Evidence of Growth Overfishing of Striped Mullet (Mugil cephalus) and White Mullet (Mugil curema) at the Mouth of the Soto La Marina River, Within the Laguna Madre Protected Area in the Gulf of Mexico: A Data-Limited Diagnosis in a High-Priority Cons

The striped mullet (Mugil cephalus) and white mullet (Mugil curema) support artisanal fishing at the mouth of the Soto La Marina River, Gulf of Mexico, an area of great ecological value within the Laguna Madre and Rio Bravo Delta Protected Natural Area, the Terrestrial Priority Region RTP-83, and the Marine Priority Region RMP-44. Given the absence of historical catch and effort time series—a typical constraint of data-limited fisheries—a length-based frequency approach was used to estimate growth parameters, mortality rates, and the exploitation rate (E = F/Z). During 2018–2019, 1134 specimens of M. cephalus and 339 of M. curema were sampled. Due to sexual dimorphism in M. cephalus, analyses were performed separately for females, males, and combined sexes, while M. curema was analyzed with sexes combined. Growth (L∞, k) and mortality (Z, M, F) parameters for combined sexes were: M. cephalus (562 mm, 0.14 year−1; 3.72, 0.21, 3.51 year−1) and M. curema (329 mm, 0.15 year−1; 1.46, 0.25, 1.21 year−1). Exploitation rates (E) substantially exceeded Gulland (E = 0.5) and Patterson (E = 0.4) reference points: M. cephalus females (0.891), males (0.915), combined sexes (0.944), and M. curema (0.828). It is concluded that both stocks show strong evidence of growth overfishing, with exploitation rates well above established reference points, revealing a disconnect between the area’s conservation designations and the actual condition of the resource.