Selection bias can inflate the Perturbational Complexity Index (PCIst) in high-dimensional low-SNR regimes: diagnosis, boundary conditions, and a fully out-of-sample estimator

{"The":[0,378],"state-transition":[1,72],"Perturbational":[2],"Complexity":[3],"Index":[4],"(PCIst;":[5],"Comolatti":[6],"et":[7,414],"al.,":[8,415],"2019,":[9],"Brain":[10],"Stimulation)":[11],"is":[12,48,145,168,180,203,491],"the":[13,32,45,51,67,79,96,103,123,156,166,177,184,226,230,295,300,318,334,341,346,398,404,426,456,471],"most":[14],"practical":[15],"validated":[16,495],"measure":[17],"of":[18,29,34,99,122,163,183,229,269,322,403],"consciousness-related":[19],"brain":[20],"complexity,":[21],"discriminating":[22],"wakefulness":[23],"from":[24,31,333],"sleep,":[25],"anesthesia":[26],"and":[27,70,143,165,215,277,290],"disorders":[28],"consciousness":[30],"complexity":[33],"TMS-evoked":[35],"responses.":[36],"Its":[37],"pipeline,":[38],"however,":[39,463],"performs":[40],"three":[41],"data-dependent":[42],"selections":[43,89],"—":[44,219,359,439],"SVD":[46],"basis":[47],"fit":[49],"on":[50,66,78,293,299,473],"response":[52,101],"window":[53],"it":[54],"later":[55],"quantifies,":[56],"principal":[57],"components":[58,151],"are":[59,74],"retained":[60,150],"by":[61,76,468],"an":[62],"SNR":[63,178],"criterion":[64,179],"evaluated":[65],"same":[68,80,124,185],"data,":[69,475],"per-component":[71],"thresholds":[73,291],"chosen":[75],"maximization":[77],"data.":[81],"We":[82,280,484],"show":[83],"in":[84,95,256,310,383,425,455],"simulation":[85,482],"that":[86,148,303],"these":[87],"nested":[88],"can":[90],"produce":[91],"large":[92],"PCIst":[93,118,240,424,490],"values":[94,306,353,467],"complete":[97],"absence":[98],"any":[100],"to":[102,170,253,266,271,307,356,375,461],"perturbation.":[104],"In":[105],"recurrent":[106],"network":[107],"models":[108],"with":[109,225,246,340],"weakly":[110],"correlated":[111,198],"per-node":[112],"noise,":[113,199,245],"sham":[114,221,250,305],"(no-pulse)":[115],"data":[116,128],"yields":[117],"≈":[119,206,209],"500,":[120],"(v4)":[121,354],"magnitude":[125],"as":[126,373,400,440],"pulsed":[127],"(three":[129],"networks":[130],"per":[131],"condition;":[132],"v3":[133,370],"wrote":[134],"\\"statistically":[135],"indistinguishable\\",":[136],"for":[137,160,211,243],"which":[138],"no":[139,338],"test":[140,368],"was":[141,394],"performed":[142],"none":[144],"possible":[146],"at":[147,470],"n);":[149],"exhibit":[152],"SNRs":[153],"narrowly":[154],"hugging":[155],"acceptance":[157],"threshold":[158],"(1.13–1.51":[159],"a":[161,181,261,283,401,476],"cutoff":[162],"1.1),":[164],"inflation":[167,202,222],"invariant":[169],"trial":[171],"count":[172],"(n":[173],"=":[174,234,351],"10–160),":[175],"because":[176],"ratio":[182],"trial-averaged":[186,447],"signal.":[187],"Under":[188],"realistic":[189],"clinical":[190,496],"conditions":[191,393],"(60":[192],"channels,":[193],"1/f":[194],"+":[195],"alpha":[196],"spatially":[197],"standard":[200,319],"windows),":[201],"modest":[204],"(sham":[205],"6–12":[207],"vs":[208,328],"45":[210],"genuine":[212,421,465],"weak":[213,323],"responses)":[214],"classifications":[216],"remain":[217],"robust":[218],"but":[220],"grows":[223],"monotonically":[224],"effective":[227,451],"dimensionality":[228,452],"noise":[231],"(Spearman":[232],"ρ":[233],"0.72,":[235],"p":[236],"<":[237],"1e-39),":[238],"reaching":[239],">":[241],"100":[242],"independent-channel":[244],"heavy-tailed":[247],"outliers":[248],"(single":[249],"realizations":[251],"up":[252],"210)":[254],"even":[255],"low-dimensional":[257],"regimes.":[258],"This":[259],"defines":[260],"danger":[262],"zone":[263],"directly":[264],"relevant":[265],"proposed":[267],"extensions":[268],"PCI":[270],"microelectrode":[272],"arrays,":[273],"organoids,":[274],"animal":[275],"preparations":[276],"artificial":[278],"systems.":[279],"introduce":[281],"PCIst-XV,":[282],"fully":[284],"out-of-sample":[285],"estimator":[286],"(basis,":[287],"component":[288],"selection":[289],"fitted":[292],"half":[294],"trials;":[296],"transitions":[297],"counted":[298],"held-out":[301],"half)":[302],"reduces":[304],"near":[308],"floor":[309],"all":[311],"tested":[312],"regimes":[313],"while":[314,431],"matching":[315],"or":[316],"exceeding":[317],"estimator's":[320],"discrimination":[321],"real":[324,410,446,474],"responses":[325],"(AUC":[326],"1.00":[327],"0.95–1.00).":[329],"An":[330],"independent":[331,419],"reimplementation":[332],"published":[335,427],"equations":[336],"(sharing":[337],"code":[339],"GPL":[342],"reference":[343,347],"implementation)":[344],"reproduces":[345],"implementation":[348],"exactly":[349],"(r":[350],"1.0000,":[352],"identical":[355],"machine":[357],"precision":[358],"maximum":[360],"absolute":[361],"difference":[362],"1.1":[363],"×":[364],"10⁻¹³":[365],"over":[366],"16":[367,379],"cases;":[369],"understated":[371],"this":[372],"\\"identical":[374],"one":[376,384],"decimal\\".":[377],"cases":[380],"were":[381],"run":[382],"adversarial":[385],"regime":[386],"(spectral":[387],"radius":[388],"0.3);":[389],"equivalence":[390],"under":[391],"clinical-SNR":[392],"not":[395,406],"tested),":[396],"establishing":[397],"bias":[399],"property":[402],"method,":[405],"its":[407,494],"code.":[408],"On":[409],"human":[411],"TMS-EEG":[412],"(Biabani":[413],"123":[416],"subjects,":[417],"two":[418],"samples),":[420],"TEPs":[422],"yield":[423],"range":[428],"(median":[429,437],"34.3/26.9)":[430],"matched":[432],"pre-stimulus":[433],"nulls":[434],"stay":[435],"low":[436],"2.6/3.1)":[438],"our":[441],"danger-zone":[442],"analysis":[443],"predicts,":[444],"since":[445],"scalp":[448],"EEG":[449],"has":[450],"1.0–4.9,":[453],"squarely":[454],"safe":[457],"zone;":[458],"raising":[459],"min_snr":[460],"2.0,":[462],"cuts":[464],"TEP":[466],"38–45%":[469],"median":[472],"substantially":[477],"higher":[478],"sensitivity":[479],"cost":[480],"than":[481],"suggests.":[483],"recommend":[485],"sham-control":[486],"and/or":[487],"cross-validation":[488],"whenever":[489],"applied":[492],"outside":[493],"domain.":[497]}