When does modelling dependence change the interpretation of biodiversity indicators?

Recent biodiversity trend analyses have modelled uncertainty arising from temporal, spatial and phylogenetic dependence. For primarily descriptive indicators such as the Living Planet Indices (LPIs) however, a prior question is whether dependence modelling improves estimation of a fixed quantity or actually changes the quantity being reported. Using the high‐profile case of Johnson et al., the current paper argues that covariance‐rich hierarchical models can make the relationship between a reported model coefficient and an intended estimand ambiguous. When aggregate trends are estimated from common coefficients in latent models with structured covariance, observations contribute unequal independent information to the estimator through assumed redundancy among related units. The reported collective trend is then a model‐based coefficient (e.g. a mean over a latent‐effect distribution) shaped by partial pooling and dependence; this is not automatically an average under declared estimand or ‘aggregation’ weights that indicator trend users may assume. A further ambiguity is whether the reported coefficient summarises the analysed sample or supports claims about a broader spatial, taxonomic or other policy‐relevant domain. One defensible reply, that the model is merely a more efficient estimator of a sample average, requires explicit statement of the estimand, weighting scheme, relationship between the model output and that estimand, and evidence of performance for that target; predictive success alone is not sufficient for this descriptive claim. Claims concerning broader generalisability require accompanying risk‐of‐bias assessments where evaluation against the true target (e.g. a time trend in some facet of global biodiversity) is unobtainable. The implication is that covariance‐rich hierarchical indicator analyses should state the estimand, the role of dependence modelling, missing data assumptions and domain of inference clearly before interpreting the resulting trend for scientific or policy applications.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1111/2041-210x.70447
Primary Topic
Statistical Methods and Bayesian Inference
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

When does modelling dependence change the interpretation of biodiversity indicators?

Oliver L. Pescott
1 links
Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Statistical Methods and Bayesian Inference
article

When does modelling dependence change the interpretation of biodiversity indicators?

Oliver L. Pescott
article en

Abstract

Recent biodiversity trend analyses have modelled uncertainty arising from temporal, spatial and phylogenetic dependence. For primarily descriptive indicators such as the Living Planet Indices (LPIs) however, a prior question is whether dependence modelling improves estimation of a fixed quantity or actually changes the quantity being reported. Using the high‐profile case of Johnson et al., the current paper argues that covariance‐rich hierarchical models can make the relationship between a reported model coefficient and an intended estimand ambiguous. When aggregate trends are estimated from common coefficients in latent models with structured covariance, observations contribute unequal independent information to the estimator through assumed redundancy among related units. The reported collective trend is then a model‐based coefficient (e.g. a mean over a latent‐effect distribution) shaped by partial pooling and dependence; this is not automatically an average under declared estimand or ‘aggregation’ weights that indicator trend users may assume. A further ambiguity is whether the reported coefficient summarises the analysed sample or supports claims about a broader spatial, taxonomic or other policy‐relevant domain. One defensible reply, that the model is merely a more efficient estimator of a sample average, requires explicit statement of the estimand, weighting scheme, relationship between the model output and that estimand, and evidence of performance for that target; predictive success alone is not sufficient for this descriptive claim. Claims concerning broader generalisability require accompanying risk‐of‐bias assessments where evaluation against the true target (e.g. a time trend in some facet of global biodiversity) is unobtainable. The implication is that covariance‐rich hierarchical indicator analyses should state the estimand, the role of dependence modelling, missing data assumptions and domain of inference clearly before interpreting the resulting trend for scientific or policy applications.

Methods in Ecology and Evolution
UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology (GB)
Natural Environment Research Council
Statistical Methods and Bayesian Inference
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon