The unit of analysis in two claimed detections of open-cluster tidal-tail asymmetry

{"Two":[0],"recent":[1],"results":[2],"are":[3,15,144,276,379,437,490],"read":[4],"as":[5,189,500],"evidence":[6,318,325],"that":[7,63,141,147,260,319,369,376,382,418,421,470,485,619],"the":[8,22,27,83,86,142,158,162,169,196,209,246,263,266,271,288,291,310,327,338,358,370,377,384,404,416,430,440,451,462,466,475,478,482,532,545,582,594,614],"tidal":[9],"tails":[10,202,489],"of":[11,47,70,85,195,212,222,270,287,400,425],"nearby":[12],"open":[13],"clusters":[14,41,60,143,199,248,386],"asymmetrically":[16],"populated,":[17],"with":[18,187,229,259,396,550,558,562],"more":[19,74],"stars":[20],"in":[21,26,157,176,249,281,347,409,585,589],"leading":[23,76],"tail":[24,348],"than":[25,303,350,362,574],"trailing":[28],"one.":[29],"Kroupa":[30,188,305],"et":[31,51,183,279,306],"al.":[32,52,184,280,307],"(2024)":[33],"combine":[34],"six":[35,353,554],"teams'":[36],"member":[37,274],"catalogues":[38,57,71],"for":[39,219,465,481,516],"four":[40,198,385],"and":[42,61,95,134,208,251,262,283,314,337,406,412,420,477,510,531,565,604,612],"report":[43,62],"an":[44,174,190,422],"8.99σ":[45,107],"falsification":[46],"leading–trailing":[48],"symmetry.":[49],"Jadhav":[50],"(2025)":[53],"grade":[54],"122":[55],"published":[56,104,180,293,501,616],"covering":[58,203],"58":[59],"among":[64],"their":[65,177,352],"higher-quality":[66],"entries":[67,526],"\\"the":[68],"majority":[69],"(38:31)":[72],"have":[73,173],"populated":[75],"tails\\".":[77],"This":[78],"note":[79,427],"re-examines":[80],"both":[81],"at":[82,215],"level":[84],"statistic.":[87],"It":[88,124,518,571],"contains":[89],"no":[90,93,96,253,514],"new":[91],"observation,":[92],"simulation":[94],"astrophysical":[97],"model;":[98],"every":[99],"number":[100,617],"is":[101,108,125,240,265,323,340,368,373,415,461,519,535,613,620],"recomputed":[102],"from":[103],"tables.":[105],"The":[106,236,365,454,495],"reproduced":[109],"exactly":[110],"(pooled":[111],"n_l":[112],"=":[113,116,119,122,217,225,297,334,389,443,508,569,599],"762,":[114],"n_t":[115],"449,":[117],"n":[118],"1211,":[120],"ε":[121,213,388],"+0.2585).":[123],"a":[126,204,343,397,471,486,503,521,559,566],"single":[127],"Bernoulli":[128,149],"test":[129,505],"over":[130],"1211":[131],"individual":[132],"stars,":[133],"its":[135,138,511],"authors":[136,512],"state":[137],"precondition":[139],"themselves:":[140],"\\"unperturbed\\",":[145],"so":[146,355],"one":[148,292,480,541,615],"description":[150],"covers":[151],"them":[152],"all.":[153],"They":[154],"also":[155,308,520],"ask,":[156],"same":[159,197,441,452,583],"section,":[160],"whether":[161],"membership":[163],"methods":[164],"could":[165],"instead":[166],"be":[167,457],"producing":[168],"asymmetry.":[170],"Both":[171],"questions":[172],"answer":[175],"own":[178],"collaboration's":[179],"numbers.":[181],"Pflamm-Altenburg":[182],"(2023)":[185],"—":[186,192,395,411,413,429,502,591,611],"author":[191],"tabulate":[193],"three":[194,272],"on":[200,245,593],"compact-convergent-point":[201],"different":[205],"radial":[206],"window,":[207],"two":[210,269],"sets":[211],"disagree":[214],"χ²":[216],"42.3":[218],"3":[220],"degrees":[221],"freedom,":[223],"p":[224,507,568,598],"3.4":[226],"×":[227],"10⁻⁹,":[228],"Praesepe":[230],"changing":[231,609],"sign":[232,610],"(−0.078":[233],"against":[234,326,439],"+0.266).":[235],"implied":[237],"per-measurement":[238],"scatter":[239,360],"τ":[241,296,320,333,442],"≈":[242],"0.18,":[243],"measured":[244,341],"very":[247],"dispute":[250],"requiring":[252],"external":[254],"sample.":[255],"Four":[256],"qualifications":[257],"belong":[258],"figure,":[261],"first":[264],"most":[267],"serious:":[268],"CCP":[273,311],"lists":[275],"unpublished":[277],"(\\"Jerabkova":[278],"prep.\\"),":[282],"they":[284,436],"supply":[285],"77%":[286],"χ².":[289],"On":[290],"list":[294],"alone":[295,534],"0.129,":[298],"which":[299,331,492],"gives":[300,506],"4.0σ":[301],"rather":[302,361,573],"3.0σ.":[304],"exclude":[309],"data":[312,378],"deliberately":[313],"say":[315],"why;":[316],"any":[317],"≠":[321],"0":[322,335,444],"itself":[324],"Newtonian":[328],"stochastic":[329],"model,":[330],"predicts":[332],"exactly;":[336],"0.18":[339],"across":[342,403,450],"longer":[344],"lever":[345],"arm":[346],"length":[349],"separates":[351],"catalogues,":[354],"it":[356],"bounds":[357],"relevant":[359],"measuring":[363],"it.":[364,517],"argument":[366],"below":[367],"quoted":[371],"confidence":[372],"unsupportable,":[374],"not":[375,588,621],"unremarkable.":[380],"Carrying":[381],"scatter,":[383],"give":[387],"+0.293":[390],"±":[391],"0.096,":[392],"or":[393],"3.0σ":[394],"defensible":[398],"range":[399],"about":[401],"2.3–4.0σ":[402],"estimators":[405],"provenances":[407],"examined":[408],"§2.4":[410],"this":[414,426,460],"part":[417],"matters,":[419],"earlier":[423],"draft":[424],"missed":[428],"per-cluster":[431],"figures":[432],"deflate":[433],"too,":[434],"because":[435],"computed":[438],"null:":[445],"COIN-Gaia13's":[446],"8.39σ":[447],"becomes":[448,548],"2.6–3.4σ":[449],"range.":[453],"distinction":[455],"must":[456],"kept":[458],"sharp:":[459],"right":[463],"correction":[464],"claim":[467,484,513],"actually":[468],"made,":[469],"universal":[472],"law":[473],"produces":[474],"asymmetry,":[476],"wrong":[479],"narrower":[483],"particular":[487],"cluster's":[488],"lopsided,":[491],"stands":[493],"untouched.":[494],"38:31":[496],"was":[497],"never":[498],"significant":[499],"binomial":[504],"0.47,":[509],"significance":[515,590],"catalogue-multiplicity":[522],"effect.":[523],"Those":[524],"non-bronze":[525],"cover":[527],"40":[528],"distinct":[529],"clusters,":[530],"Hyades":[533],"counted":[536],"seven":[537],"times.":[538],"Collapsed":[539],"to":[540,602],"value":[542],"per":[543,606],"cluster":[544,607],"population":[546],"tally":[547,579],"consistent":[549,561],"50:50":[551],"under":[552],"all":[553],"collapse":[555],"rules":[556],"tried,":[557],"mean":[560],"zero":[563],"throughout":[564],"Wilcoxon":[567],"0.85.":[570],"disappears":[572],"reversing.":[575],"Their":[576],"companion":[577],"span":[578],"does":[580],"survive":[581],"treatment":[584],"direction":[586],"if":[587],"43:28":[592],"deposited":[595],"table,":[596],"one-sided":[597],"0.048,":[600],"falling":[601],"23:17":[603],"0.63σ":[605],"without":[608],"here":[618],"disposed":[622],"of.":[623]}