":[263],"requires":[264],"explanation.":[265],"does":[268,309,326],"presume":[270],"symmetry":[272],"required.":[274],"It":[275,308],"instead":[277],"what":[278],"differences":[280,292],"are":[281,293],"invoked":[282],"justify":[284],"treatment,":[288],"interpreted,":[294],"stabilized,":[295],"contested,":[296],"revised":[298],"time.":[300],"exploratory":[304],"rather":[305],"declarative.":[307],"claim":[311],"establish":[313],"consciousness,":[315],"personhood,":[317],"personality,":[319],"universal":[321],"AI.":[324],"Nor":[325],"it":[327],"infer":[328],"validity":[330],"historical":[333],"emergence":[334],"norm.":[337],"Its":[338],"aim":[339],"provide":[342],"revisable":[344],"conceptual":[345],"framework":[346],"analysing":[348],"heterogeneous":[350],"emerge":[356],"human–AI":[358],"AI–AI":[360],"systems,":[362],"keeping":[364],"ontology,":[367],"justification,":[369],"future":[371],"design":[373],"open":[374],"further":[376],"argument.":[377]}