DNR Status and Hospital Mortality Measures Postmyocardial Infarction: Differentiating Preventable From Unpreventable Deaths in CMS Data

BACKGROUND: Publicly reported 30-day acute myocardial infarction (AMI) mortality rates are widely used to benchmark hospital performance. However, these measures may lack validity when they include deaths among patients with do-not-resuscitate (DNR) orders or those receiving palliative care-groups for whom mortality may be expected and goal-concordant. METHODS: We analyzed the national 100% Medicare Inpatient Standard Analytic File and Medicare Beneficiary Summary file to assess 30-day AMI mortality rates stratified by DNR status (absent, present-on-admission, and postadmission) and palliative care involvement. We then conducted a retrospective chart review of all 30-day AMI mortalities at a single academic medical center (2019-2025), applying Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events and a Palliative Performance Scale scores to identify unpreventable deaths, which we defined as a Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events >190.5 or Palliative Performance Scale ≤40%. Global Registry of Acute Coronary Events is a risk-stratification tool using clinical and laboratory variables whereas the Palliative Performance Scale is a bedside functional status and palliative care assessment quantifying patient's self-care ability. RESULTS: Across n=467 259 total AMI encounters, mean (SD) age was 75.1 (10.5), and the population was 44% female. Thirty-day mortality was 10.4% (39 112/376 062) among patients without DNRs, 43.1% (26 181/60 719) in those with present-on-admission DNR, and 72.1% (21 984/30 478) in those with postadmission DNR. Among 9.2% (43 090/467 259) of encounters with palliative care, there was a 76.9% mortality rate (33 151/43 090). Hazard ratios for mortality were 5.25 (95% CI, 5.17-5.33) for present-on-admission DNR and 10.73 (95% CI, 10.55-10.91) for postadmission DNR as compared with encounters without DNRs. Among n=24 AMI mortalities at our institution, 71% (17/24) had DNRs, and 33% (8/24) met the unpreventable death criteria. CONCLUSIONS: The validity of 30-day AMI mortality metrics may be undermined by their inclusion of high-acuity, end-of-life patients, which may disincentivize hospitals from delivering appropriate, patient-centered care. Removal of DNR or palliative cases from performance measures should be explored to better identify opportunities for reducing preventable deaths.