Combining Annotation Software to Identify Orthologous Genes ( CASIO ) Provides a New Dataset of Orthologous Genes for Swallowtail Butterflies

With the massive increase in genomic resources, it is becoming increasingly popular to analyse thousands of loci across many species. However, many of the available genomes are not annotated, which hinders an efficient search for orthologous protein-coding genes. Here, we aim to develop a semi-automated pipeline and compare four genomic annotation methods (BRAKER2, BUSCO, Miniprot and Scipio). Our results highlight the importance of integrating multiple annotation tools to optimise ortholog detection and improve genomic studies. Each annotation method showed different strengths. BRAKER2 annotated a substantial number of genes. BUSCO, despite limitations inherent to its reference database, identified a higher number of orthologs. Miniprot exhibited notable flexibility in accommodating diverse protein datasets, whereas Scipio successfully recovered a considerable set of genes that were not detected by the other tools. The combination of these tools allowed for more comprehensive ortholog detection. Taking advantage of this pipeline, we developed a comprehensive dataset of orthologous genes for swallowtail butterflies (Lepidoptera: Papilionidae), called Papilionidae_odb, which will facilitate future studies, especially for a non-model group with abundant genomic data and few transcriptomic resources. We tested Papilionidae_odb by inferring a robust phylogenetic framework for Leptocircini using 142 complete genomes, which improved branch support for some phylogenetic relationships, although challenges remained in resolving relationships within certain species groups, likely due to rapid radiations. Our results highlight the complementary nature of the annotation methods and suggest that combining these tools can yield more accurate results in genomic research. This approach was implemented in a Snakemake workflow called CASIO (Combining Annotation Software to Identify Orthologous genes) and can easily be applied to other non-model groups to improve genomic datasets in diverse taxa where transcriptomic resources are still limited.