Non-observations are not properties: measurement floors in superconductor databases and their propagation into machine-learning datasets

{"Superconductor":[0],"databases":[1],"record":[2],"two":[3,62,78,338,354,480,591,600,726,754],"different":[4],"kinds":[5],"of":[6,77,126,186,222,226,235,244,271,287,335,401,414,442,475,508,528,549,556,581,634,641,645,682,752,757,786,790,809,822,850,864,882,893,927,984,1015,1028],"statement":[7,32],"in":[8,66,248,265,267,309,384,398,501,543,560,587,771,783,813,910,954,1041],"the":[9,17,53,72,75,106,123,134,141,149,219,232,236,245,254,272,325,330,336,343,378,389,417,428,440,466,482,493,496,499,509,517,526,529,540,558,565,575,604,608,627,632,639,655,664,668,683,687,692,697,710,734,749,753,772,793,801,810,814,829,834,851,904,924,937,966,975,982,1003,1006,1012,1020,1029,1048,1057,1083],"same":[10,237,390,676],"field:":[11],"a":[12,31,38,67,90,161,164,197,258,362,443,449,506,585,672,805,819,838,919,955,985,1036],"measured":[13,190,260,349,871],"transition":[14,21,872],"temperature,":[15,1000],"and":[16,88,117,121,139,159,194,204,278,306,317,366,373,434,448,513,571,593,621,654,667,723,733,748,765,788,798,833,840,915,918,946,1023,1039,1066,1087,1096],"observation":[18],"that":[19,59,167,358,388,626,648,680,699,736,854,928,998,1067],"no":[20,205,845,870,1090],"was":[22,546],"found":[23,490,953,1038],"down":[24],"to":[25,133,411,427,486,521,936,1074],"some":[26],"temperature.":[27],"The":[28,152,675,889],"second":[29,255],"is":[30,55,531,579,594,615,657,804,903,996,1055,1071],"about":[33,37,563,1005],"an":[34,661],"experiment,":[35],"not":[36,171,211,347,360,375,554,568,583,651,670,775,991,1010,1056],"material.":[39],"Widely":[40],"used":[41],"derived":[42,70,168],"datasets":[43,169],"encode":[44],"it":[45,989],"as":[46,183,281,294,404,446,478,660,671],"Tc":[47,858],"=":[48,859],"0,":[49],"at":[50,199,298,303,319,437,533,847,857,876,884,912,921,931],"which":[51,268,370,988,1001,1054,1082],"point":[52,256,1004],"distinction":[54],"lost.":[56],"We":[57,252,352],"show":[58],"this":[60,385,941,1042],"has":[61,154,346,572,740],"separate":[63],"consequences.":[64],"First,":[65],"machine-learning":[68,418,483],"benchmark":[69],"from":[71,105,377,409,505,516,611,663],"SuperCon":[73,175],"database,":[74],"combination":[76],"individually":[79],"reasonable":[80],"cleaning":[81,511,938],"rules":[82],"—":[83,101,296,322,461,861,868,992],"averaging":[84],"over":[85,696],"duplicate":[86],"records,":[87,473],"discarding":[89],"compound":[91],"when":[92],"its":[93,249,619,642,706,865,993,1051,1063],"records":[94,397,685],"scatter":[95],"by":[96,261,465,491,743],"more":[97,1093],"than":[98,1078,1098],"5":[99],"K":[100,203,300,308,321,816,917],"removes":[102],"fifteen":[103,138,396,472,830],"materials":[104,812],"dataset":[107],"entirely,":[108],"among":[109],"them":[110,187,402,415,476,875,883],"Nb3Al":[111],"(17.5":[112],"K),":[113,120],"V3Si":[114],"(16.8":[115],"K)":[116],"NbN":[118],"(13.5":[119],"shifts":[122],"target":[124],"value":[125],"nineteen":[127,142],"further":[128,962],"entries.":[129],"A":[130,380],"nine-line":[131],"change":[132],"aggregation":[135,846],"restores":[136],"all":[137,323,489],"corrects":[140],"without":[143],"removing":[144],"any":[145],"entry":[146,206],"or":[147,200,885],"altering":[148],"non-superconductor":[150,250,866],"class.":[151,251,942],"patch":[153,530,935],"been":[155,292,341,348,469,573,741],"submitted":[156],"upstream.":[157],"Second,":[158],"independently,":[160],"non-observation":[162,444],"carries":[163,392,705,856],"measurement":[165,327,879,1008],"floor":[166,198,1064],"do":[170,372,374],"preserve.":[172],"In":[173],"MDR":[174],"Ver.240322":[176],"we":[177,367],"identify":[178],"3,130":[179],"formulas":[180,228],"listed":[181],"exclusively":[182],"non-superconducting;":[184],"1,749":[185],"were":[188,276,431,768],"never":[189],"below":[191,218,324,981],"1.5":[192],"K,":[193,439,553],"653":[195],"have":[196,290,339,468,869],"above":[201,283,551,886,997],"1":[202,887,959],"after":[207],"1980.":[208,351],"These":[209],"are":[210,215,631],"established":[212],"non-superconductors;":[213,525],"they":[214,240,1099],"compounds":[216,270,423],"untested":[217],"cryogenic":[220],"limit":[221],"their":[223],"time.":[224],"1,332":[225],"those":[227,288],"also":[229],"reach":[230,416,481,983],"3DSC_MP,":[231],"structure-matched":[233],"variant":[234],"dataset,":[238],"where":[239,603,969,1033],"account":[241],"for":[242,978,1062,1094],"1,334":[243,849],"1,778":[246,852],"entries":[247,832,853],"illustrate":[253],"with":[257,577,618,792],"series":[259,892],"Ku":[262],"et":[263,613,895],"al.":[264,614],"1980,":[266],"31":[269],"CeCo3B2":[273],"structure":[274],"type":[275],"characterised":[277],"23":[279],"recorded":[280],"non-superconducting":[282],"1.2":[284],"K.":[285,888,933],"Three":[286],"twenty-three":[289],"since":[291,314,350],"confirmed":[293],"superconductors":[295],"CeRu3B2":[297],"1.1":[299],"(1985),":[301],"YRu3B2":[302],"0.63,":[304],"0.7":[305],"0.81":[307],"three":[310,331,420,862,907],"independent":[311],"measurements":[312,602,926],"reported":[313],"December":[315],"2025,":[316],"LuRu3B2":[318],"0.95":[320],"1980":[326],"floor.":[328],"Of":[329],"non-magnetic":[332],"rare-earth":[333],"members":[334,908],"series,":[337],"now":[340,514,595,616,658,678,704,779,1046],"confirmed;":[342],"third,":[344],"La0.9Ru3B2,":[345],"report":[353],"pre-registered":[355,755,820],"permutation":[356],"tests":[357,756],"did":[359],"support":[361],"broader":[363],"frequency":[364],"claim,":[365],"state":[368,700],"explicitly":[369],"conclusions":[371],"follow":[376],"data.":[379],"related":[381],"check,":[382],"added":[383],"version,":[386],"finds":[387],"database":[391],"nine":[393,462,719],"retracted":[394,450,459,720],"papers,":[395],"all,":[399,877],"none":[400,474,538],"marked":[403,477],"retracted;":[405],"retraction":[406,429],"dates":[407],"range":[408,666,693],"1992":[410],"2023.":[412],"Two":[413],"benchmark:":[419],"Rh-based":[421],"Heusler":[422],"whose":[424,760],"samples,":[425],"according":[426],"notice,":[430],"palladium":[432],"compounds,":[433],"elemental":[435],"europium":[436],"1.375":[438],"average":[441],"encoded":[445],"zero":[447],"high-pressure":[451],"value.":[452],"Version":[453],"3.":[454],"New:":[455],"Section":[456,544,561,588,597,623,758,777,826,958,972,1044,1059,1088],"7.3":[457],"on":[458,638],"sources":[460],"papers":[463],"cited":[464,617],"datasheet":[467],"retracted,":[470],"carrying":[471],"such;":[479],"benchmark.":[484],"Corrections":[485],"version":[487],"2,":[488],"re-running":[492],"analyses":[494],"against":[495,818],"primary":[497],"files:":[498,716,944],"totals":[500],"Table":[502],"4.1":[503],"came":[504],"re-implementation":[507],"3DSC":[510],"step":[512,939],"come":[515],"pipeline":[518,727],"itself":[519],"(15,788":[520],"15,803":[522],"entries,":[523],"3,866":[524],"effect":[527],"unchanged":[532],"+15":[534],"restored,":[535],"19":[536],"corrected,":[537],"lost);":[539],"stratum":[541],"size":[542],"5.3":[545,778,1045],"wrong":[547],"(0":[548],"1,371":[550],"10":[552],"0":[555,860],"5,145);":[557],"claim":[559],"2.2":[562],"reproducing":[564],"normalisation":[566],"could":[567,650],"be":[569,652],"reproduced":[570],"removed;":[574],"comparison":[576],"SuperCon-MTG":[578,731],"139":[580,835],"139,":[582],"137;":[584],"quotation":[586],"2.1":[589],"conflated":[590],"sentences":[592],"verbatim;":[596],"7.4":[598],"said":[599,960,974],"conflicting":[601],"text":[605,649,773],"gives":[606],"three;":[607],"footnote":[609],"quoted":[610],"Savitskii":[612,963],"page":[620],"table.":[622],"5.2":[624],"asserted":[625],"numeric":[628],"reference":[629,708,949],"identifiers":[630],"bibliography":[633],"Roberts'":[635],"1976":[636],"compilation,":[637],"strength":[640],"stated":[643],"count":[644],"1,995":[646],"entries;":[647],"obtained":[653],"identification":[656],"given":[659],"inference":[662],"identifier":[665],"years,":[669],"verified":[673],"fact.":[674],"section":[677],"states":[679,780,1047],"151":[681],"4,241":[684],"leave":[686],"year":[688],"field":[689],"empty,":[690],"so":[691,1024],"1913–1975":[694],"holds":[695],"4,090":[698],"one.":[701],"Reference":[702],"[4]":[703],"DOI,":[707],"[12]":[709],"full":[711,784],"author":[712],"list.":[713],"New":[714,825,943],"supplementary":[715],"S5":[717],"(the":[718,725,730],"sources),":[721],"S6a":[722],"S6b":[724],"outputs),":[728],"S7":[729],"comparison),":[732],"scripts":[735,751],"produce":[737],"them;":[738],"verify_patch.py":[739],"replaced":[742],"compare_cleaned_outputs.py.":[744],"Also":[745],"new:":[746],"S8a–S8e":[747],"four":[750,961],"5.3,":[759],"counting":[761],"stages,":[762],"result":[763],"protocols":[764],"pre-registration":[766],"checksums":[767],"previously":[769],"described":[770],"but":[774],"deposited.":[776],"both":[781],"populations":[782],"(5,622":[785],"5,644":[787],"10,072":[789],"10,098,":[791],"exclusion":[794],"rule":[795],"spelled":[796],"out)":[797],"names":[799],"what":[800],"2.46":[802],"%":[803],"share":[806],"of:":[807],"11":[808],"448":[811],"0–1":[815],"stratum,":[817],"threshold":[821],"8":[823,1089],"%.":[824],"4.4:":[827],"besides":[828],"removed":[831],"averaged":[836],"ones,":[837],"third":[839],"much":[841],"larger":[842],"class":[843,867],"needs":[844],"all.":[848],"3DSC_MP":[855,911],"quarters":[863],"temperature":[873],"behind":[874],"only":[878,1026],"floors,":[880],"948":[881],"Nb-substituted":[890],"ZrNi2Ga":[891],"Winterlik":[894],"al.,":[896],"Phys.":[897],"Rev.":[898],"B":[899],"78,":[900],"184506":[901],"(2008),":[902],"worked":[905],"example:":[906],"stand":[909],"2.3,":[913],"2.4":[914],"2.87":[916],"fourth":[920],"zero,":[922],"because":[923],"magnetisation":[925],"paper":[929],"stopped":[930],"1.8":[932],"No":[934],"reaches":[940],"S9":[945],"count_nonobservations_in_3dsc.py;":[947],"new":[948],"[21].":[950],"Further":[951],"corrections":[952],"final":[956],"review:":[957],"tables":[964],"carry":[965],"measurement-floor":[967],"convention":[968,1050,1085],"six":[970],"do;":[971],"6.3":[973],"predicted":[976],"band":[977],"LaRu3B2":[979],"falls":[980],"3He":[986],"system,":[987],"does":[990],"lower":[994],"bound":[995],"base":[999],"makes":[1002],"missing":[1007],"stronger,":[1009],"weaker;":[1011],"citation-string":[1013],"parser":[1014],"match_retractions.py":[1016],"required":[1017],"whitespace":[1018],"before":[1019],"volume":[1021],"number":[1022],"parsed":[1025],"4,075":[1027],"7,254":[1030],"citation":[1031],"strings":[1032],"7,016":[1034],"parse,":[1035],"defect":[1037],"corrected":[1040],"review;":[1043],"bin":[1049],"stratification":[1052],"uses,":[1053],"one":[1058],"5.1":[1060],"declares":[1061],"bins,":[1065],"table's":[1068],"first":[1069],"row":[1070],"labelled":[1072],"\\"up":[1073],"0.1":[1075,1080],"K\\"":[1076],"rather":[1077],"\\"below":[1079],"K\\",":[1081],"declared":[1084],"requires;":[1086],"longer":[1091],"claims":[1092],"check_supercon_mtg.py":[1095],"reproduce_counts.py":[1097],"compute.":[1100]}