Post-ICSI oocyte degeneration inflates the conventional blastocyst utilization rate: degeneration-penalized and MII-anchored denominator corrections

Abstract Purpose. Conventional IVF laboratory key performance indicators (KPIs) are reported as single (“sole”) ratios in which the denominator excludes mature oocytes lost to the procedure. We tested whether the blastocyst utilization rate overstates true performance by masking post-ICSI oocyte degeneration, and we developed two complementary corrections that put degeneration back into the denominator. Methods. Retrospective analysis of a single pooled ICSI cohort of 7,216 cycles and 56,349 MII oocytes. Against the conventional blastocyst utilization rate (BUR = Frozen/2PN), we defined: a Degeneration-Penalized BUR (DP-BUR) that adds the degenerated oocytes back to the denominator — additive, Frozen/(2PN + ATR), and multiplicative, (Frozen/2PN) × (1 − ATR/MII) — and a True BUR (TBUR = Frozen/MII) anchored to all mature oocytes. Degeneration was stratified at < 5% versus ≥ 5%. We assessed each metric against a competence benchmark of 40% (blastocysts utilization rate) and quantified operator-level misclassification (operators anonymized). Results. Conventional BUR was 41.9; DP-BUR was 40.2 (additive) and 40.5 (multiplicative); TBUR was 32.8 — bracketing the correction, with DP-BUR attributing the gap to degeneration alone (+ 4% over the true value) and TBUR to all mature-oocyte attrition (+ 28%). The corrections were degeneration-dependent and, for DP-BUR, degeneration-specific: from < 5% to ≥ 5% degeneration, DP-BUR fell from 54.4% to 42.7% while conventional BUR barely moved (54.6%→52.0%), so DP-BUR is essentially flat where degeneration is low and drops only where it is high; TBUR fell 46.1%→38.4%. Against a benchmark of 40%, conventional BUR passed 24 of 38 operators, DP-BUR passed 17 (7 flipped from pass to fail), and TBUR passed 7 (17 flipped). Two cycles with identical mature-oocyte and fertilization counts but different degeneration are scored identically by both conventional BUR and TBUR, and are separated only by DP-BUR. Conclusions. Conventional blastocyst utilization overstates true performance in proportion to the degeneration it hides. A degeneration-penalized denominator (DP-BUR) isolates operator-induced oocyte damage, while an MII-anchored denominator (TBUR) reports true yield from biological starting material; both pass operators and laboratories that an honest accounting would fail.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics
Published
2026-11-14
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10815-026-04075-x
Primary Topic
Reproductive Biology and Fertility
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Post-ICSI oocyte degeneration inflates the conventional blastocyst utilization rate: degeneration-penalized and MII-anchored denominator corrections

Tuba Düzcü, Emrah Önder, İbrahim Orçun Olcay, Mustafa Bahçeci et al.
1 links
Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics
Reproductive Biology and Fertility
article

Post-ICSI oocyte degeneration inflates the conventional blastocyst utilization rate: degeneration-penalized and MII-anchored denominator corrections

Tuba Düzcü, Emrah Önder, İbrahim Orçun Olcay, Mustafa Bahçeci, Aydin M. Arici, Murat Basar, Ozcan Duzcu
article en

Abstract

Abstract Purpose. Conventional IVF laboratory key performance indicators (KPIs) are reported as single (“sole”) ratios in which the denominator excludes mature oocytes lost to the procedure. We tested whether the blastocyst utilization rate overstates true performance by masking post-ICSI oocyte degeneration, and we developed two complementary corrections that put degeneration back into the denominator. Methods. Retrospective analysis of a single pooled ICSI cohort of 7,216 cycles and 56,349 MII oocytes. Against the conventional blastocyst utilization rate (BUR = Frozen/2PN), we defined: a Degeneration-Penalized BUR (DP-BUR) that adds the degenerated oocytes back to the denominator — additive, Frozen/(2PN + ATR), and multiplicative, (Frozen/2PN) × (1 − ATR/MII) — and a True BUR (TBUR = Frozen/MII) anchored to all mature oocytes. Degeneration was stratified at < 5% versus ≥ 5%. We assessed each metric against a competence benchmark of 40% (blastocysts utilization rate) and quantified operator-level misclassification (operators anonymized). Results. Conventional BUR was 41.9; DP-BUR was 40.2 (additive) and 40.5 (multiplicative); TBUR was 32.8 — bracketing the correction, with DP-BUR attributing the gap to degeneration alone (+ 4% over the true value) and TBUR to all mature-oocyte attrition (+ 28%). The corrections were degeneration-dependent and, for DP-BUR, degeneration-specific: from < 5% to ≥ 5% degeneration, DP-BUR fell from 54.4% to 42.7% while conventional BUR barely moved (54.6%→52.0%), so DP-BUR is essentially flat where degeneration is low and drops only where it is high; TBUR fell 46.1%→38.4%. Against a benchmark of 40%, conventional BUR passed 24 of 38 operators, DP-BUR passed 17 (7 flipped from pass to fail), and TBUR passed 7 (17 flipped). Two cycles with identical mature-oocyte and fertilization counts but different degeneration are scored identically by both conventional BUR and TBUR, and are separated only by DP-BUR. Conclusions. Conventional blastocyst utilization overstates true performance in proportion to the degeneration it hides. A degeneration-penalized denominator (DP-BUR) isolates operator-induced oocyte damage, while an MII-anchored denominator (TBUR) reports true yield from biological starting material; both pass operators and laboratories that an honest accounting would fail.

Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics
Istanbul Medipol University (TR), Yale University (US), Istanbul Commerce University (TR)
Good health and well-being
Reproductive Biology and Fertility
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon