Mechanically Driven Li Dendrite Penetration: A New Perspective on Resolving the “Soft‐Penetrates‐Hard” Paradox

{"Replacing":[0],"flammable":[1],"liquid":[2],"electrolytes":[3,9,33],"and":[4,10,59,85,113,160,182,204],"graphite":[5],"anodes":[6],"with":[7,186],"solid":[8],"lithium":[11,14,27],"metal,":[12],"all-solid-state":[13],"metal":[15],"batteries":[16],"offer":[17],"a":[18,104,115,154,187],"compelling":[19],"solution":[20],"for":[21,95,118,165,176],"next-generation":[22],"energy":[23],"storage":[24],"[1,2].However,":[25],"soft":[26],"dendrites":[28],"can":[29],"penetrate":[30],"hard":[31],"ceramic":[32],"(such":[34],"as":[35],"garnet-type":[36],"LLZTO),":[37],"causing":[38],"short":[39],"circuits-a":[40],"\\"soft-penetrates-hard\\"":[41],"paradox":[42],"that":[43,91,197,206],"has":[44,71],"long":[45],"puzzled":[46],"the":[47,51,68,92,129,132,142,177,195],"academic":[48],"community":[49],"[3,4].Regarding":[50],"mechanism,":[52,131],"two":[53],"main":[54],"hypotheses":[55],"exist:":[56],"\\"mechanical":[57],"fracture\\"":[58],"\\"electron-leakage-induced":[60],"front":[61],"nucleation,\\"":[62],"but":[63,103],"direct":[64,126],"nanoscale":[65,166],"evidence":[66,127],"at":[67,201],"dendrite":[69,97,119,158,207],"tip":[70,159],"been":[72],"lacking":[73],"[5,6].Recently,":[74],"Zhang":[75],"et":[76],"al.":[77],"[7]":[78],"employed":[79],"cryogenic":[80],"transmission":[81],"Kikuchi":[82],"diffraction":[83],"(cryo-TKD-SEM)":[84],"phase-field":[86],"fracture":[87,184],"modeling":[88],"to":[89,145],"demonstrate":[90],"driving":[93],"force":[94],"Li":[96],"penetration":[98,130,208],"is":[99,209],"not":[100,210],"plastic":[101],"flow":[102],"nearly":[105],"plasticity-free":[106],"high":[107],"hydrostatic":[108],"stress,":[109],"overturning":[110],"traditional":[111],"understanding":[112],"providing":[114,161],"new":[116],"strategy":[117],"deflection":[120],"through":[121],"defect":[122],"engineering.To":[123],"lock":[124],"in":[125],"of":[128,153,190],"authors":[133],"designed":[134],"an":[135,162],"in-plane":[136],"cell":[137],"geometry":[138],"(Figure":[139,173],"1A),":[140],"thinning":[141],"LLZTO":[143],"electrolyte":[144],"about":[146,191],"150":[147],"μm,":[148],"thus":[149],"enabling":[150],"precise":[151],"localization":[152],"single":[155],"straight":[156],"through-thickness":[157],"ideal":[163],"platform":[164],"characterization.Based":[167],"on":[168],"this":[169],"design,":[170],"EBSD":[171],"analysis":[172],"1B)":[174],"captured,":[175],"first":[178],"time,":[179],"both":[180],"intergranular":[181],"transgranular":[183,188],"modes,":[185],"proportion":[189],"20%,":[192],"directly":[193],"refuting":[194],"hypothesis":[196],"\\"Li":[198],"nucleates":[199],"only":[200],"grain":[202,213],"boundaries\\"":[203],"indicating":[205],"exclusively":[211],"along":[212],"boundaries.":[214]}

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Rare Metals
Published
2026-08-28
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1002/rar2.70589
Primary Topic
Advanced Battery Materials and Technologies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
article

Mechanically Driven Li Dendrite Penetration: A New Perspective on Resolving the “Soft‐Penetrates‐Hard” Paradox

Yizhao Zhao, Yuebin Xi
Rare Metals
Advanced Battery Materials and Technologies
article

Mechanically Driven Li Dendrite Penetration: A New Perspective on Resolving the “Soft‐Penetrates‐Hard” Paradox

Yizhao Zhao, Yuebin Xi
article en

Abstract

Replacing flammable liquid electrolytes and graphite anodes with solid electrolytes and lithium metal, all-solid-state lithium metal batteries offer a compelling solution for next-generation energy storage [1,2].However, soft lithium dendrites can penetrate hard ceramic electrolytes (such as garnet-type LLZTO), causing short circuits-a "soft-penetrates-hard" paradox that has long puzzled the academic community [3,4].Regarding the mechanism, two main hypotheses exist: "mechanical fracture" and "electron-leakage-induced front nucleation," but direct nanoscale evidence at the dendrite tip has been lacking [5,6].Recently, Zhang et al. [7] employed cryogenic transmission Kikuchi diffraction (cryo-TKD-SEM) and phase-field fracture modeling to demonstrate that the driving force for Li dendrite penetration is not plastic flow but a nearly plasticity-free high hydrostatic stress, overturning traditional understanding and providing a new strategy for dendrite deflection through defect engineering.To lock in direct evidence of the penetration mechanism, the authors designed an in-plane cell geometry (Figure 1A), thinning the LLZTO electrolyte to about 150 μm, thus enabling precise localization of a single straight through-thickness dendrite tip and providing an ideal platform for nanoscale characterization.Based on this design, EBSD analysis (Figure 1B) captured, for the first time, both intergranular and transgranular fracture modes, with a transgranular proportion of about 20%, directly refuting the hypothesis that "Li nucleates only at grain boundaries" and indicating that dendrite penetration is not exclusively along grain boundaries.

Rare MetalsVol. 45(9)
Qilu University of Technology (CN)
Natural Science Foundation of Shandong Province
Openalex Percentile: Top 19%
Advanced Battery Materials and Technologies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.