Scoping when bit length of molecular fingerprints determines the reliability of computational tools in environmental chemistry and toxicology

Many modern computational tools to describe or predict the behaviour of organic chemicals rely on molecular fingerprints. Fingerprints are used as descriptors for structure-activity relationship modelling and structure-based clustering of chemicals across the fields of environmental chemistry, technology and (eco)toxicology. Here, we highlight how Extended Connectivity Fingerprint (ECFP), RDKit fingerprint, Atom Pair fingerprint, and Torsion fingerprint, among others, are susceptible to "bit collisions", which result in the same fingerprint for different molecular structures in a given dataset. Bit collisions can be introduced during hashing, where two distinct fragments result in the same hash, or more commonly, where the folding operation assigns two different structures to the same bit index. These collisions can occur at the molecular level, where two distinct substructures in a molecule collide, or at the dataset level, where collisions occur due to molecular aggregation. Using two curated datasets (pesticide degradation and global chemical inventory data), we show that bit collision is inversely related to the bit size of fingerprints and is more pronounced in Atom Pair and RDKit fingerprints compared to ECFP and Torsion fingerprints. In addition, molecular size and atom count are positively related to bit collisions. At the widely used ECFP4 with a bit length of 1024, bit collisions occurred for approximately 50% of the molecules in both tested datasets. Finally, we showcase how bit collisions can be detrimental for predictive modelling of targets with high certainty, such as hydrophobicity, while their effect is less visible for more uncertain and "noisy" targets such as persistence. Overall, this study provides guidance on fingerprint and bit size selection for predictive modelling in environmental chemistry, ecotoxicology and environmental technology.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Environmental Science Processes & Impacts
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1039/d6em00634e
Primary Topic
Computational Drug Discovery Methods
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Scoping when bit length of molecular fingerprints determines the reliability of computational tools in environmental chemistry and toxicology

Gabriel Sigmund, Daniel Probst, Miko Doeze-Jager, Eros Reij
3 links
Environmental Science Processes & Impacts
Computational Drug Discovery Methods
article

Scoping when bit length of molecular fingerprints determines the reliability of computational tools in environmental chemistry and toxicology

Gabriel Sigmund, Daniel Probst, Miko Doeze-Jager, Eros Reij
article en

Abstract

Many modern computational tools to describe or predict the behaviour of organic chemicals rely on molecular fingerprints. Fingerprints are used as descriptors for structure-activity relationship modelling and structure-based clustering of chemicals across the fields of environmental chemistry, technology and (eco)toxicology. Here, we highlight how Extended Connectivity Fingerprint (ECFP), RDKit fingerprint, Atom Pair fingerprint, and Torsion fingerprint, among others, are susceptible to "bit collisions", which result in the same fingerprint for different molecular structures in a given dataset. Bit collisions can be introduced during hashing, where two distinct fragments result in the same hash, or more commonly, where the folding operation assigns two different structures to the same bit index. These collisions can occur at the molecular level, where two distinct substructures in a molecule collide, or at the dataset level, where collisions occur due to molecular aggregation. Using two curated datasets (pesticide degradation and global chemical inventory data), we show that bit collision is inversely related to the bit size of fingerprints and is more pronounced in Atom Pair and RDKit fingerprints compared to ECFP and Torsion fingerprints. In addition, molecular size and atom count are positively related to bit collisions. At the widely used ECFP4 with a bit length of 1024, bit collisions occurred for approximately 50% of the molecules in both tested datasets. Finally, we showcase how bit collisions can be detrimental for predictive modelling of targets with high certainty, such as hydrophobicity, while their effect is less visible for more uncertain and "noisy" targets such as persistence. Overall, this study provides guidance on fingerprint and bit size selection for predictive modelling in environmental chemistry, ecotoxicology and environmental technology.

Environmental Science Processes & ImpactsVol. 28(11)
Wageningen University & Research (NL)
Computational Drug Discovery Methods
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon