Memory-based three-state model of competing technology adoption: Substitution regimes, multihoming, and churn

Technologies, products, platforms, and behavioral routines often compete through processes in which adoption is gradual, continued use requires reinforcement, and users may temporarily maintain more than one option. We formulate a homogeneous, well-mixed, three-state agent-based model of competition between an incumbent option (X) and a challenger option (Y). Agents are exclusive users of (X), exclusive users of (Y), or dual adopters (Z) who have both options available. Adoption is memory-based: an exclusive user adds the alternative only after accumulating enough adoption-relevant encounters within a finite learning window. Retention is also memory-based: a dual adopter continues to use both options only if each is sufficiently reinforced within a finite retention window. The central result is that this microscopic mechanism can reproduce aggregate usage signatures analogous to the four Adner–Kapoor technology-substitution regimes—creative destruction, robust coexistence, the illusion of resilience, and robust resilience—even though the model does not explicitly represent ecosystem emergence, ecosystem extension, complementors, prices, or strategic investment. Starting from the same small challenger seed, the four benchmark simulations differ only in post-entry mechanisms: adoption burden, retention burden, post-adoption usage preference, and the teaching role of dual adopters. Rolling usage shares reproduce aggregate substitution patterns analogous to the Adner–Kapoor regimes, while state-resolved trajectories and finite-horizon state-space projections reveal the underlying microscopic pathways. The simulations provide a mechanism-based possibility result: similar market-level substitution curves do not need to have unique causal interpretations. Ecosystem mechanisms may be essential in many empirical cases, but user-level finite-memory learning and retention alone can generate qualitatively similar aggregate regimes. The model therefore provides a compact baseline for linking technology-substitution trajectories to observable individual-level adoption, multi-homing, and discontinuance processes.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Physical review. E
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1103/cwj6-ygch
Primary Topic
Innovation Diffusion and Forecasting
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Memory-based three-state model of competing technology adoption: Substitution regimes, multihoming, and churn

Stefano Scialla, Marco Patriarca, Julyan H. E. Cartwright, Els Heinsalu
Physical review. E
Innovation Diffusion and Forecasting
article

Memory-based three-state model of competing technology adoption: Substitution regimes, multihoming, and churn

Stefano Scialla, Marco Patriarca, Julyan H. E. Cartwright, Els Heinsalu
article en

Abstract

Technologies, products, platforms, and behavioral routines often compete through processes in which adoption is gradual, continued use requires reinforcement, and users may temporarily maintain more than one option. We formulate a homogeneous, well-mixed, three-state agent-based model of competition between an incumbent option (X) and a challenger option (Y). Agents are exclusive users of (X), exclusive users of (Y), or dual adopters (Z) who have both options available. Adoption is memory-based: an exclusive user adds the alternative only after accumulating enough adoption-relevant encounters within a finite learning window. Retention is also memory-based: a dual adopter continues to use both options only if each is sufficiently reinforced within a finite retention window. The central result is that this microscopic mechanism can reproduce aggregate usage signatures analogous to the four Adner–Kapoor technology-substitution regimes—creative destruction, robust coexistence, the illusion of resilience, and robust resilience—even though the model does not explicitly represent ecosystem emergence, ecosystem extension, complementors, prices, or strategic investment. Starting from the same small challenger seed, the four benchmark simulations differ only in post-entry mechanisms: adoption burden, retention burden, post-adoption usage preference, and the teaching role of dual adopters. Rolling usage shares reproduce aggregate substitution patterns analogous to the Adner–Kapoor regimes, while state-resolved trajectories and finite-horizon state-space projections reveal the underlying microscopic pathways. The simulations provide a mechanism-based possibility result: similar market-level substitution curves do not need to have unique causal interpretations. Ecosystem mechanisms may be essential in many empirical cases, but user-level finite-memory learning and retention alone can generate qualitatively similar aggregate regimes. The model therefore provides a compact baseline for linking technology-substitution trajectories to observable individual-level adoption, multi-homing, and discontinuance processes.

Physical review. E
Innovation Diffusion and Forecasting
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon