When errors become etched in stone: The U.S. Navy's deeply flawed, never retracted World War II asbestos epidemiology study

In January 1946, the Journal of Industrial Hygiene and Toxicology published "A Health Survey of Pipe Covering Operations in Constructing Naval Vessels." This cross-sectional epidemiological study is one of the most consequential in the history of industrial hygiene and occupational medicine as it errantly concluded that insulation work on ships using asbestos-containing materials was "…not a dangerous occupation." As a consequence of this innocuous conclusion, the U.S. Navy and others neglected to protect insulators and other employees from asbestos dust for the next 25 years, leading to an epidemic of asbestos-related diseases in active and retired workers. Subsequently, attorneys and expert witnesses used this exculpating conclusion to mount "state of the art/science" defenses for asbestos manufacturers in tort actions, arguing that their clients relied on this publication when they failed to protect their own employees from asbestos or warn their customers of the hazard. Both the industrial hygiene and the medical components of this study were deeply flawed. The successor publisher to the original journal has refused to consider retracting this paper, so this catastrophic blunder may remain a part of the literature, available to asbestos tort defense attorneys and their experts. Publishing industry policies and precedent related to retracting very old articles are reviewed.