Comparative Technical and Economic Analysis of Heating Schemes for Rural Buildings

Currently, heating supply in rural areas of China still predominantly relies on conventional coal-fired heating, which suffers from poor thermal insulation performance and severe environmental pollution. To address the issues of energy waste and environmental pollution associated with traditional heating methods in rural China, this study selects a detached rural residential building in Jilin City as the research object. A building thermal load calculation model incorporating phase-change material (PCM) walls and dynamic simulation models for five clean heating coupling systems are developed using TRNSYS software, so as to analyze the influence of PCM placement at different positions within the wall assembly on the building’s thermal load, as well as the technical and economic performance of the five heating systems. The results show that, when PCM is placed on the inner side of the building envelope, the peak heating load is reduced from 15,234.2 W to 11,266.5 W, and the cumulative heating load drops from 33,744.3 kWh to 25,688.9 kWh. Compared with the conventional PV (photovoltaic) system, the PVT (photovoltaic–thermal) system achieves an 11% improvement in power generation efficiency. Among the five clean heating systems, the PVT–ground-source heat pump system exhibits the lowest energy consumption, while the PVT–biomass boiler system records the highest energy consumption. Based on life-cycle cost analysis, the PVT–biomass boiler system delivers the optimal economic performance, with a levelized annual cost of 9285.48 CNY.