An Algebraic Resolution of the Firewall Paradox

The AMPS firewall argument relies on treating early radiation, late outgoing Hawking modes, and interior partner modes as approximately independent quantum subsystems. In diffeomorphism-invariant quantum gravity, however, gravitational dressing and asymptotic constraints obstruct such a tensor-product factorization of physical observables. In this essay, we sharpen this obstruction by formulating subsystem independence directly in operator-algebraic terms. Using modular theory, half-sided modular inclusions along null directions, and the sector-wise maximality of the dressed radiation algebra at future null infinity, we show that—within a fixed asymptotic charge sector—the algebra associated with the interior Hawking partner cannot form an independent commuting subalgebra, but must be contained as a (non-commuting) subalgebra of the radiation algebra itself. The subsystem-independence assumption underlying the AMPS paradox therefore fails, and the entanglement-monogamy step never becomes applicable. As a result, unitary black hole evaporation and semiclassical horizon smoothness are compatible in asymptotically flat quantum gravity, without invoking entanglement islands, replica wormholes, or modifications of semiclassical horizon physics.