Cost-effectiveness evaluation of artificial intelligence-assisted chest radiograph interpretation for tuberculosis screening in rural health units in the Philippines

Tuberculosis remains a major public health burden in the Philippines, where diagnostic delays are amplified by limited radiology capacity in rural health units (RHUs) and geographically isolated and disadvantaged areas (GIDAs). Computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) using artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted chest radiograph interpretation may shorten the screening pathway and reduce reliance on scarce specialist readers. However, its economic value for RHU-based tuberculosis screening has not been fully evaluated. We developed a decision-tree cost-effectiveness model in Microsoft Excel 365 to compare AI-assisted chest radiograph interpretation with conventional manual radiologist or teleradiology interpretation among a theoretical annual cohort of 1,000 presumptive tuberculosis patients in RHU settings. The model adopted a provider perspective over a 5-year horizon, used 2026 Philippine pesos, and applied a base-case discount rate of 5%, with 3% and 7% explored in scenario analyses. Diagnostic performance inputs were derived from published CAD evaluations, while cost inputs were based on local program costing assumptions, public-sector salary and diagnostic cost estimates, and supplier quotations where available. Outcomes were expressed as additional true tuberculosis cases correctly detected, discounted incremental costs, and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). One-way, multi-way, and diagnostic-performance scenario analyses were conducted. In the base case, AI-assisted interpretation detected 90.22 true tuberculosis cases per 1,000 screened compared with 88.72 under manual interpretation, while reducing false-positive radiographs from 453.51 to 286.11. Annual costs were Php 877,330 for AI-assisted interpretation and Php 1,142,230 for manual interpretation. Over 5 years, the discounted incremental cost was Php − 946,878 and the discounted incremental effectiveness was 6.49 additional correctly detected tuberculosis cases, yielding a dominant ICER of Php − 145,803 per additional case detected. The base-case conclusion remained cost-saving under most deterministic sensitivity analyses. When a lower manual/teleradiology reading fee of Php 300 per scan or Philippine qXR pseudo-accuracy estimates were applied, AI-assisted interpretation was no longer cost-saving but remained more effective, emphasizing the importance of local calibration and budget-impact assessment. This decision-analytic model suggests that AI-assisted chest radiograph interpretation may be a cost-saving and more effective tuberculosis screening strategy for RHU settings under base-case assumptions, largely by reducing unnecessary confirmatory GeneXpert testing. The findings support pilot implementation and targeted evaluation in high-burden, underserved settings; however, national scale-up should be accompanied by local diagnostic validation, implementation monitoring, and budget-impact analysis.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
BMC Health Services Research
Published
2026-08-26
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-026-15449-3
Primary Topic
COVID-19 diagnosis using AI
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Cost-effectiveness evaluation of artificial intelligence-assisted chest radiograph interpretation for tuberculosis screening in rural health units in the Philippines

Bryan Christopher Lao, Harold Henrison Chiu, Gloanne C. Adolor
BMC Health Services Research
COVID-19 diagnosis using AI
article

Cost-effectiveness evaluation of artificial intelligence-assisted chest radiograph interpretation for tuberculosis screening in rural health units in the Philippines

Bryan Christopher Lao, Harold Henrison Chiu, Gloanne C. Adolor
article en

Abstract

Tuberculosis remains a major public health burden in the Philippines, where diagnostic delays are amplified by limited radiology capacity in rural health units (RHUs) and geographically isolated and disadvantaged areas (GIDAs). Computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) using artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted chest radiograph interpretation may shorten the screening pathway and reduce reliance on scarce specialist readers. However, its economic value for RHU-based tuberculosis screening has not been fully evaluated. We developed a decision-tree cost-effectiveness model in Microsoft Excel 365 to compare AI-assisted chest radiograph interpretation with conventional manual radiologist or teleradiology interpretation among a theoretical annual cohort of 1,000 presumptive tuberculosis patients in RHU settings. The model adopted a provider perspective over a 5-year horizon, used 2026 Philippine pesos, and applied a base-case discount rate of 5%, with 3% and 7% explored in scenario analyses. Diagnostic performance inputs were derived from published CAD evaluations, while cost inputs were based on local program costing assumptions, public-sector salary and diagnostic cost estimates, and supplier quotations where available. Outcomes were expressed as additional true tuberculosis cases correctly detected, discounted incremental costs, and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). One-way, multi-way, and diagnostic-performance scenario analyses were conducted. In the base case, AI-assisted interpretation detected 90.22 true tuberculosis cases per 1,000 screened compared with 88.72 under manual interpretation, while reducing false-positive radiographs from 453.51 to 286.11. Annual costs were Php 877,330 for AI-assisted interpretation and Php 1,142,230 for manual interpretation. Over 5 years, the discounted incremental cost was Php − 946,878 and the discounted incremental effectiveness was 6.49 additional correctly detected tuberculosis cases, yielding a dominant ICER of Php − 145,803 per additional case detected. The base-case conclusion remained cost-saving under most deterministic sensitivity analyses. When a lower manual/teleradiology reading fee of Php 300 per scan or Philippine qXR pseudo-accuracy estimates were applied, AI-assisted interpretation was no longer cost-saving but remained more effective, emphasizing the importance of local calibration and budget-impact assessment. This decision-analytic model suggests that AI-assisted chest radiograph interpretation may be a cost-saving and more effective tuberculosis screening strategy for RHU settings under base-case assumptions, largely by reducing unnecessary confirmatory GeneXpert testing. The findings support pilot implementation and targeted evaluation in high-burden, underserved settings; however, national scale-up should be accompanied by local diagnostic validation, implementation monitoring, and budget-impact analysis.

BMC Health Services Research
Ateneo de Manila University (PH), Lung Center of the Philippines (PH), Diabetes Australia (AU), Chinese General Hospital and Medical Center (PH), University of the Philippines Manila (PH), University of Santo Tomas (PH), University of the Philippines Diliman (PH)
Openalex Percentile: Top 11%
COVID-19 diagnosis using AI
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.