Autophagy and Mitophagy in Hypertensive Chronic Kidney Disease: Evidence Grading, Cell-Type Divergence, and a Working Lysosomal Hypothesis

Hypertension is a major attributed cause of chronic kidney disease (CKD) and kidney failure, yet the cellular mechanisms linking chronic hemodynamic and neurohormonal stress to progressive nephron loss remain incompletely defined. Interpretation is further complicated by the clinical heterogeneity and limited pathological validation of hypertensive nephrosclerosis. Autophagy and mitophagy are important intracellular quality-control pathways and have been increasingly implicated in hypertensive kidney injury. In this review, we critically appraise the available evidence using a multidimensional ACGEM framework that evaluates autophagy/mitophagy measurement (A), cell-type resolution (C), genetic manipulation (G), experimental causality (E), and disease-model relevance (M) as independent dimensions. The available literature does not support a uniform increase or decrease in autophagy during hypertensive kidney disease. Rather, autophagic responses appear to depend on renal cell type, hypertensive stimulus, disease stage, and the component of the pathway being measured. In podocytes, chronic angiotensin II exposure provides evidence of impaired autophagic flux with a protective role for intact autophagy, whereas mineralocorticoid stress can induce a compensatory increase in autophagic flux. Tubular studies likewise suggest protective roles for effective autophagic and mitochondrial quality control, although direct cell-specific causal evidence in hypertensive models remains limited. Across the field, most studies rely on static autophagy-associated markers and bulk kidney measurements, while dynamic flux assessment, cell-specific genetic approaches, and direct evaluation of lysosomal competence remain uncommon. Observations from APOL1-associated kidney disease, chronic interstitial nephritis in agricultural communities, proteinuric overload, aging, and obesity provide mechanistic or pathological precedent for lysosomal vulnerability but do not constitute direct evidence for classical hypertensive nephrosclerosis. We therefore propose, as a falsifiable working hypothesis rather than an established mechanism, that lysosomal clearance may become rate limiting in a subset of hypertensive CKD. Testing this model will require longitudinal, cell-type-resolved flux measurements, direct assessment of lysosomal function, and pathological validation in biopsy-confirmed human hypertensive nephrosclerosis.