How sharp is the radial acceleration relation's transition? A calibration-limited measurement of the interpolating-function index, and the exclusion of a C0 onset to weak gravity

{"Version":[0],"2.":[1],"Adds":[2],"a":[3,35,78,83,113,180,209,392],"comparison":[4],"with":[5,34,179,208,255,285,313],"the":[6,23,28,50,53,95,109,117,132,149,156,162,171,236,242,251,256,261,264,314,318,321,349,352,365,368,389,400,406,425,429],"published":[7],"SPARC":[8,177,431],"MOND":[9],"fits":[10],"of":[11,52,68,112,367,391],"Li,":[12],"Lelli,":[13],"McGaugh":[14,434],"&":[15,435],"Schombert":[16,436],"(2018,":[17],"A&A":[18],"615,":[19],"A3),":[20],"which":[21],"reported":[22,385],"same":[24],"α–mass-to-light":[25],"degeneracy":[26,54],"from":[27,44,72],"opposite":[29],"side":[30],"and":[31,46,90,135,146,165,187,220,260,317,370,381,412,424],"closed":[32],"it":[33,92,355],"1.7%":[36],"prior":[37],"on":[38,364,371],"a_0.":[39],"That":[40],"reference":[41],"was":[42,403],"missing":[43],"v1":[45],"its":[47,144,289,325],"omission":[48],"overstated":[49],"novelty":[51],"finding.":[55],"Text":[56],"unchanged":[57],"otherwise;":[58],"all":[59],"numbers":[60],"identical.":[61],"Summary.":[62],"The":[63,125,271,345,361],"radial":[64],"acceleration":[65,120],"relation":[66],"(RAR)":[67],"disk":[69],"galaxies":[70],"turns":[71],"Newtonian":[73,134],"to":[74,93,99,175,405,416],"deep-MOND":[75,136],"behaviour":[76],"over":[77],"finite":[79],"width,":[80],"not":[81,310],"at":[82,116,231,288,327],"point.":[84],"This":[85],"note":[86],"measures":[87],"that":[88,183,399],"width":[89],"uses":[91],"test":[94],"C⁰":[96,172,273],"(\\"kinked\\")":[97],"onset":[98],"weak":[100],"gravity":[101],"predicted":[102],"by":[103],"van":[104,295],"Putten":[105],"(2017a,":[106],"2018)":[107],"as":[108,190],"galaxy-scale":[110],"signature":[111],"causal":[114],"threshold":[115,319,326,346],"de":[118],"Sitter":[119],"a_dS":[121,329],"=":[122,129,153,160,200,225,233,240,247,278,307],"cH.":[123],"Method.":[124],"one-parameter":[126],"family":[127],"μ_α(x)":[128],"x/(1+x^α)^(1/α)":[130],"has":[131],"correct":[133,315],"limits":[137,359],"for":[138],"every":[139,418],"α,":[140],"so":[141],"a_0":[142,219,224],"keeps":[143],"meaning":[145],"α":[147,152,159,166,199,246],"isolates":[148],"sharpness":[150,252],"alone:":[151],"1":[154],"is":[155,169,253,275,347,356,373],"simple":[157],"function,":[158,164],"2":[161],"standard":[163,237],"→":[167],"∞":[168],"exactly":[170,332],"kink.":[173],"Fitting":[174],"2696":[176],"points":[178],"block-covariance":[181],"likelihood":[182],"carries":[184],"distance,":[185],"inclination":[186],"mass-to-light":[188,213,258,407],"errors":[189],"galaxy-level":[191],"(rank-one)":[192],"terms":[193],"rather":[194,376],"than":[195,377],"per-point":[196],"ones.":[197],"Results.":[198],"1.25,":[201],"68%":[202],"[1.20,":[203],"1.31],":[204],"95%":[205],"[1.15,":[206],"1.37],":[207],"global":[210],"3.6":[211],"µm":[212],"calibration":[214],"offset":[215],"profiled":[216],"out":[217],"alongside":[218],"two":[221,265],"intrinsic":[222],"scatters;":[223],"1.17":[226],"×":[227],"10^−10":[228],"m":[229],"s^−2":[230],"Υ_disk":[232,239],"0.61.":[234],"At":[235],"normalisation":[238],"0.5":[241],"fit":[243],"instead":[244],"gives":[245],"1.10":[248],"[1.06,":[249],"1.14]:":[250],"degenerate":[254],"stellar":[257],"calibration,":[259],"shift":[262],"between":[263],"treatments":[266],"exceeds":[267],"either":[268],"statistical":[269],"interval.":[270],"strong":[272],"form":[274],"excluded":[276],"(ΔlnL":[277],"440;":[279],"rms":[280],"0.1464":[281],"against":[282,343],"0.1346":[283],"dex":[284,342],"each":[286],"model":[287,323],"own":[290],"calibration).":[291],"A":[292],"correction":[293],"in":[294,348,386,395],"Putten's":[296],"favour.":[297],"His":[298],"deep":[299],"scaling":[300],"a_N/α":[301],"≃":[302],"2.1":[303],"ζ^(1/2)":[304],"implies":[305],"ν":[306],"(1/2.1)":[308],"y^(−1/2),":[309],"2.1.":[311],"Fitted":[312],"coefficient":[316],"free,":[320],"two-branch":[322],"places":[324],"1.07":[328],"—":[330,336],"essentially":[331],"where":[333],"he":[334],"predicts":[335],"while":[337],"still":[338],"fitting":[339],"poorly":[340],"(0.172":[341],"0.135).":[344],"right":[350],"place;":[351],"shape":[353,366],"around":[354],"not.":[357],"What":[358],"this.":[360],"dominant":[362],"systematic":[363],"RAR,":[369],"a_0,":[372],"stellar-population":[374],"modelling":[375],"rotation":[378],"curves.":[379],"Negative":[380],"self-correcting":[382],"results":[383],"are":[384,420,428],"full,":[387],"including":[388],"withdrawal":[390],"claim":[393],"made":[394],"an":[396],"earlier":[397],"draft":[398],"kink":[401],"exclusion":[402],"insensitive":[404],"calibration.":[408],"All":[409],"code,":[410],"logs":[411],"intermediate":[413],"outputs":[414],"needed":[415],"reproduce":[417],"number":[419],"included.":[421],"Rotation":[422],"curves":[423],"galaxy":[426],"table":[427],"public":[430],"release":[432],"(Lelli,":[433],"2016),":[437],"https://astroweb.cwru.edu/SPARC/.":[438]}

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-09-09
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22680309
Primary Topic
Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
preprint

How sharp is the radial acceleration relation's transition? A calibration-limited measurement of the interpolating-function index, and the exclusion of a C0 onset to weak gravity

Dat Tan Nguyen
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
preprint

How sharp is the radial acceleration relation's transition? A calibration-limited measurement of the interpolating-function index, and the exclusion of a C0 onset to weak gravity

Dat Tan Nguyen
preprint en

Abstract

Version 2. Adds a comparison with the published SPARC MOND fits of Li, Lelli, McGaugh & Schombert (2018, A&A 615, A3), which reported the same α–mass-to-light degeneracy from the opposite side and closed it with a 1.7% prior on a_0. That reference was missing from v1 and its omission overstated the novelty of the degeneracy finding. Text unchanged otherwise; all numbers identical. Summary. The radial acceleration relation (RAR) of disk galaxies turns from Newtonian to deep-MOND behaviour over a finite width, not at a point. This note measures that width and uses it to test the C⁰ ("kinked") onset to weak gravity predicted by van Putten (2017a, 2018) as the galaxy-scale signature of a causal threshold at the de Sitter acceleration a_dS = cH. Method. The one-parameter family μ_α(x) = x/(1+x^α)^(1/α) has the correct Newtonian and deep-MOND limits for every α, so a_0 keeps its meaning and α isolates the sharpness alone: α = 1 is the simple function, α = 2 the standard function, and α → ∞ is exactly the C⁰ kink. Fitting to 2696 SPARC points with a block-covariance likelihood that carries distance, inclination and mass-to-light errors as galaxy-level (rank-one) terms rather than per-point ones. Results. α = 1.25, 68% [1.20, 1.31], 95% [1.15, 1.37], with a global 3.6 µm mass-to-light calibration offset profiled out alongside a_0 and two intrinsic scatters; a_0 = 1.17 × 10^−10 m s^−2 at Υ_disk = 0.61. At the standard normalisation Υ_disk = 0.5 the fit instead gives α = 1.10 [1.06, 1.14]: the sharpness is degenerate with the stellar mass-to-light calibration, and the shift between the two treatments exceeds either statistical interval. The strong C⁰ form is excluded (ΔlnL = 440; rms 0.1464 against 0.1346 dex with each model at its own calibration). A correction in van Putten's favour. His deep scaling a_N/α ≃ 2.1 ζ^(1/2) implies ν = (1/2.1) y^(−1/2), not 2.1. Fitted with the correct coefficient and the threshold free, the two-branch model places its threshold at 1.07 a_dS — essentially exactly where he predicts — while still fitting poorly (0.172 dex against 0.135). The threshold is in the right place; the shape around it is not. What limits this. The dominant systematic on the shape of the RAR, and on a_0, is stellar-population modelling rather than rotation curves. Negative and self-correcting results are reported in full, including the withdrawal of a claim made in an earlier draft that the kink exclusion was insensitive to the mass-to-light calibration. All code, logs and intermediate outputs needed to reproduce every number are included. Rotation curves and the galaxy table are the public SPARC release (Lelli, McGaugh & Schombert 2016), https://astroweb.cwru.edu/SPARC/.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Galaxies: Formation, Evolution, Phenomena
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.