Using P‐Mobilization Traits in Modern Maize Varieties for Optimizing the P Fertiliser Use Efficiency of Struvite Under P Limitation: First Evidence From a Pot and Field Trial

ABSTRACT Introduction Current recycling measures for closing the phosphorus (P) cycle are limited by the lower fertiliser use efficiencies of recycled products. Increasing P use efficiency (PUE) through maize genotype selection and management may offer a sustainable solution, but the potential of variety choice and its interaction with placed fertilisation for enhancing recycled fertilisers' efficiency remains unclear. Material and Methods Four maize genotypes differing in P efficiency were tested in a pot trial, where microbial P, phosphatase activity, and Olsen‐P were measured and their links to PUE were investigated. Three of these genotypes were examined in a two year field trial comparing two fertiliser types (diammonium phosphate (DAP); struvite) and application methods (broadcast vs. placed). Results Stabil showed higher microbial biomass P and LG_30258 higher phosphatase activity than other varieties. Although not significant, the PUE, expressed as biomass divided by fertilisation, varied among genotypes ( Amaroc 3.4 x higher than Ricardinio ). In the field, no genotype × management interaction was detected and genotypic differences became minimal ( LG_30258 1.4 x higher than Stabil ). Struvite performed comparably to DAP across both years, while fertiliser placement only increased biomass and P offtake in the drier year, 2022. P mobilisation traits could not predict PUE, however, P offtake in the pot and field trial followed the same ranking order as the P mobilization traits. Conclusion This study highlights that the slow‐release fertiliser, struvite, has a comparable fertiliser efficiency than DAP, and fertiliser placement can further enhance PUE in dry seasons, independent of the fertiliser source. Although slight genotypic variance in P mobilisation exists in modern maize varieties and can predict P responsiveness, the influence of genotype choice and management options appeared additive rather than synergistic since genotype x management interaction was not significant. Future research should further explore how to exploit synergies between genotypes, management, and fertilisers.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment
Published
2026-08-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1002/sae2.70202
Primary Topic
Phosphorus and nutrient management
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
article

Using P‐Mobilization Traits in Modern Maize Varieties for Optimizing the P Fertiliser Use Efficiency of Struvite Under P Limitation: First Evidence From a Pot and Field Trial

Michelle Natalie Herrmann, Peteh Mehdi Nkebiwe, Daniel J. Wanke, Torsten Müller
Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and Environment
Phosphorus and nutrient management
article

Using P‐Mobilization Traits in Modern Maize Varieties for Optimizing the P Fertiliser Use Efficiency of Struvite Under P Limitation: First Evidence From a Pot and Field Trial

Michelle Natalie Herrmann, Peteh Mehdi Nkebiwe, Daniel J. Wanke, Torsten Müller
article en

Abstract

ABSTRACT Introduction Current recycling measures for closing the phosphorus (P) cycle are limited by the lower fertiliser use efficiencies of recycled products. Increasing P use efficiency (PUE) through maize genotype selection and management may offer a sustainable solution, but the potential of variety choice and its interaction with placed fertilisation for enhancing recycled fertilisers' efficiency remains unclear. Material and Methods Four maize genotypes differing in P efficiency were tested in a pot trial, where microbial P, phosphatase activity, and Olsen‐P were measured and their links to PUE were investigated. Three of these genotypes were examined in a two year field trial comparing two fertiliser types (diammonium phosphate (DAP); struvite) and application methods (broadcast vs. placed). Results Stabil showed higher microbial biomass P and LG_30258 higher phosphatase activity than other varieties. Although not significant, the PUE, expressed as biomass divided by fertilisation, varied among genotypes ( Amaroc 3.4 x higher than Ricardinio ). In the field, no genotype × management interaction was detected and genotypic differences became minimal ( LG_30258 1.4 x higher than Stabil ). Struvite performed comparably to DAP across both years, while fertiliser placement only increased biomass and P offtake in the drier year, 2022. P mobilisation traits could not predict PUE, however, P offtake in the pot and field trial followed the same ranking order as the P mobilization traits. Conclusion This study highlights that the slow‐release fertiliser, struvite, has a comparable fertiliser efficiency than DAP, and fertiliser placement can further enhance PUE in dry seasons, independent of the fertiliser source. Although slight genotypic variance in P mobilisation exists in modern maize varieties and can predict P responsiveness, the influence of genotype choice and management options appeared additive rather than synergistic since genotype x management interaction was not significant. Future research should further explore how to exploit synergies between genotypes, management, and fertilisers.

Journal of Sustainable Agriculture and EnvironmentVol. 5(3)
University of Hohenheim (DE)
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft
Responsible consumption and production
Openalex Percentile: Top 10%
Phosphorus and nutrient management
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.